SOUTH Asia has had few opportunities to celebrate its diversity.
Instead, what we have heard are voices of concern about the treatment of
minorities in the region. At Tuesday`s Regional Conference on the
Rights of Religious Minorities in South Asia, held in Islamabad,
speakers deplored the treatment meted out to marginalised religious
communities in South Asia. A speaker from India said the way Hindus
treated Muslims in his country was linked to the Pakistani penchant for
going after the minority Hindu community. He was happy to note that
people belonging to all religions believed in Mahatma Gandhi. But
unfortunately, httle appears to have been said about how putting faith
in the non-violent Mahatma is useful for the targeted. A Pakistani Hindu
was of the view that Pakistan was as much his country as anybody
else`s.
Yet the reality could be gauged from his account of cases
of unending persecution of Pakistan`s Hindus.In much the same vein, a
Pakistani Christian talked of his community`s contribution to the
country`s progress but eventually it is the sad comparison the present
offers with the past that puts the national journey in doubt. The
Mahatmas, the rights activists and the natural instinct for tolerance
notwithstanding, the picture is dismal overall.
One consensus
coming out of the meeting was that all religions abhor violence. The
special reference to Islam was unavoidable given how its name has been
used for a violent cleansing exercise from Tirah to Timbuktu. That point
inevitably leads to reflections about the protective and trendsetting
roles of the state which, today, is quite inseparable from religion. `No
nonMuslim ambassador or federal secretary ... Hindus barred from the
atomic energy commission. .
the state has, in fact, failed its minorities, and failed to set an example of tolerance for all its people.
Thursday, July 5, 2012
Nato supplies deal
AFTER seven months of obstinacy by both sides, and a year and a half of
tensions between the US and Pakistan, the reopening of Nato supply
routes holds in it the promise of a turning point in the relationship.
Whether through a recognition of our increasing international isolation,
a desire to be involved in the future of Afghanistan, or simply a
realisation of the limited power Pakistan really had in these
negotiations, the Pakistani civilian and military leaderships have
finally demonstrated a willingness to compromise despite hurt
sensitivities and political pressure at home. In return, the US needs to
be extremely conscious of Pakistani sovereignty going forward,
including when it comes to the unilateral use of drone attacks. If both
sides grasp the opportunity this moment presents, it could help turn a
dysfunctional relationship into one that can actually help solve the
region`s security problems.
In fact, the most significant advantage Pakistan could derive from this moment is to start reversing the reputation it has developed of being an obstacle to peace in the region. The outcome of the talks has shown Pakistan did not gain much else from miscalculating the leverage it really had and then sticking stubbornly to that calculation. We have managed to obtain an apology though some argue it wasn`t formal or directenough but not much else is different seven months later. There will be no transit fees, Pakistan had to say mistakes were made by both sides a significant step back from the earlier position that the Americans attacked Pakistani soldiers deliberately and the coalition support funds that will now come through represent overdue reimbursements for money already spent and will not solve the ongoing issues that come up every year with processing CSF payments.
In the process, we have risked our reputation with the other Isaf countries as well. The lesson from all this should be that a concern for Pakistani sovereignty has to be balanced with the need to play a constructive, cooperative role in the region.
Aside from sorting out lingering issues with America, particularly counterterrorism cooperation, the task at home now is to rein in any violent right-wing reactions. The right was encouraged when public anger was needed as evidence of Pakistan`s political constraints, and by the same token it can probably be controlled now that a deal has been struck. But the risk with fostering intolerant forces is that they cannot always be managed. The Taliban, too, have said they will retaliate. It is now the security forces` responsibility to make sure that truckers, and the communities that they pass through, remain safe.
In fact, the most significant advantage Pakistan could derive from this moment is to start reversing the reputation it has developed of being an obstacle to peace in the region. The outcome of the talks has shown Pakistan did not gain much else from miscalculating the leverage it really had and then sticking stubbornly to that calculation. We have managed to obtain an apology though some argue it wasn`t formal or directenough but not much else is different seven months later. There will be no transit fees, Pakistan had to say mistakes were made by both sides a significant step back from the earlier position that the Americans attacked Pakistani soldiers deliberately and the coalition support funds that will now come through represent overdue reimbursements for money already spent and will not solve the ongoing issues that come up every year with processing CSF payments.
In the process, we have risked our reputation with the other Isaf countries as well. The lesson from all this should be that a concern for Pakistani sovereignty has to be balanced with the need to play a constructive, cooperative role in the region.
Aside from sorting out lingering issues with America, particularly counterterrorism cooperation, the task at home now is to rein in any violent right-wing reactions. The right was encouraged when public anger was needed as evidence of Pakistan`s political constraints, and by the same token it can probably be controlled now that a deal has been struck. But the risk with fostering intolerant forces is that they cannot always be managed. The Taliban, too, have said they will retaliate. It is now the security forces` responsibility to make sure that truckers, and the communities that they pass through, remain safe.
`US respects people`s aspirations` No secret deal with US: Khar
SLAMABAD, July 4: Foreign Minister Hina Rabbani Khar denied on Wednesday
any secret deal for reopening Nato supply routes and insisted that the
American `sorry` showed their respect for aspirations of the people of
Pakistan.
`I can today tell the people of Pakistan that US respects their aspirations as stated by the parliamentary recommendations,` Ms Khar said at a reception at the US embassy to celebrate America`s 236th Independence Day.
She described the breakthrough in ties as a `turning point` and hoped that the new beginning would translate into a strong friendship.
US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said `sorry` on Tuesdayfor the deaths of24 Pakistani troops killed in a border post attack to secure resumption of Nato supplies. Pakistan was further assured that there would be no repeat of Salalatype incidents, but the agreement did not touch upon several other parliamentary demands, including cessation of drone attacks.
The government ministers, anticipating a strong backlash by the opposition, however, made it a point to emphasise that the deal was in accordance with the April 12 parliamentary resolution on new terms of engagement with the US.
The foreign minister, who looked upbeat over Tuesday`s developments that led to the reopening of supply routes, also said she expected that the two coun-tries could convert the insurmountable challenges in their relationship into new opportunities. She noted that there was no other option but to work together.
The foreign minister further said that the progress achieved so far would now help the two countries to engage seriously on other issues.
Ambassador Cameron Munter, who will soon be leaving Islamabad, in his brief comments wished that Pakistan would keep its promise to achieve the promise made to it by the US.
Earlier in the day, Ms Khar said there was no `secret agreement` with the US to end the seven-month long suspension of supply routes.
She rather contended that the US had to `back down`
`I can today tell the people of Pakistan that US respects their aspirations as stated by the parliamentary recommendations,` Ms Khar said at a reception at the US embassy to celebrate America`s 236th Independence Day.
She described the breakthrough in ties as a `turning point` and hoped that the new beginning would translate into a strong friendship.
US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said `sorry` on Tuesdayfor the deaths of24 Pakistani troops killed in a border post attack to secure resumption of Nato supplies. Pakistan was further assured that there would be no repeat of Salalatype incidents, but the agreement did not touch upon several other parliamentary demands, including cessation of drone attacks.
The government ministers, anticipating a strong backlash by the opposition, however, made it a point to emphasise that the deal was in accordance with the April 12 parliamentary resolution on new terms of engagement with the US.
The foreign minister, who looked upbeat over Tuesday`s developments that led to the reopening of supply routes, also said she expected that the two coun-tries could convert the insurmountable challenges in their relationship into new opportunities. She noted that there was no other option but to work together.
The foreign minister further said that the progress achieved so far would now help the two countries to engage seriously on other issues.
Ambassador Cameron Munter, who will soon be leaving Islamabad, in his brief comments wished that Pakistan would keep its promise to achieve the promise made to it by the US.
Earlier in the day, Ms Khar said there was no `secret agreement` with the US to end the seven-month long suspension of supply routes.
She rather contended that the US had to `back down`
2,000 booked for burning `blasphemer` to death
BAHAWALPUR, July 4: Police registered on Wednesday an FIR against about 2,000 men for killing a man, causing injuries to eight police personnel, rioting and torching a police station, four residential quarters and four police vehicles in Channigoth on the outskirts of Bahawalpur.
SHO Ghulam Mohyuddin of Channigoth told Dawn by phone the FIR had been lodged under sections 302, 395 PPC and 7 section of AntiTerrorism Act (ATA).
He said none of the accused had been named in the FIR and no arrest had been made.
ThecaseisaboutaTuesday night incident when hundreds of people attacked the Channigoth police station where a man had been detained for allegedly desecrating the Holy Quran.
The mob set the police station on fire, started beating the man and dragged him to an open place and set him on fire. The crowd watched as the man known as Malang (insane) kept screaming for help.
The fire destroyed parts of the police station and four police vehicles.
Malang had been detained on information about the alleged `blasphemous` act.
Police used teargas and fired in the air but failed to disperse the charged crowd.
According to sources, a heavy contingent of police and elite force had been sent to the town from Bahawalpur and Liaquatpur to help local police.
But before it reached the place the mob had entered the police station and overpowered the two constables guarding the lock-up.
SHO Ghulam Mohyuddin of Channigoth told Dawn by phone the FIR had been lodged under sections 302, 395 PPC and 7 section of AntiTerrorism Act (ATA).
He said none of the accused had been named in the FIR and no arrest had been made.
ThecaseisaboutaTuesday night incident when hundreds of people attacked the Channigoth police station where a man had been detained for allegedly desecrating the Holy Quran.
The mob set the police station on fire, started beating the man and dragged him to an open place and set him on fire. The crowd watched as the man known as Malang (insane) kept screaming for help.
The fire destroyed parts of the police station and four police vehicles.
Malang had been detained on information about the alleged `blasphemous` act.
Police used teargas and fired in the air but failed to disperse the charged crowd.
According to sources, a heavy contingent of police and elite force had been sent to the town from Bahawalpur and Liaquatpur to help local police.
But before it reached the place the mob had entered the police station and overpowered the two constables guarding the lock-up.
Wednesday, July 4, 2012
THE annual inflation number has been released
THE annual inflation number has been released, and it is a moment for cautious optimism with the emphasis being on caution.
If official statistics are to be believed and there is some concern that technical changes made this fiscal year now understate price increases the consumer price index stood at 11 per cent this year, down from 13.7 per cent in 201011. Given the inflation in the mid-20s that persisted in the current government`s first year in office, the administration should be credited for bringing an alarmingly high number broadly under control. And in recent months it has successfully passed on reductions in global commodity prices to consumers. But the achievement also needs to be put into perspective. For one, much of the decline in inflation is due to global price declines, especially those of oil and certain food items, rather than improvements on the domestic front. And inflation still remains stubbornly in the double digits for the fifth year running, a reality borne out by the common complaint among citizens that even basic needs, including food, fuel,electricity and transport, remain hard to meet.
Even more worrying is the persistence of the fundamental issues behind this problem, which remain in place and are getting worse. The State Bank recently pointed out that inflation remains high because of continued, and continually increasing, government borrowing, itself a function of the growing fiscal deficit. And the new budget doesn`t inspire confidence that the required belt-tightening will take place, at least not before the next elections.
The recent expansion of the cabinet and the hike in salaries and pensions of government employees are just a couple of indications of how politics continues to trump sound economic management, even as the fiscal deficit for 2011-12 will likely come in at nearly eight per cent. Add to that a low tax-to-GDP ratio, electricity and other subsidies, and the losses racked up by public-sector enterprises, as well as a precarious external accounts position that is weakening the rupee and making imports more expensive, and the outlook for inflation doesn`t look bright.
If official statistics are to be believed and there is some concern that technical changes made this fiscal year now understate price increases the consumer price index stood at 11 per cent this year, down from 13.7 per cent in 201011. Given the inflation in the mid-20s that persisted in the current government`s first year in office, the administration should be credited for bringing an alarmingly high number broadly under control. And in recent months it has successfully passed on reductions in global commodity prices to consumers. But the achievement also needs to be put into perspective. For one, much of the decline in inflation is due to global price declines, especially those of oil and certain food items, rather than improvements on the domestic front. And inflation still remains stubbornly in the double digits for the fifth year running, a reality borne out by the common complaint among citizens that even basic needs, including food, fuel,electricity and transport, remain hard to meet.
Even more worrying is the persistence of the fundamental issues behind this problem, which remain in place and are getting worse. The State Bank recently pointed out that inflation remains high because of continued, and continually increasing, government borrowing, itself a function of the growing fiscal deficit. And the new budget doesn`t inspire confidence that the required belt-tightening will take place, at least not before the next elections.
The recent expansion of the cabinet and the hike in salaries and pensions of government employees are just a couple of indications of how politics continues to trump sound economic management, even as the fiscal deficit for 2011-12 will likely come in at nearly eight per cent. Add to that a low tax-to-GDP ratio, electricity and other subsidies, and the losses racked up by public-sector enterprises, as well as a precarious external accounts position that is weakening the rupee and making imports more expensive, and the outlook for inflation doesn`t look bright.
ATM - charges
THE Competition Commission of Pakistan has found that the practice of charging the same rate (Rs15 per transaction) by 28 different banks for cash withdrawals by customers of rival banks from their ATMs represents an example of price collusion and an act of a cartel. The banks in question are members of an ATM network `switch`, 1-Link, itself a guarantee limited company created and owned by 11 of the member banks. 1-Link is one of two such ATM networks operating in the country. Having found 1Link and its members guilty, the commission has fined all the offending parties Rs770m in total.
The problems with ATMs in Pakistan have been commonplace for some years now, with network outages and frequent shortages of cash being some of the commonly highlighted ones. Additionally, security problems in some places mean customers often have to worry when they go to withdraw funds fromtheir accounts. While the banks and 1-Link claim that the CCP has wrongly applied competition law in fining them, customers may rightly wonder about the extra Rs15 they are charged every time they use an ATM of another bank are they getting a service that is reasonably safe and efficient at a competitive price? While the State Bank of Pakistan has worked towards keeping the charges by networks such as 1-Link and its client banks in check and there has been some effort at improving the customer experience at ATMs ensuring they are stocked with cash over weekends and holidays, providing brightly lit and more secure spaces, etc there is still a long way to go.
More broadly, as the CCP fine indicates, there are all manner of small fees and charges that banks bill customers in the hope they won`t notice or mind. More vigilance by the State Bank and entities like the CCP will help.
The problems with ATMs in Pakistan have been commonplace for some years now, with network outages and frequent shortages of cash being some of the commonly highlighted ones. Additionally, security problems in some places mean customers often have to worry when they go to withdraw funds fromtheir accounts. While the banks and 1-Link claim that the CCP has wrongly applied competition law in fining them, customers may rightly wonder about the extra Rs15 they are charged every time they use an ATM of another bank are they getting a service that is reasonably safe and efficient at a competitive price? While the State Bank of Pakistan has worked towards keeping the charges by networks such as 1-Link and its client banks in check and there has been some effort at improving the customer experience at ATMs ensuring they are stocked with cash over weekends and holidays, providing brightly lit and more secure spaces, etc there is still a long way to go.
More broadly, as the CCP fine indicates, there are all manner of small fees and charges that banks bill customers in the hope they won`t notice or mind. More vigilance by the State Bank and entities like the CCP will help.
Monday, July 2, 2012
Doctor's agitations
WITH TV images of patients` suffering being beamed live into every home, the striking young doctors in Punjab need to be aware that, regardless of the legitimacy of their demands, public patience may be wearing thin. Also that most of those being denied treatment are so poor that they rely solely on the strike-hit government hospitals for treatment. While the doctors say they aren`t protesting for more money, the Punjab government maintains that the `service structure` they seek adds Rs23bn to the provincial health budget, an amount it can`t divert from frontline healthcare provision to their bank accounts.
The government also says it has already given the young doctors raises worth Rs4.5bn. Unfortunately, all the signs are that the battle lines are hardening especially after the police action last night on the Services Hospital hostel in Lahore that saw the arrest of dozens of doctors. Such a situation, both on the part of the doctors and the administration, whose strong-arm tactics cannot be condoned, does not augur well for patients, especially those who can`t afford private treatment.Meanwhile, the element of militancy that has crept into the strike action has caused some senior professors and doctors to privately say theyfeelthreatened if they staff outpatient departments, even though they are not bound by the strike call. It is sad that such action is now being associated with a noble profession that has public service at its core. We don`t need to remind the doctors of their Hippocratic Oath. Although the representatives of the Young Doctors Association, Punjab, have repeatedly said they are providing cover for essential medical services, they need only look in their own hospital yards to see the mass of suffering humanity. Now army doctors have been called in.
Given the deadlock, what is needed is an independent arbitration and reconciliation service modelled after the UK`s ACAS which can be asked to step in if employees and employers can`t sort out disputes. For the moment, we can only call for restraint especially after last night`s events and dialogue so that the fundamental right to healthcare can be restored to the people.
The government also says it has already given the young doctors raises worth Rs4.5bn. Unfortunately, all the signs are that the battle lines are hardening especially after the police action last night on the Services Hospital hostel in Lahore that saw the arrest of dozens of doctors. Such a situation, both on the part of the doctors and the administration, whose strong-arm tactics cannot be condoned, does not augur well for patients, especially those who can`t afford private treatment.Meanwhile, the element of militancy that has crept into the strike action has caused some senior professors and doctors to privately say theyfeelthreatened if they staff outpatient departments, even though they are not bound by the strike call. It is sad that such action is now being associated with a noble profession that has public service at its core. We don`t need to remind the doctors of their Hippocratic Oath. Although the representatives of the Young Doctors Association, Punjab, have repeatedly said they are providing cover for essential medical services, they need only look in their own hospital yards to see the mass of suffering humanity. Now army doctors have been called in.
Given the deadlock, what is needed is an independent arbitration and reconciliation service modelled after the UK`s ACAS which can be asked to step in if employees and employers can`t sort out disputes. For the moment, we can only call for restraint especially after last night`s events and dialogue so that the fundamental right to healthcare can be restored to the people.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)