Thursday, July 12, 2012

Egypt - power-hungry military

NO one should be less surprised than us Pakistanis at the unfolding political drama in Egypt.

Suddenly, a nation groaning under authoritarian rule for nearly six decades is grappling with the task of self-governance. How key players behave under the circumstances is familiar to us. Generals who have tasted power have no intention of parting with it; leaders elected by the people hope legitimately to be in the saddle; the judiciary enjoys its newly gained freedom and proves itself to be a stickler for the letter of the law. On Tuesday, the Supreme Constitutional Court annulled President Mohammad Morsi`s decree calling for the assembly to meet.

The newly elected assembly was dissolved by the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces after the constitutional court declared it illegal on technical grounds. Going against what appears to be a common move by the generals and the judges, the president chose to convene the assembly.

From the very beginning President Morsi has been hamstrung by the generals` ploys, for the dissolution of the assembly meant he would not be able to pursue his legislative agenda and lawmaking would be done by Scaf by decree. The generals, headed by Field Marshal Hussain Tantawi, have already told President Morsi it is they who will make the budget. More painfully, a new generalelection cannot be held unless a new constitution is made, and that should take at least another year. This means, if President Morsi still decides to stay on in the presidential palace, Egypt will for all practical purposes continue to be ruled by the military in spite of all that has happened since the anti-Mubarak uprising began in January 2011.

There are two aspects of the present situation: one is the struggle between democratic forces and a military addicted to power; the other is the political forces` polarisation between the Islamists and secularists. The result of the run-off in the presidential election showed that a sizable section of the Egyptian people believe in a pluralistic society. Their fears that the Brotherhood may turn Egypt into a theocracy deserves to be addressed.

That`s the reason why many of them are not averse to collaborating with the military. This is a big mistake, and emphasises the need for President Morsi and his Freedom and Justice Party to take the secularists along in the effort to eliminate the military`s role. Egyptians should learn from Pakistan`s example and realise that the transition from authoritarianism to democracy entails decades of setbacks and sacrifices, and that it is not so easy to push a power-hungry military back to the barracks.

Supreme Court accused the Frontier Corps of being involved in the disappearance of every third missing person in Balochistan.

QUETTA, July 11: The Supreme Court rejected on Wednesday a police investigation report on the murder of Mir Hagmal Raisani, a nephew of Balochistan Chief Minister Nawab Aslam Raisani.

A three-judge bench comprising Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhry, Justice Jawwad s. Khwaja and Justice Khilji Arif Hussain is hearing a petition on law and order and human rights violations in the province at the Quetta registry of the court.

The chief justice directed the home department to prepare a list of the decomposed bodies found so far. He also ordered the Frontier Corps Balochistan to produce all missing persons before the court. Otherwise, he warned, all FC commandants would be summoned.

The court asked FC`s counsel Raja Irshad to submit statements of the FC commandants on missing persons and the law and order situation.

The counsel sought some time to comply with the order.

The court warned FC officials involved in human rights violations to end such violations and asked the counsel why the FC was accused of being involved in disappearance of people.(According to AFP, the Supreme Court accused the Frontier Corps of being involved in the disappearance of every third missing person in Balochistan.

`Enough evidences are available for involvement of the Frontier Corps in picking up of every third missing person` in the province, Chief Justice Iftikhar Chaudhry said.

The court also heard a case about the alleged abduction of 30 people and killing of two tribesmen in Khuzdar district in February last year. It ordered FC officials to produce people from the incident which it had in custody.) The CJP wondered why the Khuzdar district administration was unaware of the FC operation.

He asked why law-enforcement personnel did not bother to check vehicles with tinted glasses which carried armed guards.

The court observed that parliament had elected a new prime minister three days after termination of the previous one and a consensus had been reached between the government and opposition over the appointment of a new chief election commissioner, but on the issue of Balochistan there had been no progress. `It is responsibility of the government to improve law and order in the province,` it added.

The CJP asked the chief secretary why the people of Balochistan were so frustrated and scared.

The chief secretary blamed some political decisions and the previous local bodies system for pushing the province many years back.

`Had the LG system been allowed to be prevailed and human rights violations stopped, the present situation of law and order would not have emerged in Balochistan,` the CJP observed.

The court ordered the authorities to call on duty the Levies Force personnel sitting in their homes.

The court was informed that there was no official bythe name of Major Saif in Military Intelligence and the National Database Registration Authority had not provided record of the person.

A recovered missing person, Abdul Wahab, was produced before the court for recording his statement.

The mother of missing person Zafrullah and the father another missing man Iqbal appealed to the court to issue an order for their recovery. `Authorities concerned should feel the grievance and sorrow of an ageing mother,` the CJP observed.

The court said local tribes should be taken on board for improving law and order in Dera Bugti. It directed the authorities to remove landmines and IEDs from the district.

The court asked the Balochistan police chief to appear before it on Thursday.

Wednesday, July 11, 2012

those who inflated the balloon decided to prick it.

CONTRARY to previous reports that the `long march` of the Defence of Pakistan Council would not be allowed to enter Islamabad, the rally that included an outlawed organisation and some `banned` leaders did manage to enter the capital on Monday and disperse peacefully. There was no violence along the rally`s 275-kilometre journey from Lahore to Islamabad, and the federal authorities allowed the convoy to D-Chowk opposite parliament because the two sides had come to an understanding. This peaceful conclusion of the rally on the basis of the `understanding` was a pleasant surprise.

Suddenly things begin to make sense, especially when Hafiz Saeed counsels peace. Since the Salala incident and the blocking of the Nato supply line, the DPC leadership had vowed never to allow supplies for the USled Isaf forces in Afghanistan to be resumed. Often, DPC leaders had threatened to set the country on fire fromKarachi to Khyber if trucks started rolling again along highways vulnerable to sabotage.

The blocking of Nato supplies and the subsequent resumption had parliamentary approval both decisions having the backing of a military bruised as much by May 2 as by Nov 26. While the DPC`s enthusiastic support for the supply cut-off was in keeping with its militant opposition to America and to Islamabad`s perceived `slavery` to Washington, its low-profile opposition to the resumption decision and the `understanding` with the federal administration sound baffling, if not secretive. Evidently, those who inflated the balloon decided to prick it.

The DPC`s anti-government rhetoric may still find a place in the media, but the zing is gone. The powers that be may revive the DPC under a new garb for the general election, and there may be new entrants, but for the present the DPC`s tacit approval of supply resumption has deprived it of its raison d`être.

Gujrat attack

MONDAY`S attack on soldiers in Gujrat was a stark reminder that homegrown militants still have the intention, and the means, to target security forces outside the tribal areas. The pace of such attacks has slowed down, and there have been no recent incidents on the scale of PNS Mehran or GHQ, so some progress against this threat has been made over the last couple of years. But the ease with which this most recent assault took place indicates that the danger persists and that the quality of preventive intelligence-gathering, and even of routine surveillance around a military presence, is still not where it needs to be. Second, the incident was a reminder of the militant nexus connecting settled areas to Fata-based militancy. It is not entirely clear whether the Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan, which has claimed responsibility, was involved directly, or if the attack was carried out by Punjab-based militants affiliated with it. But it is plain that Punjab is still vulnerable to violent extremism and anti-state activity that is made possi-ble by links that stretch from Fata to the province.

What remains missing is official messaging that can inform Pakistanis about the real nature of this threat that it is homegrown and focused on the destruction of the Pakistani state as it exists today. The view that such attacks are carried out by foreign hands, for example, or that they are justified because of Pakistan`s alliance with the United States, are alarmingly common. But each incident can also be used as an opportunity to fight these misperceptions. The concept of the so-called Punjabi Taliban still remains a murky one in terms of who is involved, who they are linked to, and what their aims are. And not all sensitive information about these groupscanbe shared publicly. But this is not a war that can be fought without citizens` support, and some amount of disclosure about how these groups are weakening Pakistan could help build a national consensus against militancy and improve intelligence-gathering by making citizens responsive to suspicious activity in their communities.

New Chief Election Comissioner

THE nomination of Fakhruddin G. Ebrahim, a retired justice of the Supreme Court, has ended the months-long wrangling between the PPP and the PML-N over the appointment of the next chief election commissioner. This is welcome news at a time when the democratic project could certainly do with a boost. For a while it had appeared that egos were going to keep the two sides deadlocked on the appointment of a new CEC. Leader of the Opposition in the National Assembly Chaudhry Nisar in particular appeared determined to get his way, wanting one of his three nominees to get the nod from the parliamentary committee even if other qualified and non-controversial candidates were brought into the mix as a compromise. In the end, with a new prime minister in the saddle and the PPP facing uncertainty over his fate, the party acquiesced.

What remained was to convince a reluctant Mr Ebrahim to accept the CEC slot ahead of a general election. While health concerns will remain, the octogenarian Mr Ebrahim is certainly a man of integrity and forthrightness and under his watch the Election Commission of Pakistan could come closer to playing its rightful constitutional role in the holding of an election.

While the challenges will be immense free and fair elections, or at least freer and more fair thanhave been held to date, are rarely in the interests of the political class and the other powers that shape elections here this is perhaps the right moment in Pakistan`s history to work towards making the electoral process more transparent and fair.

But the deal between the opposition and the government to elect a new CEC goes beyond the matter of elections. It is yet another sign that if given the time and space to work out their differences, politicians can and do deliver. That basic argument for the continuity of the system is often ignored in Pakistan and drowned out by the protests against governmental incompetence and parliamentary toothlessness. While criticism of the present government is all too real and meaningful, there have been notable achievements, particularly from the structural point of view. The 18th Amendment to give more power to the provinces and disempower the president`s office; the NFC that has given more resources to the provinces to deliver on an expanded range of responsibilities; the 20th Amendment that built on the 18th Amendment to give more autonomy to the ECP are some well-known examples. Now the biggest challenge is ahead: a legitimate general election conducted under the auspices of the civilians. They may just deliver, if given the time and space.

Friday, July 6, 2012

musharraf on NATO supply

IT was a potential gift for the United States on its independence day. If the reopening of the Nato supply route was not enough cause for celebration, we had a proven strongman offering the Americans a reincarnation of Abraham Lincoln. In his own modest way, Gen (retd) Pervez Musharraf was being his old self since the reasoning behind the comparison between Pakistan`s former president and Mr Lincoln was as simple as his logic has ever been. The resultant conclusion was as categorical as when Gen Musharraf was hailed the new Kemal Atatürk in the months following his military coup in 1999. `I know he [president Lincoln] had violated the constitution because his responsibility was to protect the state and therefore protect the constitution. So this has been the dilemma of Pakistan all through its history.` This is how Gen Musharraf made a grabfor the long unclaimed Lincoln mantle. Perfect a justification for one coup supported by an `example` from American history.

What if a century and half separated the two visionaries? It is fate that throws up great saviours at a time of its choosing.

But as fate would have it, Gen Musharraf`s remarks were reported just a day before Pakistan underwent the painful ritual of marking the anniversary of the start of the Zia martial law that was so pivotal to changing the course of this country, this society and this state. Gen Musharraf has his views and he has rights. He is free to predict a role for himself in Pakistani politics. The problem is that if his latest elaborations are a guide to the tone of his future politics, his presence is hardly something for the inhabitants of this land to look forward to.

Thank you, sir, we have been saved enough times already.

blasphamy lynching

THE most obvious implication of the burning of a man to death in Bahawalpur is the brutality of Pakistani society when it comes to alleged blasphemy cases. In this instance the victim was also mentally ill, proving once again that the law is blatantly abused and punishment doled out without evidence or reason. But Tuesday`s incident is also a reminder that in the face of blasphemy allegations, the country`s justice and law-enforcement systems are helpless. The victim was pried out of a police station that was also set on fire. This follows two similar incidents in June, when mobs attacked police stations in Quetta and Karachi to demand that blasphemy suspects one a drug addict and the other mentally ill be handed over.

Last year some lawyers and religious groups demanded that the judge who sentenced Salmaan Taseer`s killer to death be handed over to them, though thankfully he did not meet the fate of Justice Arif Bhatti, who was killed in his office in 1997 for striking down allegations of blasphemy against two Christians.Over a decade has passed since that incident, and the state has yet to make clear in no uncertain terms that vigilante justice is not acceptable simply because the case happens to be one of blasphemy. The Punjab government is particularly guilty of this, turning a blind eye to the way in which rightwing groups abuse and support the law in that province.

The other alarming aspect of the incident is that it is yet another instance of a mob taking justice into its own hands, a problem not limited to blasphemy cases. The size of these groups makes it difficult to hold anyone responsible; who will be held to account in the Bahawalpur case, for example, when 2,000 people have been booked and no one named? From rioters destroying shops and vehicles to protest energy shortages, to the Sialkot lynching case, to the blasphemy incidents mentioned here, all the evidence says that intolerance and lack of compassion, combined with lack of faith in the state and the justice system, has turned Pakistan into a shockingly brutal society.