PRIME Minister Raja Pervez Ashraf, during the inauguration ceremony of a
hydroelectricity project in Besham, once again invited all political
parties to come and sit together ... to find a workable solution to the
persisting crisis... He lamented that a dictator ruled the country for
10 years but no one stopped him while all stepstaken by a democratic
government are being challenged.
We cannot say how political
parties willrespond to the prime minister`s offer, but we are sure that
if they do not respond positively no one will be able to stop us from
destruction. It is strange that despite the hard experience of
dictatorships our politicians fail to develop democratic attitudes....
The sufferers from dictatorship and political confrontation are the
people. .
Regrettably our leaders and guides ... are further pushing us to this undesired destination.
One
can have hundreds of differences with ... the incum-bent government.
Its performance may not be praised, the restoration of the constitution
and of the rights of the provinces might be brushed aside, but it
deserves credit that it was heading to complete its tenure. No doubt
this is a victory for democrats...
[In the past] the attitudes of
political parties and their unwise steps were causes forthe imposition
of dictatorship. The undemocratic forces always took advantage of this
situation. It appears that wehave neither learnt from the past nor want
to learn in the future. Otherwise political parties might not be
demanding early elections.
However, the prime minister`s offer is
a positive sign and we hope political forces will take it with
sincerity and cooperate with the government so that the democratic
dispensation can complete its destination and heal injuries caused by
undemocratic forces. (July 16) Selected and translated by Sohail Sangi
Tuesday, July 17, 2012
Asghar`s petition hearing in SC ISI cell on the receiving end of criticism
ISLAMABAD, July 16: While referring to the dreaded political cell in the InterServices Intelligence (ISI), the Supreme Court categorically stated on Monday that the judiciary would not accept any extra-constitutional interference in the democratic order.
Citing a number of judgments, including the July 31, 2009, landmark verdict which denounced successive military takeovers and the one which sent former prime minister Yousuf Raza Gilani home, a three-judge bench said that through these pronouncements the court had made it abundantly clearthat the affairs ofthe state had to be governed strictly in accordance with the Constitution and no interference of any nature from functionaries, other than those under the Constitution, was acceptable.
The bench comprising Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, Justice Jawwad S. Khwaja and Justice Khilji Arif Hussain had taken up a 1996 petition of Tehrik-i-Istiqlal chief Air Martial (retd) Asghar Khan who accused the ISI of financing politicians in the 1990 elections by dishing out Rs140 million to create Islami Jamboori Ittehad (IJI) and prevent Benazir Bhutto`s PPP from winning the polls.
`The democratic order under the Constitution shouldbe allowed to continue without any extra-constitutional interference,` the court said while citing its earlier verdicts. It asked Attorney General Irfan Qadir to seek instructions from the quarters concerned about the existence of the cell.
On May 17 also the court had directed the AG to procure and submit the notification under which the political cen had been set up in 1975 by then chief executive Zulfikar Ali Bhutto.
Mr Qadir assured the court that he would dig out information about the notification. He is also required to bring into the notice of the prime minister underwhose commands the ISI functions about the dictum laid down by the Supreme Court in different cases in which the court always encouraged the continuation of the democratic system of governance.
`What the Constitution provides are required to be done accordingly,` observed the chief justice while dictating the order after Monday`s proceedings.
Advocate Salman Akram Raja, representing Asghar Khan, regretted that former ISI chief Hameed Gul had been claiming in interviews that given the chance what was done in the 90s would be repeated again. `There has been no repentance and this mindset has not changed, the counsel said.
The court observed that it had endeavoured to change this mindset through theJuly 31 judgment.
Bangladesh model `Let the democratic process continue. We are happy that the new prime minister has come. No Bangladesh model can be introduced in Pakistan,` the court observed.
The chief justice had some praise for the armed forces when he said the court had great respect for the troops.
`They are being slaughtered like anything,` the court said.
The court was informed that former director general of ISI Lt-Gen (retd) Asad Durrani had submitted documents which shed light on the process of setting up the ISI political cell. The documents include facts about the existence of the cell contained in a concise statement he had earlier submitted to the court.
Gen Durrani is also required to submit the list he had promised containing the names of ISI officials involved in the operation to substantiate the doling out of funds among different politicians.
The attorney general said nothing substantive or detrimental evidence in any manner had been provided in the documents. The court asked him to submit the documents in a sealed cover.
The court also mentioned the Feb 6, 1997, order which indicated that the former AG had to inform the court whether the ISI political cell was still working or had been disbanded.
Defence Secretary Nargis Sethi, who appeared before the court, was asked if the ISI, Military Intelligence and the defence ministry would be represented by any counsel.
`We want to give an opportunity so that nobody can say he has been condemned unheard,` the court said.
The defence secretary said she would consult relevant stakeholders in this regard.
She said that despite her best efforts the notification about the setting up of political cell in the ISI could not be traced.
`The issue is 38 years old, but I will make another effort, she assured the court.
The attorney general informed the court that authenticity or veracity of the commission`s report on Mehran Bank Limited was not possible because the original one was still missing.
About the report on Habib Bank Limited, the AG said it could not be completed because the then government had stopped the commission concerned from conducting the inquiry in 1997.
The court recalled that 14 to 15 statements had been recorded before the commission on Habib Bank and asked the AG to get their copies.
The court adjourned the hearing till July 30.
Citing a number of judgments, including the July 31, 2009, landmark verdict which denounced successive military takeovers and the one which sent former prime minister Yousuf Raza Gilani home, a three-judge bench said that through these pronouncements the court had made it abundantly clearthat the affairs ofthe state had to be governed strictly in accordance with the Constitution and no interference of any nature from functionaries, other than those under the Constitution, was acceptable.
The bench comprising Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, Justice Jawwad S. Khwaja and Justice Khilji Arif Hussain had taken up a 1996 petition of Tehrik-i-Istiqlal chief Air Martial (retd) Asghar Khan who accused the ISI of financing politicians in the 1990 elections by dishing out Rs140 million to create Islami Jamboori Ittehad (IJI) and prevent Benazir Bhutto`s PPP from winning the polls.
`The democratic order under the Constitution shouldbe allowed to continue without any extra-constitutional interference,` the court said while citing its earlier verdicts. It asked Attorney General Irfan Qadir to seek instructions from the quarters concerned about the existence of the cell.
On May 17 also the court had directed the AG to procure and submit the notification under which the political cen had been set up in 1975 by then chief executive Zulfikar Ali Bhutto.
Mr Qadir assured the court that he would dig out information about the notification. He is also required to bring into the notice of the prime minister underwhose commands the ISI functions about the dictum laid down by the Supreme Court in different cases in which the court always encouraged the continuation of the democratic system of governance.
`What the Constitution provides are required to be done accordingly,` observed the chief justice while dictating the order after Monday`s proceedings.
Advocate Salman Akram Raja, representing Asghar Khan, regretted that former ISI chief Hameed Gul had been claiming in interviews that given the chance what was done in the 90s would be repeated again. `There has been no repentance and this mindset has not changed, the counsel said.
The court observed that it had endeavoured to change this mindset through theJuly 31 judgment.
Bangladesh model `Let the democratic process continue. We are happy that the new prime minister has come. No Bangladesh model can be introduced in Pakistan,` the court observed.
The chief justice had some praise for the armed forces when he said the court had great respect for the troops.
`They are being slaughtered like anything,` the court said.
The court was informed that former director general of ISI Lt-Gen (retd) Asad Durrani had submitted documents which shed light on the process of setting up the ISI political cell. The documents include facts about the existence of the cell contained in a concise statement he had earlier submitted to the court.
Gen Durrani is also required to submit the list he had promised containing the names of ISI officials involved in the operation to substantiate the doling out of funds among different politicians.
The attorney general said nothing substantive or detrimental evidence in any manner had been provided in the documents. The court asked him to submit the documents in a sealed cover.
The court also mentioned the Feb 6, 1997, order which indicated that the former AG had to inform the court whether the ISI political cell was still working or had been disbanded.
Defence Secretary Nargis Sethi, who appeared before the court, was asked if the ISI, Military Intelligence and the defence ministry would be represented by any counsel.
`We want to give an opportunity so that nobody can say he has been condemned unheard,` the court said.
The defence secretary said she would consult relevant stakeholders in this regard.
She said that despite her best efforts the notification about the setting up of political cell in the ISI could not be traced.
`The issue is 38 years old, but I will make another effort, she assured the court.
The attorney general informed the court that authenticity or veracity of the commission`s report on Mehran Bank Limited was not possible because the original one was still missing.
About the report on Habib Bank Limited, the AG said it could not be completed because the then government had stopped the commission concerned from conducting the inquiry in 1997.
The court recalled that 14 to 15 statements had been recorded before the commission on Habib Bank and asked the AG to get their copies.
The court adjourned the hearing till July 30.
India invites Pakistan Circket Team
NEW DELHI, July 16: The Indian cricket board said on Monday it had invited Pakistan for a series later this year, their first in five years, in a further sign of improving ties between the neighbours.
If approved by the two governments, the series would comprise three one-day internationals and two Twenty20 games in December-January, the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) said in a statement.
`It was decided to resume cricketing ties with Pakistanby inviting the Pakistan cricket team for a short series in Dec 2012-Jan 2013,` it said, adding that modalities would be worked out shortly.
The rivals have not played a series since Pakistan`s tour of India in 2007, after cricket ties were snapped following the 2008 terror attacks on Mumbai.
The ODI matches will be played in Chennai, Kolkata and New Delhi and the Twenty20 games in Bangalore and Ahmedabad, BCCI spokesman Rajiv Shukla toldreporters in New Delhi.
The series will be held when England, who are dueto tour India later this year, return home briefly for Christmas and New Year.Cricket ties have been the subject of discussions between the two governments that have been holding regular meetings in a bid to improve ties and eventually thrash out a peace agreement. Indian and Pakistani cricket teams have only met in international tournaments since 2007. `Once they have decided, then there will be the issue of internal security, which will be reviewed and decided by various agencies.
Former Indian captain Sunil Gavaskar said Pakistanwas still not cooperating in the Mumbai attacks probe.
`Being a Mumbaikar (hailing from Mumbai), I feel what is the urgency (for a series) when there is no cooperation from the other side,` the Press Trust of India (PTI) news agency quoted him as saying.
But fellow former skipper Bishan Bedi welcomed the revival. `It is a step in the right direction,` he told PTI.
`The amount of interest and goodwill it will generate will be huge.`-AFP
If approved by the two governments, the series would comprise three one-day internationals and two Twenty20 games in December-January, the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) said in a statement.
`It was decided to resume cricketing ties with Pakistanby inviting the Pakistan cricket team for a short series in Dec 2012-Jan 2013,` it said, adding that modalities would be worked out shortly.
The rivals have not played a series since Pakistan`s tour of India in 2007, after cricket ties were snapped following the 2008 terror attacks on Mumbai.
The ODI matches will be played in Chennai, Kolkata and New Delhi and the Twenty20 games in Bangalore and Ahmedabad, BCCI spokesman Rajiv Shukla toldreporters in New Delhi.
The series will be held when England, who are dueto tour India later this year, return home briefly for Christmas and New Year.Cricket ties have been the subject of discussions between the two governments that have been holding regular meetings in a bid to improve ties and eventually thrash out a peace agreement. Indian and Pakistani cricket teams have only met in international tournaments since 2007. `Once they have decided, then there will be the issue of internal security, which will be reviewed and decided by various agencies.
Former Indian captain Sunil Gavaskar said Pakistanwas still not cooperating in the Mumbai attacks probe.
`Being a Mumbaikar (hailing from Mumbai), I feel what is the urgency (for a series) when there is no cooperation from the other side,` the Press Trust of India (PTI) news agency quoted him as saying.
But fellow former skipper Bishan Bedi welcomed the revival. `It is a step in the right direction,` he told PTI.
`The amount of interest and goodwill it will generate will be huge.`-AFP
Monday, July 16, 2012
Political Challenge
PRIME Minister Raja Pervez Ashraf`s offer to national political leaders to enter in talks with the government to `reach a consensus on national issues and to find a workable solution to the persisting crisis`` is a suggestion worthy of serious consideration by all political parties. As the uncertainty over the fate of Prime Minister Ashraf and the government itself grows, there is no mistaking that the democratic order itself may come under attack. Despite their acute differences in a fractured and polarised polity, the major political parties have shown a commendable degree of maturity and good sense in keeping the transition to democracy on track the past four and a half years.
Now, in this moment of perhaps the sternest test so far, the parties are in a position to once again present a united front against the growing talk of anti-democratic measures being contemplated in certain quarters.
Of course, the primary responsibility for rallying the political class behind democracy is the government`s. In particular, the PPP needs to demonstrate that it is committed to holding free and fair elections. The appointment of Fakhruddin Ebrahim as chief election commissioner was one step in that direction. But there is much more to be done. An independent Election Commission of Pakistan isone thing, demonstrating that the administrative machine of the country will be put at its disposal for election purposes without political interference is another thing. Then there is the challenge of finding an impartial and effective caretaker government that will see the country through the election period. Asking political allies and rivals to support the PPP`s agenda for democracy will likely be met with a more positive response if the PPP demonstrates its own good intentions and willingness to compromise first.
Having said that, the burden of keeping the democratic project on track is not of the government`s alone. The opposition, particularly the PML-N, need to be brave and bold in the critical weeks ahead.
While there is speculation that behind-the-scenes negotiations are continuing between the PML-N and the PPP on the timing of a general election and the modalities of the caretaker set-up, until a deal is publicly unveiled the old adage that there`s many a slip between lip and cup is worth keeping in mind. If a deal is struck between government and opposition, however, much of the uncertainty over the next stage in the transition to democracy will dissipate.
The anti-democratic forces appear to be waiting in the wings, so it is up to the politicians to steal centre stage and keep democracy on track.
Now, in this moment of perhaps the sternest test so far, the parties are in a position to once again present a united front against the growing talk of anti-democratic measures being contemplated in certain quarters.
Of course, the primary responsibility for rallying the political class behind democracy is the government`s. In particular, the PPP needs to demonstrate that it is committed to holding free and fair elections. The appointment of Fakhruddin Ebrahim as chief election commissioner was one step in that direction. But there is much more to be done. An independent Election Commission of Pakistan isone thing, demonstrating that the administrative machine of the country will be put at its disposal for election purposes without political interference is another thing. Then there is the challenge of finding an impartial and effective caretaker government that will see the country through the election period. Asking political allies and rivals to support the PPP`s agenda for democracy will likely be met with a more positive response if the PPP demonstrates its own good intentions and willingness to compromise first.
Having said that, the burden of keeping the democratic project on track is not of the government`s alone. The opposition, particularly the PML-N, need to be brave and bold in the critical weeks ahead.
While there is speculation that behind-the-scenes negotiations are continuing between the PML-N and the PPP on the timing of a general election and the modalities of the caretaker set-up, until a deal is publicly unveiled the old adage that there`s many a slip between lip and cup is worth keeping in mind. If a deal is struck between government and opposition, however, much of the uncertainty over the next stage in the transition to democracy will dissipate.
The anti-democratic forces appear to be waiting in the wings, so it is up to the politicians to steal centre stage and keep democracy on track.
Outside role in Kashmir ruled out Obama welcomes Pak-India efforts to lessen tension
WASHINGTON, July 15: US President Barack Obama has ruled out any outside role in the Kashmir dispute but has emphasised the needfor other nations to play a role in stabilising Pakistan.
In an interview with Indian journalist Lalit K.
Jha, Mr Obama also advised India to liberalise economy, noting that New Delhi prohibited foreign investment in too many sectors.
His remarks riled the Indian opposition, which rejected the suggestion as `laughable` and urged the Indian government not to accept his advice.
Mr Obama welcomed the Indo-Pakistan dialogue process and urged the two neighbours to work together to find a solution to a dispute that had already caused three wars between them.
`It is not the place of any nation, including the United States, to try to impose solutions from the outside,` said Mr Obama, apparently endorsing the Indian position that it would not accept any outside role in settling this issue.
`That said, nations must meet their responsibilities and all of us have a profound interest in a Pakistan that is stable, prosperous and democratic,` said the US president,WASHINGTON, July 15: US President Barack Obama has ruled out any outside role in the Kashmir dispute but has emphasised the needfor other nations to play a role in stabilising Pakistan.
In an interview with Indian journalist Lalit K.
Jha, Mr Obama also advised India to liberalise economy, noting that New Delhi prohibited foreign investment in too many sectors.
His remarks riled the Indian opposition, which rejected the suggestion as `laughable` and urged the Indian government not to accept his advice.
Mr Obama welcomed the Indo-Pakistan dialogue process and urged the two neighbours to work together to find a solution to a dispute that had already caused three wars between them.
`It is not the place of any nation, including the United States, to try to impose solutions from the outside,` said Mr Obama, apparently endorsing the Indian position that it would not accept any outside role in settling this issue.
`That said, nations must meet their responsibilities and all of us have a profound interest in a Pakistan that is stable, prosperous and democratic,` said the US president,leaving open the possibility of involving India in bringing stability to Pakistan.
Mr Jha, the only Indian journalist ever to have interviewed a US president twice, told Dawn that Mr Obama made it clear the best way forward for the two countries was to keep talking to each other.
Mr Obama told him that lessening of tensions between India and Pakistan would not only be good for South Asia but also for the rest of the world.
`President (Asif Ali) Zardari`s visit to India was encouraging. Increased trade and people-to-people contacts betSea change in atmospherics with India, says Pak envoy: Page 3 ween Indians and Pakistanis can lead to greater prosperity and understanding on both sides,` said Mr Obama.
`Efforts in New Delhi and Islamabad to improve relations give hope for further progress, including a possible visit to Pakistan by Prime Minister (Manmohan) Singh, he said.
Mr Obama, however, did not say if he planned to fulfil his promise to visit Pakistan.
Another cause of concern for Pakistan was Mr Obama`s warm welcome to India`s growing role in Afghanistan.
`India will be critical to Afghanistan`s future,` he said, noting that India was already playing a major role in helping Afghanistan.India, he said, had made generous contributions to Afghanistan`s progress, helping to train Afghan police, promoting development and in improving the lives of ordinary Afghans.
India was the first nation to forge a Strategic Partnership Agreement with Afghanistan, he noted, adding that India`s civil service could be a model as Afghans strengthened their own governance and institutions.
India hosted an international investment conference on Afghanistan last month and Mr Obama said that by doing so, New Delhi had shown its readiness to champion Kabul`s economic development.
Mr Obama said the United States and its Nato allies had chalked out, at the Chicago summit earlier this year, a clear path for bringing the Afghan war to an end.
By mid-2013, Afghan forces would lead combat operations and coalition forces would have shifted from combat to a supporting role across the country, he said, hoping that this would allow a steady withdrawal of US and Nato troops from Afghanistan.
`By the end of 2014, the transition to Afghan lead for security will be complete so that Afghans can take responsibility for their own country,` said Mr Obama. `After 2014, Nato will continue to train, advise and assist and support Afghan forces as they grow stronger.
In an interview with Indian journalist Lalit K.
Jha, Mr Obama also advised India to liberalise economy, noting that New Delhi prohibited foreign investment in too many sectors.
His remarks riled the Indian opposition, which rejected the suggestion as `laughable` and urged the Indian government not to accept his advice.
Mr Obama welcomed the Indo-Pakistan dialogue process and urged the two neighbours to work together to find a solution to a dispute that had already caused three wars between them.
`It is not the place of any nation, including the United States, to try to impose solutions from the outside,` said Mr Obama, apparently endorsing the Indian position that it would not accept any outside role in settling this issue.
`That said, nations must meet their responsibilities and all of us have a profound interest in a Pakistan that is stable, prosperous and democratic,` said the US president,WASHINGTON, July 15: US President Barack Obama has ruled out any outside role in the Kashmir dispute but has emphasised the needfor other nations to play a role in stabilising Pakistan.
In an interview with Indian journalist Lalit K.
Jha, Mr Obama also advised India to liberalise economy, noting that New Delhi prohibited foreign investment in too many sectors.
His remarks riled the Indian opposition, which rejected the suggestion as `laughable` and urged the Indian government not to accept his advice.
Mr Obama welcomed the Indo-Pakistan dialogue process and urged the two neighbours to work together to find a solution to a dispute that had already caused three wars between them.
`It is not the place of any nation, including the United States, to try to impose solutions from the outside,` said Mr Obama, apparently endorsing the Indian position that it would not accept any outside role in settling this issue.
`That said, nations must meet their responsibilities and all of us have a profound interest in a Pakistan that is stable, prosperous and democratic,` said the US president,leaving open the possibility of involving India in bringing stability to Pakistan.
Mr Jha, the only Indian journalist ever to have interviewed a US president twice, told Dawn that Mr Obama made it clear the best way forward for the two countries was to keep talking to each other.
Mr Obama told him that lessening of tensions between India and Pakistan would not only be good for South Asia but also for the rest of the world.
`President (Asif Ali) Zardari`s visit to India was encouraging. Increased trade and people-to-people contacts betSea change in atmospherics with India, says Pak envoy: Page 3 ween Indians and Pakistanis can lead to greater prosperity and understanding on both sides,` said Mr Obama.
`Efforts in New Delhi and Islamabad to improve relations give hope for further progress, including a possible visit to Pakistan by Prime Minister (Manmohan) Singh, he said.
Mr Obama, however, did not say if he planned to fulfil his promise to visit Pakistan.
Another cause of concern for Pakistan was Mr Obama`s warm welcome to India`s growing role in Afghanistan.
`India will be critical to Afghanistan`s future,` he said, noting that India was already playing a major role in helping Afghanistan.India, he said, had made generous contributions to Afghanistan`s progress, helping to train Afghan police, promoting development and in improving the lives of ordinary Afghans.
India was the first nation to forge a Strategic Partnership Agreement with Afghanistan, he noted, adding that India`s civil service could be a model as Afghans strengthened their own governance and institutions.
India hosted an international investment conference on Afghanistan last month and Mr Obama said that by doing so, New Delhi had shown its readiness to champion Kabul`s economic development.
Mr Obama said the United States and its Nato allies had chalked out, at the Chicago summit earlier this year, a clear path for bringing the Afghan war to an end.
By mid-2013, Afghan forces would lead combat operations and coalition forces would have shifted from combat to a supporting role across the country, he said, hoping that this would allow a steady withdrawal of US and Nato troops from Afghanistan.
`By the end of 2014, the transition to Afghan lead for security will be complete so that Afghans can take responsibility for their own country,` said Mr Obama. `After 2014, Nato will continue to train, advise and assist and support Afghan forces as they grow stronger.
Thursday, July 12, 2012
THE emergency landing by an Indian passenger plane in Nawabshah
THE emergency landing by an Indian passenger plane in Nawabshah on
Monday does signify some progress in Pakistan-India relations over time.
That the flight which had developed faults midair while flying from Abu
Dhabi to New Delhi was able to land in Pakistani territory at all is an
important landmark. On the other hand, the 130 passengers and crew who
spent 13 hours inside the plane in Nawabshah can be viewed as a metaphor
for the millions who find themselves caught between the governments in
Delhi and Islamabad that are tediously slow when it comes to improving
ties.
These 130 accidental guests could have acted as better-equipped agents of normalisation had they been allowed to experience Pakistani hospitality firsthand. Instead, they were made to spend 13 hours inside the parked aircraft, the pilot choosing toburdenthe chancehosts with no more than arequest for a few bottles of water. He was not unfriendly at all and has been described as polite.
Yet, it appears that he was carrying on his shoulders not just the responsibility of ensuring his passengers reached their destination, a monumental task no doubt. He was also weighed down by perceptions and policies and fears and suspicions that would be hard to overcome in `hostile` territory. With this baggage, he could hardly be blamed for acting cautious when he refused food and an offer for the passengers to step out of the plane and refresh themselves. However, this `pleasant` stopover has to be marked somehow. The peace activists will be all too keen to highlight the incident and the newspapers to cash in on it. It would be great though if the Pakistani government could sent some 130 gifts to the Air India passengers and crew as souvenirs of their memorable stay in Nawabshah.
These 130 accidental guests could have acted as better-equipped agents of normalisation had they been allowed to experience Pakistani hospitality firsthand. Instead, they were made to spend 13 hours inside the parked aircraft, the pilot choosing toburdenthe chancehosts with no more than arequest for a few bottles of water. He was not unfriendly at all and has been described as polite.
Yet, it appears that he was carrying on his shoulders not just the responsibility of ensuring his passengers reached their destination, a monumental task no doubt. He was also weighed down by perceptions and policies and fears and suspicions that would be hard to overcome in `hostile` territory. With this baggage, he could hardly be blamed for acting cautious when he refused food and an offer for the passengers to step out of the plane and refresh themselves. However, this `pleasant` stopover has to be marked somehow. The peace activists will be all too keen to highlight the incident and the newspapers to cash in on it. It would be great though if the Pakistani government could sent some 130 gifts to the Air India passengers and crew as souvenirs of their memorable stay in Nawabshah.
Dual nationality bill
N a rare show of public disagreement over proposed legislation, members
of the ruling coalition, and even of the PPP itself, have spoken out
against the dual nationality bill. That should provide some indication
to the party that it needs to rethink its policy on the issue. The ANP
has refused to support it, other major coalition partners have expressed
reservations, and even party stalwarts such as Aitzaz Ahsan and Raza
Rabbani are opposing it publicly. Given this, it is unlikely that the
bill will survive, at least in its current form. While the PPP may be
able to eventually push it through the Senate, it is not likely to be
able to do so in the National Assembly with the two-thirds majority
required.
What, then, is to be gained from pursuing the matter? In the absence of even internal support, the move seems to be aimed at saving the skins of a handful of legislators. At a time when the government is also pursuing a new contempt of court law, the attempt adds to the perception that its prime motivation isopportunistic politics.
And given the party`s poor governance record, the move strengthens the general view that the administration is concerned with narrow interests rather than the national interest. Public sentiment on the issue is apparent, and is no doubt in part responsible for the stand taken by some members of the coalition as well as the opposition both inside and outside parliament. So with all the other issues the party is currently dealing with, from pressure due to the reopening of Nato supply routes to the NRO implementation case, pursuing this matter doesn`t appear to make sense.
There is also the matter of the principle involved, which the government should ultimately be focusing on. At this point in its turbulent history, and given the widespread lack of faith in politicians among the Pakistani public, why should dual nationality holders not be willing to give up their foreign passports if they want to take on public office? This is one fight the government would do well to reconsider.
What, then, is to be gained from pursuing the matter? In the absence of even internal support, the move seems to be aimed at saving the skins of a handful of legislators. At a time when the government is also pursuing a new contempt of court law, the attempt adds to the perception that its prime motivation isopportunistic politics.
And given the party`s poor governance record, the move strengthens the general view that the administration is concerned with narrow interests rather than the national interest. Public sentiment on the issue is apparent, and is no doubt in part responsible for the stand taken by some members of the coalition as well as the opposition both inside and outside parliament. So with all the other issues the party is currently dealing with, from pressure due to the reopening of Nato supply routes to the NRO implementation case, pursuing this matter doesn`t appear to make sense.
There is also the matter of the principle involved, which the government should ultimately be focusing on. At this point in its turbulent history, and given the widespread lack of faith in politicians among the Pakistani public, why should dual nationality holders not be willing to give up their foreign passports if they want to take on public office? This is one fight the government would do well to reconsider.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)