Thursday, July 26, 2012

Samosa Justics

THE days of the cheap samosa are over. While the savoury little delight is consumed with great relish by Pakistanis around the year, sales of the samosa skyrocket during Ramazan as it is a staple of the iftar spread. However, the Supreme Court has set aside a notification of the Punjab government regulating the price of samosas.

As reported in the media, in 2009 the Lahore local government had fixed the price of the crispy delight at Rs6 a samosa. The local government`s machinery took action against some shopkeepers found to be selling more expensive samosas. However, not satisfied with the price set for their product, the bakers and sweet-makers of the Punjab went to court.

When the Lahore High Court turned down their petition, the bakers appealed to the Supreme Court. They felt the samosa did not fall within the purview of the Punjab Foodstuffs (Control) Act, 1958, hence the government could not fix itsprices, a notion the apex court seemed to agree with.

While the commercial bakers will rejoice at the verdict, others waiting for justice in Pakistan`s everclogged judicial system may be wondering when their turn will come. With a question of interpretation of a law at stake, the Supreme Court was the ultimate forum for resolving the matter, however trifling it may appear to the average citizen. The question, then, is whether the superior judiciary should devise some rules and a system to fast-track more urgent and serious matters for justice rather than spend valuable time on a regulation that is virtually unenforceable in any case the proof of that being a visit to any market in Lahore where samosas are openly being sold for much higher than Rs6. Samosa-makers may be happy and another case struck from the superior judiciary`s docket, but was it the court`s best use of time at this stage?

SC Restraint

WITH apprehensions running high and speculation running wild, something needed to be done to lower the political temperature. That something came from the Supreme Court yesterday in the form of an accommodating and conciliatory hearing in the NRO implementation case. Without giving any specific directions, the court essentially asked the government to find a compromise and return on Aug 8 with some kind of solution to the writing of the so-called Swiss letter.

What could a compromise look like? Perhaps just writing to Swiss authorities that the state of Pakistan no longer considers the letter written by the Musharraf-era attorney general, Malik Qayyum, to be legally valid. By stopping at that and not going on to specifically say that the state of Pakistan renews its request for legal assistance, wants once more to secure its status as a civil party in any revived proceedings against President Zardari in Switzerland and is once again laying a claim to the money that was once lodged in the Swiss accounts and which allegedly belonged to Mr Zardari, a compromise of sorts could be fashioned the Malik Qayyum letter would stand void but the Swiss would not have to consider whether to restart the proceedings against the president. Will the government meet the court halfway now andsave its second prime minister and the country from more political instability? The country will know more between now and Aug 8 on that front.

The government should think hard about how it wants to proceed. Welcome as the court`s restraint is, it is unlikely to last indefinitely. At least two reasons other than perhaps a change of heart at this late stage can be discerned for the court`s soft approach yesterday.

One, the Supreme Court hearings into the new contempt law passed by the government to try and protect Prime Minister Ashraf are still continuing.

While that matter has yet to be decided, contempt proceedings against him would be difficult to initiate after all, were the court to choose to move against Mr Ashraf, would it do so under the old, presently repealed law, or the new, presently under-challenge law? Two, after having suffered strident and increasingly direct criticism, the court may be aware that it has to tread softly at the moment. Throwing the ball into the government`s court to find an acceptable compromise now will make it more difficult for blame to be pinned on the judiciary later were Prime Minister Ashraf also to find himself in the dock.

Now is the time, then, for the government to compromise to disperse the clouds obscuring the election on the horizon.

Wednesday, July 25, 2012

بساط الٹ چکی ہے - اوریا مقبول جان

Sialkot FootBall in Olympics

PAKISTAN will not be a part of football matches at the Olympics, but footballs manufactured in Sialkot will. After a Chinese machine-made ball was selected for the 2010 World Cup in South Africa, breaking years of Pakistani domination, Sialkot`s official selection as producer for the Olympics should please Pakistani fans of the game and serve as a morale booster for the Sialkot sportsmanufacturing industry.

Until 2000, Pakistan was the world leader in football production. But several factors, including global concerns about child labour, competition from China and Thailand, and production issues related to the power crisis have reduced the country`s share considerably. The Chinese ball used in 2010 had come under intense criticism from leading players, and the selection of the colourful Sialkoti ball for the Olympics instead is a sign that despite the industry`s difficulties Pakistani footballs were able to meetplayers` needs and that leading multinational sports brands continue to look to Sialkot for world-class footballs.

The challenge now is to regain the city`s slot as world leader in the sector.

Proper attention paid to Sialkot`s sports-manufacturing sector can not only provide much-needed jobs and bring in valuable foreign exchange, it could also help improve Pakistan`s unenviable global public image. Manufacturers need to be able to compete with the savvy and technology of foreign producers while adhering to global standards against child labour.

The power shortage is, of course, a national issue and needs to be addressed from the top. With commitment to quality and proper marketing, it should be possible for Sialkot to recapture its share in the global sports market. In the meantime, we should celebrate the contribution Pakistan will make to global sporting competition this summer.

fake identity documents

A BRITISH tabloid`s exposé of the ease of obtaining fake identity documents and UK visas in Pakistan has become a scandal of international proportions because of its link with the upcoming Olympics. But the problem is not a new one. Despite the money and expertise that has been poured into modernising CNICs and passports in recent years, getting hold of fake ones remains shockingly easy.

The old days of manual processes for creating these documents are long gone.

But even now, when they are computerised and managed through automated processes and electronic databases, the systems which apparently meet international standards remain vulnerable to corruption. If you can find an agent with the right links inside Nadra and the passport directorate, procuring another person`s identity is simple enough for anyone willing to pay a price.

And as long as it doesn`t crack down hard enough on people on the inside who are willing to tamper with the process, Nadra, where the CNICs that become the basis for fake passports originate, has limited options. It can continue building more sophisticated checks into the system, but much of the technology used is already world-class, including software that carries out fingerprint and photograph matching.

Ultimately, the problem comes down to corrupt individuals being willing to manually override systemsand tamper with records for a fee. While there have been multiple raids within Nadra over the years, many of which don`t make it into the media, they have obviously not been effective enough as deterrents.

Fixing responsibility is not difficult the names of operators are entered at every step of the process so this seems to be a simple enough matter of being more vigilant about detecting irregularities and cracking down more frequently on operators on the inside and agents on the outside.

Despite the implication that the UK visa scam could have been used to smuggle terrorists into the Olympics, at the moment this seems like pure speculation. And the history of Islamist terrorist attacks in the UK indicates that it is largely a home-grown problem there. But for Pakistan itself, this is a national-security matter. Fake Pakistani documents have been found on foreign terrorists, including former Iranian Jundullah head Abdolmalek Rigi and Ramzi Yousef, and been used by members of banned Pakistani outfits to leave the country.

So while such forgeries take place in other countries too, in Pakistan`s case they are particularly risky, further damaging its international reputation and allowing domestic militants to get away. World-class systems may be in place, but Nadra and the passport directorate need to carry out some significant housecleaning.

Afghanistan`s refusal to act against militant sanctuaries in Kunar and Nuristan

SLAMABAD, July 24: Afghanistan`s refusal to act against militant sanctuaries in Kunar and Nuristan provinces has left the Pakistan government frustrated.

When Prime Minister Raja Pervez Ashraf visited Kabul last week, one of his main objectives was to get a firm commitment from his host, President Hamid Karzai, that he would act against militants` sanctuaries in eastern Afghan provinces of Kunar and Nuristan from where terrorists have launched15 attacks against Pakistani border posts and villages over the past year, killing 105 soldiers and civilians.

A member of Pakistani del-egation said the issue was `strongly` raised by Prime Minister Ashraf.

But, the prime minister found Mr Karzai unwilling to act unconditionally against militants` hideouts on his territory.

Afghans, who have apparently stiffened their stance on militant havens, did not even allow the Pakistanis to mention the matter in the joint statement issued after the Ashraf-Karzai meeting.

Observing diplomatic niceties, Mr Karzai had only agreed on setting up a factfinding body of senior officials from both sides.

Senior officials of the Karzai administration have, during conversation with Pakistani officials, beenlately admitting the presence of Mullah Fazlullah and other Pakistani militant commanders in the eastern provinces.

The militants had taken refuge in Afghan villages along the border after fleeing military operations in Swat and Bajaur.

The issue of sanctuaries has been on Pakistan`s priority list not only because of the casualties suffered because of militant attacks, but also because of the risk they pose to the progress they have achieved in their counter-militancy efforts.

A Pakistani source noted that these sanctuaries were not only causing problems for Pakistanis, but local Afghans were also against their presence in their villages.

Some of the locals had initially accommodated them but have now turned against them.

However, it is believed that some political considerations are stopping the Afghan government from evicting the terrorists from the area.

Even prior to Mr Ashraf`s meeting with the Afghan president, the issue had been raised with Isaf commander Gen John Allen, at the diplomatic level and during meetings of border coordination centre. However, Islamabad has consistently failed to get a sympathetic ear.Isaf and Afghan officials have told Pakistani interlocutors that the coalition and Afghan forces were too preoccupied with operations in other areas to secure the eastern region.

The army has quite often responded to militant attacks by firing rockets at terrorists fleeing back to their sanctuaries across the border.

But the shellings have served only to provoke a strong reaction from Kabul which over the weekend warned that future incidents would seriously harm relations.

The senior military brass have now started believing that the Afghans were not acting against sanctuaries held by Pakistani militants inresponse to perceived Pakistan`s inaction against havens of Afghan militants in tribal areas.

A senior military official said it was a tactical plan of the NDS (National Directorate of Security).

There is no direct evidence of Isaf`s involvement with the Pakistani militants, another official noted.

Pakistan Army, however, is playing a `wait and see` game to fully comprehend the Afghan game plan. For now they are concentrating on reinforcing the borders and strengthen defences.

`It is a clear sign that the militants have so far failed to dent the security situation in the region despite the attacks,` an official said.

Plea on NRO case returned with objection Govt stance on Swiss letter unchanged

ISLAMABAD, July 24: A day ahead of the hearing of NRO implementation case by a five-judge Supreme Court bench, the federal government filed on Tuesday an application in which it unequivocally stated that it would not write a letter to the Swiss authorities to reopen graft cases against President Asif Zardari.

But the response drafted by Attorney General Irfan Qadir after holding brainstorming sessions with Prime Minister Raja Pervez Ashraf and Law Minister Farooq H. Naek on Monday night was returned by the court office with an objection that a civil miscellaneous application could not be filed against a court decision, although a petition seeking review of an earlier order was possible.

Mr Qadir told reporters that he would move a review petition possibly Wednesday with contentions similar to that contained in the application, reflecting the government`s mood that it was not going to budge from its stance on NRO implementation.

`The prime minister cannot be asked by means of the July 12 order to implement an un-implementable directiongiven by the Supreme Court in the NRO case,` said the application returned by the court. It requested the court to recall its June 27 and July 12 orders asking the prime minister to clarify his stance on implementing the NRO verdict.

On July 12, the special bench headed by Justice Asif Saeed Khosa had asked the prime minister to submit a report about compliance with the NRO judgment which required writing the letter to Swiss authorities. The court • Legal brains in a fix: Page 3 • Scope of immunity clause widened: Page 14 also warned that it could initiate any appropriate action under the Constitution if the government failed to comply with its orders.

`There is no question whatsoever ofrevivalofPakistan`s status as a damaged party (writing of letter to the Swiss authorities) because the Supreme Court`s own jurisdiction is limited to the territories of Pakistan,` the application said, adding that if the apex court itself was not in a position to seek revival of Pakistan`s status as a damaged party then it also had no mandate to force the prime minister to do the same. `In fact after the conclusion of Swiss investigations Pakistan has no role to play in these matters. There was no occasion for the seven-judgeSupreme Court hearing a contempt case against the former prime minister to have called him thrice in the court. This is an utter disregard of the Constitution and the law,` the application said.

It also argued that since the new prime minister had not received any advice from his cabinet to implement the NRO judgment, he (prime minister) was, therefore, not obliged under the Constitution and the rules of business to do so.

The application said the June 27 and July 12 orders were against Article 248 (1 and 2) (immunity) because the prime minister by virtue of his oath was bound to preserve and protect the Constitution and was under constitutional obligation to disregard any order of the court which negated the Constitution and the law.

The application pointed out certain peculiarities of the NRO case and said: `In this case over 8,000 persons were condemned unheard.

The government did not contest this case. Seventeen judges sat for a considerably long period in a case not contested by either side at all. .

The Supreme Court assumed full control of NAB, thereby transgressing into executive domain.

It said a number of portions of paragraphs 177, 178 and 179 (writing of letter to the Swiss authorities) were not implementable. `In fact such portions have not been implemented till date,` it said