WASHINGTON, Dec 11: Pakistan has signalled its readiness to deal with
terrorists operating within its borders as well as with those who cross
over to Afghanistan, US Defence Secretary Leon Panetta said on Tuesday.
The
statement followed a clarification by officials of the Defence and
State Departments of a Pentagon report that tended to create an
impression that Pakistan was still allowing terrorist safe havens in
Fata to operate.
The officials said the report was old and since
then Pakistan had carried out several `complementary operations` with
Afghan and Nato forces against the terrorists.
`We are more
encouraged with the fact that they want to take steps to try to limit
the terrorist threat within their own country and obviously the threat
that goes across the border` to Afghanistan, Mr Panetta told reporters
travelling with him to Kuwait.He said that army chief Gen Ashfaq Parvez
Kayani had `indicated a willingness to try to put more pressure on safe
havens` While `actions have to speak louder than words, I do believe
they`re in a better place because they understand the kind of threats
they should deal with,` Mr Panetta added.
A Pentagon report,
released to the media on Monday but sent to Congress three months ago,
had alleged that terrorist safe havens in Fata were preventing US and
allied forces from dealing a `decisive defeat` to militants inside
Afghanistan.
`The Taliban-led insurgency and its Al Qaeda
affiliates still operate from sanctuaries in Pakistan,` the report
claimed. `The insurgency`s safe havens in Pakistan, the limited
institutional capacity of the Afghan government and endemic corruption
remain the greatest risks tolong-term stability and sustainable security
in Afghanistan.
The Pakistan Embassy in Washington drew the
Pentagon`s attention to the report, widely publicised by the media,
pointing out that it did not reflect the improvements that have occurred
since July this year.
In July, the United States had apologised
to Pakistan over an air raid that killed 24 Pakistani soldiers last year
and Islamabad reopened the supply routes to Afghanistan it had closed
after the attack.
Since then the two countries have taken a
number of steps to improve ties and this month they held a series of
working group meetings to restart the US-Pakistan strategic dialogue
after more than a year.
Secretary Panetta also acknowledged that
Pakistan was helping Afghanistan in talking to the Taliban for seeking a
peaceful solution to the Afghan conflict.
But reconciliation with the Taliban, he said, was not easy because of the number of factions involved in the conflict.
`We
have to at least make the effort to develop some kind of political
solution as well as the military effort we are engaged in.
PENTAGON
REPORT CLARIFIED: At the Pentagon, two senior Defence and State
Department officialsbriefed the media on the report sent to Congress,
explaining that relations with Pakistan had improved considerably since
the reporting period.
The report was apparently prepared before July, when the two countries took several significant steps to improve ties.
`We`re
very encouraged by the dialogue that`s taking place between Afghanistan
and Pakistan. And an important and essential part of that dialogue is
the cross-border situation,` said a senior State Department official.
`So
we hope that dialogue will continue. We hope and expect to see
confidencebuilding measures from both the Afghans, and the Pakistanis.
The
United States wants to encourage that dialogue is in the interest of
peace and stability `to the extent that can be helpful`, he said.
`Cooperation with Pakistan has improved during this reporting period.
Pakistan
agreed to reopen the ground lines of communication, which were closed
in November of last year, observed a senior Defence Department official.
Meetings
with Pakistan, both bilaterally between ISAF forces, and Pakistani
military forces, and trilaterally with Afghan military forces, were also
going well, he added.
The official noted that NATO forces were
now conducting `a growing number of complementary operations` with
Pakistan, which in the last reporting had virtually ceased.
`At
the same time, I don`t want to leave you with the impression that we
think everything is working well, because the safe havens do continue to
exist,` the official warned.
Wednesday, December 12, 2012
Pakistan ready to act against safe havens: US
Thursday, November 29, 2012
New tax on CNG planned
ISLAMABAD, Nov 28: The government is considering to impose a new tax on
compressed naturalgas to reduce the price difference between CNG and
petrol in order to phase outtheuse ofthe gasin private transport.
`The government has planned to phase out CNG stations gradually as they are causing heavy loss to the national economy by wasting this valuable commodity (natural gas), instead of its use for industrialisation and investment and domestic use, Prime Minister`s Adviser on Petroleum Dr Asim Hussain told the National Assembly`s Standing Committee onPetroleum on Wednesday.
The country does not have sufficient or surplus gas reserves to allow it to be burnt in private and luxury vehicles.
He said the government wanted to set equitable prices for all fuels and allow only a reasonable profit to owners of CNG stations.
He said the CNG should only be used by public transport and private vehicles should be discouraged from burning the cheaper fuel.
To achieve this goal, he indicated imposition of a new tax but did not give details.
The committee headed by Muhammad Tariq Khattak asked the petroleum ministryto come up with a solution by Dec 5 and play the role of a mediator between the CNG station owners and the Oil and Gas Regulatory Authority (Ogra) in fixing a reasonable price to mitigate people`s difficulties.
It expressed concern over closure of CNG stations and the disagreement over the pricing mechanism.
Dr Asim said Ogra had failed to play the role of a regulator. The government increased the wellhead gas price to $6 which boosted exploration work and 40 rigs were operating in the country. He said 30,000 barrels of oil from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa would start flowing into the national system by March next year.
He said the department of explosives that granted no-objection certificate to CNG and petrol stations was under the industries ministry where officials received bribes to issue laboratory certificates. The petroleum ministry, he said, had initiated a legislation to bring the department under its control.
The parliamentarians expressed concern over recent explosions in CNGfitted vehicles and wondered what role the department of explosives and the Hydrocarbon Development Institute played in allowing substandard cylinders.
The members said that while Ogra and the station owners were taking extreme positions, the consumers were forced to spend a major part of their day in long queues to get CNG.
Some members called for a national debate to determine if there was sufficient gas available for vehicles or it should be used only for value-added sectors so that a clear roadmap could be followed and confusion and people`s difficulties removed.
MNA Rana Afzaal Hussain said the CNG Association had become a cartel and minted millions ofrupees at the cost ofpeople. He wondered why 100 per cent profit was promised in the agreement the government had reached with the CNG sector in 2008.
`The government has planned to phase out CNG stations gradually as they are causing heavy loss to the national economy by wasting this valuable commodity (natural gas), instead of its use for industrialisation and investment and domestic use, Prime Minister`s Adviser on Petroleum Dr Asim Hussain told the National Assembly`s Standing Committee onPetroleum on Wednesday.
The country does not have sufficient or surplus gas reserves to allow it to be burnt in private and luxury vehicles.
He said the government wanted to set equitable prices for all fuels and allow only a reasonable profit to owners of CNG stations.
He said the CNG should only be used by public transport and private vehicles should be discouraged from burning the cheaper fuel.
To achieve this goal, he indicated imposition of a new tax but did not give details.
The committee headed by Muhammad Tariq Khattak asked the petroleum ministryto come up with a solution by Dec 5 and play the role of a mediator between the CNG station owners and the Oil and Gas Regulatory Authority (Ogra) in fixing a reasonable price to mitigate people`s difficulties.
It expressed concern over closure of CNG stations and the disagreement over the pricing mechanism.
Dr Asim said Ogra had failed to play the role of a regulator. The government increased the wellhead gas price to $6 which boosted exploration work and 40 rigs were operating in the country. He said 30,000 barrels of oil from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa would start flowing into the national system by March next year.
He said the department of explosives that granted no-objection certificate to CNG and petrol stations was under the industries ministry where officials received bribes to issue laboratory certificates. The petroleum ministry, he said, had initiated a legislation to bring the department under its control.
The parliamentarians expressed concern over recent explosions in CNGfitted vehicles and wondered what role the department of explosives and the Hydrocarbon Development Institute played in allowing substandard cylinders.
The members said that while Ogra and the station owners were taking extreme positions, the consumers were forced to spend a major part of their day in long queues to get CNG.
Some members called for a national debate to determine if there was sufficient gas available for vehicles or it should be used only for value-added sectors so that a clear roadmap could be followed and confusion and people`s difficulties removed.
MNA Rana Afzaal Hussain said the CNG Association had become a cartel and minted millions ofrupees at the cost ofpeople. He wondered why 100 per cent profit was promised in the agreement the government had reached with the CNG sector in 2008.
Tuesday, November 13, 2012
Saving the saviours ( the bomb disposal squad is at risk)
WHILE the security situation has been derailed across the country over
the past decade or so, it is Khyber Pakhtunkhwa that has borne the brunt
of increasing incidents of bombing. Lives are not only lost when
terrorists hit security or civilian targets; even the bomb disposal
squad is at risk when it attempts to defuse an unexploded device. The
latter point was underscored by the death of explosives expert Inspector
Hukam Khan who was killed while defusing an IED device in September.
The incident highlighted the fact that bomb disposal is a potentially
lethal line of work and each attempt at defusing explosives is haunted
by potential tragedy. It is fitting, then, that yesterday`s newspapers
carried photographs of the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa police department
initiating the use of robotic systems operated remotely through a
computer interface and capable of defusing explosive devices. Purchased
from the British government, the robotic systems can scan a suspicious
object or vehicleand defuse explosives if present. Equipped with camera
sensors and with the capability to dig up explosives, they can be used
for dealing with IEDs, bombs, parcel bombs and vehicles rigged with
explosives. Indeed, on Monday such a robot was used to defuse a device
in Peshawar`s Nasirpur area.
Police departments all across the country, particularly in metropolises where bomb attacks are common, need to be equipped with such technology. The hard fact is that militants and terrorists are conversant with technology of various kinds for their grim purposes from cellular communication tools to the Internet to ever-mutating methods of blowing things up. Worryingly, however, the country`s law-enforcement agencies, particularly on the civilian side, continue to operate with archaic methodologies and insufficient technology. Investing in machines and systems that can help save lives and avert tragedy is expensive, but the country`s hostile and worsening climate demands just this.
Police departments all across the country, particularly in metropolises where bomb attacks are common, need to be equipped with such technology. The hard fact is that militants and terrorists are conversant with technology of various kinds for their grim purposes from cellular communication tools to the Internet to ever-mutating methods of blowing things up. Worryingly, however, the country`s law-enforcement agencies, particularly on the civilian side, continue to operate with archaic methodologies and insufficient technology. Investing in machines and systems that can help save lives and avert tragedy is expensive, but the country`s hostile and worsening climate demands just this.
karachi- new wave of violence
EVEN as the law and order situation in Karachi gets increasingly out of
hand dozens have been killed since the start of the weekend the reaction
to the sectarian violence that has flared up has been as inadequate as
the usual response to political violence in the city. When clashes erupt
between activists of ethnic or mainstream political parties, those
parties let a certain amount of bloodshed take place before they hammer
out a deal and then issue instructions to their workers or affiliates to
retreat.
While that process is taking place, law enforcement appears to be at a complete loss as it sits back, taking only reactive action, and waits for the politicians to sort out the mess. Meanwhile, the interior minister blames mysterious and unnamed external forces.
As sectarian clashes now dominate the Karachi headlines, a similar pattern of response or lack thereof seems to be emerging.
In this case it is the ulema who are issuing empty platitudes in public while in reality being unable or unwilling to order their followers to stop the bloodbath. Over the weekend the Milli Yakjehti Council met in Islamabad not in Karachi, where a meeting of this particular organisation, meant to promote cooperation across sects, would have sent a strong signal against sectarian violence. And while it discussed everythingfrom the role of religious parties in Pakistani politics to unity of Muslims across the world to supporting the blasphemy laws, what got lost in all this talk was the carnage taking place in Karachi, which should have been thefocus of the meeting. A couple of days later, the interior minister made the rather remarkable assertion that there is no sectarian conflict in Karachi and that the recent clashes are being carried out by `invisible forces`. He said this after another meeting of the ulema again held in Islamabad.
The upshot of all this is that officials and leaders appear to be doing nothing, leaving an illequipped, poorly trained and understaffed lawenforcement structure to react to incidents once they have already taken place. Putting in place extraordinary Muharram security arrangements is a necessary step, but that is only a short-term fix. What it will not improve is the fundamental inability of law enforcement to tackle a problem that is simply beyond its scope;even the army is now vulnerable to anti-state groups, and the Rangers have demonstrated that they cannot fill the void created by an undermanned and easily influenced police force. As long as the ulema and the government fail to develop a more lasting political solution, there is only so much any of these organisations can do
While that process is taking place, law enforcement appears to be at a complete loss as it sits back, taking only reactive action, and waits for the politicians to sort out the mess. Meanwhile, the interior minister blames mysterious and unnamed external forces.
As sectarian clashes now dominate the Karachi headlines, a similar pattern of response or lack thereof seems to be emerging.
In this case it is the ulema who are issuing empty platitudes in public while in reality being unable or unwilling to order their followers to stop the bloodbath. Over the weekend the Milli Yakjehti Council met in Islamabad not in Karachi, where a meeting of this particular organisation, meant to promote cooperation across sects, would have sent a strong signal against sectarian violence. And while it discussed everythingfrom the role of religious parties in Pakistani politics to unity of Muslims across the world to supporting the blasphemy laws, what got lost in all this talk was the carnage taking place in Karachi, which should have been thefocus of the meeting. A couple of days later, the interior minister made the rather remarkable assertion that there is no sectarian conflict in Karachi and that the recent clashes are being carried out by `invisible forces`. He said this after another meeting of the ulema again held in Islamabad.
The upshot of all this is that officials and leaders appear to be doing nothing, leaving an illequipped, poorly trained and understaffed lawenforcement structure to react to incidents once they have already taken place. Putting in place extraordinary Muharram security arrangements is a necessary step, but that is only a short-term fix. What it will not improve is the fundamental inability of law enforcement to tackle a problem that is simply beyond its scope;even the army is now vulnerable to anti-state groups, and the Rangers have demonstrated that they cannot fill the void created by an undermanned and easily influenced police force. As long as the ulema and the government fail to develop a more lasting political solution, there is only so much any of these organisations can do
the good qualities of west
IN one of the provinces of Canada the electricity bill is delivered
after every two months. Owing to the use of the central heating system
the bill charges rise three to four times in winters as compared to the
rest of the seasons.
As my semester was to conclude at the end ofJune 2009,Ireturned to Pakistan. Since my electricity bill for May and June wouldn`t have been delivered before the first week of July and my flight back home was at the end of June, I decided to make the bill payment in advance.
I wrote the cheque for an amount exceeding even that of our last bill for (winter) months of March and April, though there was no need for showing such generosity as I had not used the central heating system in May and June). I did that as I did not want ourhost country authorities to have the slightest idea that we had cheated them.
On the same note, like my university, bank, insurance, Internet and telephone company and mobile phone service provider, I had also apprised the electricity company about my address in Pakistan in case a need arises to settle the bills.
However, to my surprise and delight, in August and then in November 2009 I received two cheques from our electricity company.
I have personally known a number of people, including doctors and engineers who got loans worth thousands of pounds from banks abroad, never to return the same, before going back to Pakistan.
On the other hand, there are institutions like our electricitycompany in Canada which gladly returned almost 100 Canadian dollars to me without any demand and that too to an ex-consumer who is not even residing in Canada.
I feel pity for the West bashers, the majority of whom might not have even gone beyond their provincial territories but feel it their birthright to condemn the West for their say one per cent evil deeds and very conveniently overlook 99 per cent of their traits like honesty, justice, fairness and, above all, respect for humanity without any discrimination.
Lastly, I pity this mob of most ignorant hooligans who burn down their own abodes just to condemn sheer acts of stupidity committed by some lunatics thousands of miles away.
MAKHDOOM SAIF Islamabad
As my semester was to conclude at the end ofJune 2009,Ireturned to Pakistan. Since my electricity bill for May and June wouldn`t have been delivered before the first week of July and my flight back home was at the end of June, I decided to make the bill payment in advance.
I wrote the cheque for an amount exceeding even that of our last bill for (winter) months of March and April, though there was no need for showing such generosity as I had not used the central heating system in May and June). I did that as I did not want ourhost country authorities to have the slightest idea that we had cheated them.
On the same note, like my university, bank, insurance, Internet and telephone company and mobile phone service provider, I had also apprised the electricity company about my address in Pakistan in case a need arises to settle the bills.
However, to my surprise and delight, in August and then in November 2009 I received two cheques from our electricity company.
I have personally known a number of people, including doctors and engineers who got loans worth thousands of pounds from banks abroad, never to return the same, before going back to Pakistan.
On the other hand, there are institutions like our electricitycompany in Canada which gladly returned almost 100 Canadian dollars to me without any demand and that too to an ex-consumer who is not even residing in Canada.
I feel pity for the West bashers, the majority of whom might not have even gone beyond their provincial territories but feel it their birthright to condemn the West for their say one per cent evil deeds and very conveniently overlook 99 per cent of their traits like honesty, justice, fairness and, above all, respect for humanity without any discrimination.
Lastly, I pity this mob of most ignorant hooligans who burn down their own abodes just to condemn sheer acts of stupidity committed by some lunatics thousands of miles away.
MAKHDOOM SAIF Islamabad
private school vs government schools
PRIVATE schools are better than public schools. This is an established
fact in the urban areas of Pakistan. Now this trend is also seen taking
place among the rural population, as the demand for private schools is
increasing. The main reason is the belief that the quality of education
and facilities in these schools is better than that of their
public-sector counterparts.
But is that really the case? Recent studies show that there definitely is a difference in the quality of education between the two sectors, measured by the difference in the learning-level outcomes of the students.
Students studying in privately-owned schools in the rural areas perform better atevery level of schooling as compared to the students from the same grade levels in government schools.
However, the alarming feature that needs to be noted is that the difference between the two education providers is negligible at best.
Using the information from a survey of 32 districts across the country by ASER 2010, it was seen that any child going to a private school has less than four per cent probability of having better learning levels as compared to a child going to a government school. The difference is minute.
This is the case because private schools have no incentive to improve any further than the bare minimum that is required forthem to attract demand.
The quality of government schools is the benchmark for the private sector education providers, above which they have no incentive to further improve their facilities or other quality indicators.
The pre-conceived notion of private schools being always better than government schools is contradicted by the evidence from ASER 2010 facilities` statistics where other than the availability of water and toilet facilities, private schools have no edge over government schools.
In case of the number of classrooms, availability of playgrounds, boundary wall and the attendance of teachers, private schoolsare not only at similar levels but are even worse off than government schools in some provinces.
The poor quality of education and facilities is not just an issue in government schools but for the whole educational system. There is not only a need to alter the popular notion that private schools are always better than government schools but also to work on improving the quality of learning in both types of school.
Improving quality in government schools, and regulating and setting standards for the private sector is the need of the hour.
But is that really the case? Recent studies show that there definitely is a difference in the quality of education between the two sectors, measured by the difference in the learning-level outcomes of the students.
Students studying in privately-owned schools in the rural areas perform better atevery level of schooling as compared to the students from the same grade levels in government schools.
However, the alarming feature that needs to be noted is that the difference between the two education providers is negligible at best.
Using the information from a survey of 32 districts across the country by ASER 2010, it was seen that any child going to a private school has less than four per cent probability of having better learning levels as compared to a child going to a government school. The difference is minute.
This is the case because private schools have no incentive to improve any further than the bare minimum that is required forthem to attract demand.
The quality of government schools is the benchmark for the private sector education providers, above which they have no incentive to further improve their facilities or other quality indicators.
The pre-conceived notion of private schools being always better than government schools is contradicted by the evidence from ASER 2010 facilities` statistics where other than the availability of water and toilet facilities, private schools have no edge over government schools.
In case of the number of classrooms, availability of playgrounds, boundary wall and the attendance of teachers, private schoolsare not only at similar levels but are even worse off than government schools in some provinces.
The poor quality of education and facilities is not just an issue in government schools but for the whole educational system. There is not only a need to alter the popular notion that private schools are always better than government schools but also to work on improving the quality of learning in both types of school.
Improving quality in government schools, and regulating and setting standards for the private sector is the need of the hour.
Pakistan agrees to set free Taliban leaders
SLAMABAD, Nov 13: In an unprecedented gesture of support for
Afghanistan`s struggling reconciliation process, Pakistan agreed on
Tuesday to release several Taliban leaders detained in the country`s
jails.
The development, which hasn`t been made public by either side, came on the second day of Afghan High Peace Council Chief Mr Salahuddin Rabbani`s three-day visit to Islamabad to re-start the peace process which has been in the limbo for over a year now.
It was unclear if the detainees, who are said to be numbering close to 10, have been set free on Tuesday or would be released at the conclusion of Mr Rabbani`s visit.
The group, according to a source, does not include Mullah Baradar Taliban`s second in command who was captured by Pakistani security forces in Karachi in 2010.
Talks between the peace delegation led by Mr Rabbani and Pakistani officials would continue on Wednesday when the two sides are expected to come up with a joint statement on the progress made by them.
A Pakistani official, who had been briefed on the talks, told Dawn that `significant progress has already been made`.
The release of Taliban detainees in Pakistan has been a longstanding Afghan demand for catalysing the slow moving process.
A keen follower of the negotiations, who didn`t want to be named, said the release of prisoners was a positive step, which would provide the right environment for reconciliation.
Islamabad has long said that it supportedpeace and stability in Afghanistan, but has been holding back its cards in view of lack of clarity about the peace process with Taliban both in Kabul and Washington.
However, with the drawdown deadline approaching fast and all sorts of unfavourable scenarios for Pakistan being projected (with the assumption that instability in Afghanistan would continue), the government appears to have changed its tack and decided to more proactively support the process for the sake of its success. It is more than clear to Pakistani strategists that successful reconciliation in Afghanistan is their best bet.
Dr Maleeha Lodhi, Pakistan`s former envoy to US and UK, had last week told the Senate Standing Committee on Defence that absence of a political settlement in Afghanistan `could lead to disastrous consequences for the region, especially for Pakistan, which is already reeling from over three decades of turmoil and conflict in its western neighbour`.
President Asif Ali Zardari in his meeting with the Afghan peace delegation reiterated the government`s position that Pakistan would continue to extend every possible support to Afghanistan in its journey to peace and socio-economic development.
Mr Zardari noted that a peaceful, stable and economically developed Afghanistan was vital for Pakistan`s own stability and prosperity.
The delegation also called on Army Chief Gen Ashfaq Pervez Kayani at the military headquarters in Rawalpindi. Mr Rabbani was invariably reminded by all his interlocutors in Islamabad that trust deficit remained to be addressed and that cross-border shelling by Afghanistan was adding to problems in ties.
The development, which hasn`t been made public by either side, came on the second day of Afghan High Peace Council Chief Mr Salahuddin Rabbani`s three-day visit to Islamabad to re-start the peace process which has been in the limbo for over a year now.
It was unclear if the detainees, who are said to be numbering close to 10, have been set free on Tuesday or would be released at the conclusion of Mr Rabbani`s visit.
The group, according to a source, does not include Mullah Baradar Taliban`s second in command who was captured by Pakistani security forces in Karachi in 2010.
Talks between the peace delegation led by Mr Rabbani and Pakistani officials would continue on Wednesday when the two sides are expected to come up with a joint statement on the progress made by them.
A Pakistani official, who had been briefed on the talks, told Dawn that `significant progress has already been made`.
The release of Taliban detainees in Pakistan has been a longstanding Afghan demand for catalysing the slow moving process.
A keen follower of the negotiations, who didn`t want to be named, said the release of prisoners was a positive step, which would provide the right environment for reconciliation.
Islamabad has long said that it supportedpeace and stability in Afghanistan, but has been holding back its cards in view of lack of clarity about the peace process with Taliban both in Kabul and Washington.
However, with the drawdown deadline approaching fast and all sorts of unfavourable scenarios for Pakistan being projected (with the assumption that instability in Afghanistan would continue), the government appears to have changed its tack and decided to more proactively support the process for the sake of its success. It is more than clear to Pakistani strategists that successful reconciliation in Afghanistan is their best bet.
Dr Maleeha Lodhi, Pakistan`s former envoy to US and UK, had last week told the Senate Standing Committee on Defence that absence of a political settlement in Afghanistan `could lead to disastrous consequences for the region, especially for Pakistan, which is already reeling from over three decades of turmoil and conflict in its western neighbour`.
President Asif Ali Zardari in his meeting with the Afghan peace delegation reiterated the government`s position that Pakistan would continue to extend every possible support to Afghanistan in its journey to peace and socio-economic development.
Mr Zardari noted that a peaceful, stable and economically developed Afghanistan was vital for Pakistan`s own stability and prosperity.
The delegation also called on Army Chief Gen Ashfaq Pervez Kayani at the military headquarters in Rawalpindi. Mr Rabbani was invariably reminded by all his interlocutors in Islamabad that trust deficit remained to be addressed and that cross-border shelling by Afghanistan was adding to problems in ties.
education is the only way out
SINCE years we have been in a state of war. ...[There are] bomb blasts,
suicide attacks, passengers travelling by bus being made to disembark
and then shot dead on sectarian grounds. ...This has become the order of
the day. In rural areas there are tribal feuds and ethnic conflict. It
seems as if this state has become a nursery for riots where ...
clashesand conflicts are growing. This continues regardless of whether
there is a democratic era or dictatorship in thecountry. In a
dictatorship, the bureaucracy calls the shots, while in a democracy
chieftains, feudals ... enjoy power.
Neither dictatorship nor democracy has changed the situation for the common man.
This does not mean that we are opposed to democracy, but we want to point out that elected representatives ... do not follow democratic values.
These feudals cannot be friends of the people. We are unable to promote education.
No outsider is hampering the progress of education, but it is our feudals, chaudhries and waderas who have converted school buildings into cattlepens.... They have neither allowed the middle class to rise nor have they worked in the spirit of democracy. This can also be seen in the recruitment for jobs where no merit is observed. ...[J]obs are handed over to MNAs and MPAs.
Hence jobs are not given on merit but according to political compulsions.... We have a majority of such people in theeducation department.
...President Asif Ali Zardari, while inaugurating the Waseela-iTaleem scheme ..warned that if we failed to impart education to our children history will not forgive us. President Zardari has rightly said that history will not only hold us accountable but the nation will be wiped out [from the world map] if we failed to educate them. Today we are stuck in the quagmire of extremism; the reason behind it is also the lack of education. ...It is painful that we ... spend the budget on purchasing arms. This has destroyed our health and education sectors. ...-(Nov 11) Selected and translated by Sohail Sangi
Neither dictatorship nor democracy has changed the situation for the common man.
This does not mean that we are opposed to democracy, but we want to point out that elected representatives ... do not follow democratic values.
These feudals cannot be friends of the people. We are unable to promote education.
No outsider is hampering the progress of education, but it is our feudals, chaudhries and waderas who have converted school buildings into cattlepens.... They have neither allowed the middle class to rise nor have they worked in the spirit of democracy. This can also be seen in the recruitment for jobs where no merit is observed. ...[J]obs are handed over to MNAs and MPAs.
Hence jobs are not given on merit but according to political compulsions.... We have a majority of such people in theeducation department.
...President Asif Ali Zardari, while inaugurating the Waseela-iTaleem scheme ..warned that if we failed to impart education to our children history will not forgive us. President Zardari has rightly said that history will not only hold us accountable but the nation will be wiped out [from the world map] if we failed to educate them. Today we are stuck in the quagmire of extremism; the reason behind it is also the lack of education. ...It is painful that we ... spend the budget on purchasing arms. This has destroyed our health and education sectors. ...-(Nov 11) Selected and translated by Sohail Sangi
Monday, November 12, 2012
Iran warns US it will act firmly if airspace violated
TEHRAN, Nov 11: Iran warned on Sunday it would react strongly against
any US intrusion into its airspace after two of its warplanes fired at
an American drone 10 days ago, the ISNA news agency reported.
`Yes, we opened fire, and it was with warning shots. If they do it again they can expect an even stronger response,` the agency quoted General Amir-Ali Hadjizadeh, head of the elite Revolutionary Guards air and space forces, as saying.
Pentagon spokesman George Little said on Thursday the Iranian Su-25 Frogfoot fighters fired at the robotic Predator drone on Nov 1 but did not hit it.
`They intercepted the aircraft and fired multiple rounds,` he said.
The American drone was `never in Iranian airspace` and came under fire from the fighter jets off the Iranian coast over international waters, Little said.
In a warning to Tehran, the Pentagon spokesman said the United States was prepared to safeguard its forces.
`We have a wide range of options, from diplomatic to military, to protect our military assets and our forces in the region and will do so when necessary,` Little said.
On Friday, Iranian Defence Minister Ahmad Vahidi confirmed the incident, saying the drone had `entered the space over the territorial waters of the Islamic Republic of Iran in the Persian Gulf area` Hadjizadeh was reported as saying on Sunday: `This spy drone entered Iranian airspace and had to turn around because of the immediate reaction by fighters of the Revolutionary Guards.
He added that the US unmanned aircraft had been `flying over Kharg island to gather information about economic activity on the island, and the arrival and departure of oil tankers.
Kharg, 25 kilometres off the Iranian mainland, is the Islamic republic`s main export terminal for its oil.
The United States and the European Union have both imposed economic sanctions against Iran over its controversial nuclear ambitions which western powers and Israel believe are aimed at producing atomic weapons.
Tehran denies the charge, sayings its programme of uranium enrichment is entirely peaceful and is for energy and medical purposes. The Nov 1 drone incident came less than a week before America`s presidential election, but the Pentagon kept it quiet until reports of the confrontation leaked out.-AFP
`Yes, we opened fire, and it was with warning shots. If they do it again they can expect an even stronger response,` the agency quoted General Amir-Ali Hadjizadeh, head of the elite Revolutionary Guards air and space forces, as saying.
Pentagon spokesman George Little said on Thursday the Iranian Su-25 Frogfoot fighters fired at the robotic Predator drone on Nov 1 but did not hit it.
`They intercepted the aircraft and fired multiple rounds,` he said.
The American drone was `never in Iranian airspace` and came under fire from the fighter jets off the Iranian coast over international waters, Little said.
In a warning to Tehran, the Pentagon spokesman said the United States was prepared to safeguard its forces.
`We have a wide range of options, from diplomatic to military, to protect our military assets and our forces in the region and will do so when necessary,` Little said.
On Friday, Iranian Defence Minister Ahmad Vahidi confirmed the incident, saying the drone had `entered the space over the territorial waters of the Islamic Republic of Iran in the Persian Gulf area` Hadjizadeh was reported as saying on Sunday: `This spy drone entered Iranian airspace and had to turn around because of the immediate reaction by fighters of the Revolutionary Guards.
He added that the US unmanned aircraft had been `flying over Kharg island to gather information about economic activity on the island, and the arrival and departure of oil tankers.
Kharg, 25 kilometres off the Iranian mainland, is the Islamic republic`s main export terminal for its oil.
The United States and the European Union have both imposed economic sanctions against Iran over its controversial nuclear ambitions which western powers and Israel believe are aimed at producing atomic weapons.
Tehran denies the charge, sayings its programme of uranium enrichment is entirely peaceful and is for energy and medical purposes. The Nov 1 drone incident came less than a week before America`s presidential election, but the Pentagon kept it quiet until reports of the confrontation leaked out.-AFP
education and Global Action Day for Malala Yousufzai
AS the world geared up to mark the Global Action Day for Malala
Yousufzai, the Pakistan government launched on Friday a literacy
programme to provide free education to children, primarily girls. The
fouryear Waseela-i-Taleem initiative, undertaken under the umbrella of
the Benazir Income Support Programme, aims to educate three million poor
children, with President Zardari noting during its launch that `no
country can make any progress without investing in its human capital`.
We hope the state remains committed enough to achieve its goals. There
is no doubt that, as report after report has pointed out, Pakistan faces
an education emergency with the young not being able to attend school
due to a wide variety of reasons ranging from convention or poverty to
security as the injuries suffered by Malala so horrifyingly
demonstrated. Not only are there not enough schools in the country,
Pakistan`s dropout rates are much higher andenrolment figures woefully
lower than they should be.
The grim picture of the fate of the next generation, particularly its female members, is drawn in clear lines by the recently released Education for All Global Monitoring Report.
Pakistan is among the bottom 10 countries in terms of education for females in straitened financial circumstances. It was also amongst the last 10 for the amount of time girls spend in schools in their lifetimes, with almost two-thirds of the poorest girls never going to school at all. These figures are cause for serious concern, for coupled with population growth and demographic figures, they point towards a future where growing numbers of people are not just poor but illiterate as well, thus further decreasing opportunities for uplift. Only if the government takes strides towards achieving the Waseela-i-Taleem initiative`s goal can it be considered to have demonstrated its commitment to this crucial sector.
The grim picture of the fate of the next generation, particularly its female members, is drawn in clear lines by the recently released Education for All Global Monitoring Report.
Pakistan is among the bottom 10 countries in terms of education for females in straitened financial circumstances. It was also amongst the last 10 for the amount of time girls spend in schools in their lifetimes, with almost two-thirds of the poorest girls never going to school at all. These figures are cause for serious concern, for coupled with population growth and demographic figures, they point towards a future where growing numbers of people are not just poor but illiterate as well, thus further decreasing opportunities for uplift. Only if the government takes strides towards achieving the Waseela-i-Taleem initiative`s goal can it be considered to have demonstrated its commitment to this crucial sector.
Wednesday, November 7, 2012
In heart of France, Islamic school trains clerics
AINT-LIGER-DE-FOUGERET (France), Nov 6: Deep in the wooded hills of
Burgundy in central France, an unusual institute is training unusual
students: aspiring French imams who hope to minister to the country`s
large Muslim population.
Early in the morning, some 200 students from across the country stream into the European Institute of Human Sciences de Saint-Legerde-Fougeret, where they learn to read the holy Quran and study Islamic theology and Arabic literature.
After seven intensive years of study, only 10 or so graduates eachyear to lead prayers or preach at mosques.
Estimates of France`s Muslim population vary widely, from between 3.5 million and 6.0 million, though there is little hard evidence as to how many are practising. In any event, France`s Muslim community is the largest in western Europe.
Relations between the authorities and Muslims, many of them secondor third-generation immigrants, chiefly from North Africa, have often been tense.
Some younger Muslims have been tempted by extremist jihadist views and France hasimplemented a contentious ban on women wearing full veils.
Over the past nine years, various governments have encouraged the professional training of local religious leaders. Interior Minister Manuel Valls recently backed the practice, even if the job of imam is badly paid, if at all, and enjoys no official recognition.
The initiative goes back 20 years when the Union of Islamic Organisations in France, which has close ties to the Muslim Brotherhood, converted a former children`s holiday centre into the institute. Its stated aim is to train imams equipped `with a solidknowledge of Islam and the sociocultural realities of Europe`.
The idea was to provide an alternative to the recruitment of foreign imams, who often spoke no French and had little or no knowledge of French lifestyles.
`The training of imams who are products of French society is vital: Today 70 per cent of the faithful don`t speak Arabic,` said the institute`s director Zuhair Mahmood.
Initially financed by the Gulf States, the school depends heavily on fees of about 3,400 euros ($4,400) a year board and lodging included.
`Since I was small I havedreamed of becoming an imam, said 18-year-old Wahib, who did not want to give his last name, `but seven years is long and there are no grants`.
Apart from the rural setting, the atmosphere in the run-down prefabricated corridors of the institute is like that of any other college.
At break time men, often bearded, and women, all of them wearing head scarves, wait for coffee.
The women can follow the 20 hours of weekly courses but cannot become imams.
Said, who also did not want to give his last name, was born inMorocco and now living in Nice in southern France. He took correspondence courses for two years and left his family to `deepen` his knowledge of Islam. `If I succeed, I become an imam. It`s my vocation,` he said.
`I would love to pass on my knowledge to others and above all fight against extremism.
There are about 10 people in his class. They listen to the interpretations of a sura from holy Quran, as part of a third year theology course, which also includes an introduction to French law.
`Being an imam, it isn`t something that happens,` the 33-year-old Said told this correspondent.
`It`s a real responsibility, We have to be safeguards.
`Radicalism is always the result of ignorance,` Said`s theology teacher Larbi Belbachir added.
Traditionally, congregations of the faithful choose their imams, who carry out their duties as volunteers or are paid by gifts. Those presiding in large mosques can earn 1,500 euros ($1,950) a month.
They are classified as educators or teachers but never as imams.
`When this profession is recognised and paid as such,` Said suggested, `perhaps there will be more vocations`.-AFP
Early in the morning, some 200 students from across the country stream into the European Institute of Human Sciences de Saint-Legerde-Fougeret, where they learn to read the holy Quran and study Islamic theology and Arabic literature.
After seven intensive years of study, only 10 or so graduates eachyear to lead prayers or preach at mosques.
Estimates of France`s Muslim population vary widely, from between 3.5 million and 6.0 million, though there is little hard evidence as to how many are practising. In any event, France`s Muslim community is the largest in western Europe.
Relations between the authorities and Muslims, many of them secondor third-generation immigrants, chiefly from North Africa, have often been tense.
Some younger Muslims have been tempted by extremist jihadist views and France hasimplemented a contentious ban on women wearing full veils.
Over the past nine years, various governments have encouraged the professional training of local religious leaders. Interior Minister Manuel Valls recently backed the practice, even if the job of imam is badly paid, if at all, and enjoys no official recognition.
The initiative goes back 20 years when the Union of Islamic Organisations in France, which has close ties to the Muslim Brotherhood, converted a former children`s holiday centre into the institute. Its stated aim is to train imams equipped `with a solidknowledge of Islam and the sociocultural realities of Europe`.
The idea was to provide an alternative to the recruitment of foreign imams, who often spoke no French and had little or no knowledge of French lifestyles.
`The training of imams who are products of French society is vital: Today 70 per cent of the faithful don`t speak Arabic,` said the institute`s director Zuhair Mahmood.
Initially financed by the Gulf States, the school depends heavily on fees of about 3,400 euros ($4,400) a year board and lodging included.
`Since I was small I havedreamed of becoming an imam, said 18-year-old Wahib, who did not want to give his last name, `but seven years is long and there are no grants`.
Apart from the rural setting, the atmosphere in the run-down prefabricated corridors of the institute is like that of any other college.
At break time men, often bearded, and women, all of them wearing head scarves, wait for coffee.
The women can follow the 20 hours of weekly courses but cannot become imams.
Said, who also did not want to give his last name, was born inMorocco and now living in Nice in southern France. He took correspondence courses for two years and left his family to `deepen` his knowledge of Islam. `If I succeed, I become an imam. It`s my vocation,` he said.
`I would love to pass on my knowledge to others and above all fight against extremism.
There are about 10 people in his class. They listen to the interpretations of a sura from holy Quran, as part of a third year theology course, which also includes an introduction to French law.
`Being an imam, it isn`t something that happens,` the 33-year-old Said told this correspondent.
`It`s a real responsibility, We have to be safeguards.
`Radicalism is always the result of ignorance,` Said`s theology teacher Larbi Belbachir added.
Traditionally, congregations of the faithful choose their imams, who carry out their duties as volunteers or are paid by gifts. Those presiding in large mosques can earn 1,500 euros ($1,950) a month.
They are classified as educators or teachers but never as imams.
`When this profession is recognised and paid as such,` Said suggested, `perhaps there will be more vocations`.-AFP
Army`s concerns
AS the country digests the army chief`s latest foray into, strictly
speaking, non-military matters, it appears that Gen Kayani`s comments on
Monday were directed at his principal constituency: the armed forces
itself. The discomfort within the rank and file and the leadership too
in recent weeks is not very difficult to fathom.
Mehrangate, the NLC scam, inquiries into a luxury resort in Lahore, and myriad other questions about the army`s political role and management of security affairs have all combined to probably create a sense of siege. For an institution as proud and domestically predominant as the army has been over the decades, it may well be bewildering to be subjected to the kind of scrutiny and commentary that nonuniformed leaders have long been used to. So Gen Kayani`s words targeted as they appear to have been against the judiciary and sections of the media, and not really the civilian political leadership were probably intended to allay concerns within the armed forces that somewhat legitimate criticism of narrow problems, from the army`s perspective, were growing into wanton and gratuitous criticism of the entire institution.
Questionable as the army`s concerns may be those never subjected to intense scrutiny will always resist a changing order it is perhaps a signof the times, and a good one at that, that the army chief chose tough words instead of strong action. In eras past, a discreet phone call or a public swipe would have been enough to tamp down criticism and make unwanted investigations disappear. So perhaps in time, even the dubious use of the ISPR to put out such controversial statements will be a practice curbed.
For the long road to civilian control of the state to be travelled, however, one of the key elements is the question of who determines the `national interest`. Gen Kayani was correct in saying that `no individual or institution has the monopoly to decide what is right or wrong in defining the national interest` and that it should emerge through a `consensus`. But in truth, it must go much further than that in a truly democratic polity. While other institutions do have some role to play, the central pivot has to be the civilian leadership that represents the will of the people through parliament. It cannot and must not be forgotten that the internal and external instability the country faces today is largely rooted in policies pursued by the army itself in the name of the national interest. But if a few court cases and investigations so unsettle the armed forces, can they really be willing to cede control of the `national interest`?
Mehrangate, the NLC scam, inquiries into a luxury resort in Lahore, and myriad other questions about the army`s political role and management of security affairs have all combined to probably create a sense of siege. For an institution as proud and domestically predominant as the army has been over the decades, it may well be bewildering to be subjected to the kind of scrutiny and commentary that nonuniformed leaders have long been used to. So Gen Kayani`s words targeted as they appear to have been against the judiciary and sections of the media, and not really the civilian political leadership were probably intended to allay concerns within the armed forces that somewhat legitimate criticism of narrow problems, from the army`s perspective, were growing into wanton and gratuitous criticism of the entire institution.
Questionable as the army`s concerns may be those never subjected to intense scrutiny will always resist a changing order it is perhaps a signof the times, and a good one at that, that the army chief chose tough words instead of strong action. In eras past, a discreet phone call or a public swipe would have been enough to tamp down criticism and make unwanted investigations disappear. So perhaps in time, even the dubious use of the ISPR to put out such controversial statements will be a practice curbed.
For the long road to civilian control of the state to be travelled, however, one of the key elements is the question of who determines the `national interest`. Gen Kayani was correct in saying that `no individual or institution has the monopoly to decide what is right or wrong in defining the national interest` and that it should emerge through a `consensus`. But in truth, it must go much further than that in a truly democratic polity. While other institutions do have some role to play, the central pivot has to be the civilian leadership that represents the will of the people through parliament. It cannot and must not be forgotten that the internal and external instability the country faces today is largely rooted in policies pursued by the army itself in the name of the national interest. But if a few court cases and investigations so unsettle the armed forces, can they really be willing to cede control of the `national interest`?
Sandy Storm: learning a lesson from America
KEEPING aside the rhetoric of some right-wing elements in our society
that the storm Sandy is `natural justice` on the `infidels`, the cue for
Pakistan should be the management part of it.
The normality witnessed just on the third day after the storm hit the United States of America`s east coast is a leading example for nations to follow.
More than anything else, it was sheer determination on the part of their leaders to stand united in theface of this catastrophe.
They threw politics off their shoulders and tackled what turned out to be one of the worst disasters in American history.
Out of 78 million people affected, the number of deaths at 100 shows the preparedness on all three stages: pre-disaster, during disaster and postdisaster.
Even though Pakistan has seen worst of floods during the past three years, yet the levelof preparednessis unfortunately at the lowest ebb.Vast areas still remain inundated, while scores of people are still fighting their fate and struggling to make ends meet.
Blaming destiny has become a synonym for lack of preparedness in our country.
Hopefully, our leaders who often portray a pro-western stance would follow in the footsteps of their counterparts in the West in this regard as well.
The normality witnessed just on the third day after the storm hit the United States of America`s east coast is a leading example for nations to follow.
More than anything else, it was sheer determination on the part of their leaders to stand united in theface of this catastrophe.
They threw politics off their shoulders and tackled what turned out to be one of the worst disasters in American history.
Out of 78 million people affected, the number of deaths at 100 shows the preparedness on all three stages: pre-disaster, during disaster and postdisaster.
Even though Pakistan has seen worst of floods during the past three years, yet the levelof preparednessis unfortunately at the lowest ebb.Vast areas still remain inundated, while scores of people are still fighting their fate and struggling to make ends meet.
Blaming destiny has become a synonym for lack of preparedness in our country.
Hopefully, our leaders who often portray a pro-western stance would follow in the footsteps of their counterparts in the West in this regard as well.
Thursday, October 25, 2012
Malala Yousafzai and the Other Half of Muslim History
BLOOMINGTON, Indiana -- As someone who writes and lectures about women and gender in Islam, I am often asked if women had any role in the making of the Islamic tradition. Happily, the answer is always yes. There were in fact many prominent women in the early history of Islam.
At the top of the list would have to be Aisha, the widow of the Prophet Muhammad, who was renowned for her learning and wit. The Prophet in fact is said to have counselled his followers to "take half of your religion" from Aisha -- in recognition of her learning. After his death, she spent the rest of her life transmitting the sayings of her husband and commenting on the Quran. Her authoritative pronouncements have decisively shaped the later Islamic legal tradition.
The early period of Islam in particular is peopled with such intelligent, assertive and pious women. Another name that comes to mind is Umm Umara. Although she was a prominent companion of the Prophet Muhammad, whom he regarded highly in her own time, she has become an obscure figure over the centuries. One possible reason for this is that Umm Umara was a "difficult" woman -- that is to say, she was someone who asked a lot of questions and who protested loudly when she was faced with inequality, especially in regard to women's rights. Her passion for justice and outspokenness, however, were hardly out of place in the first century of Islam.
As historical records inform us, women in particular excelled in religious scholarship through the late Mamluk period, the 14th and 15th centuries of the common era. This should not be surprising since women's right to education is firmly guaranteed by Islam. A well-known saying of the Prophet Muhammad asserts that knowledge is equally obligatory for males and females -- which has allowed for considerable Muslim receptivity toward providing education for girls and women alongside their male counterparts through the centuries. As a result, women scholars dot the Islamic intellectual landscape.
The famous ninth century Muslim jurist al-Shafii, widely regarded as the father of Islamic jurisprudence, studied with female teachers. Ibn Hajar, another prominent jurist from the 15th century, gratefully acknowledges his debt to a number of his female professors whose study circles he frequented.
Ibn Hajar's student, al-Sakhawi, dedicated one whole volume of his encyclopaedic biographical work on famous scholars from the Mamluk period to women alone. Among the 1,075 women listed in this volume, over 400 were active in scholarship. One such scholar is on record as having complained that she was not getting adequate compensation for her teaching (a complaint that may sound dismayingly familiar to contemporary professional women the world over today).
Regrettably, the memory of these accomplished women has grown dim over time. As Muslim societies became more patriarchal after the first century of Islam, many of these women have been air-brushed out of the master narrative of Islamic history, leaving us with the impression that the Islamic tradition was shaped mainly by men.
This erasure of women can lead to a dangerously mistaken belief that Islam itself mandates this marginalization of women. The danger is real -- as became recently evident in the Taliban's brutal and misogynist vendetta against the indomitable 14-year-old Malala Yousafzai. A fearless warrior to promote education for females in her native Pakistan, Yousafzai has paid a huge price for her courageous stance, as she now struggles to recover after being shot by the Taliban.
Yousafzai's fate is a reminder that women's historical roles in Islamic learning and scholarship need to become much better known among Muslims themselves. This is imperative so that in the future the Taliban's grotesque interpretation of women's rights can immediately be recognised for what it is: a violation of fundamental Islamic principles and one that should not be granted even the veneer of religious legitimacy.
In her fearless insistence on the right to be educated and to be heard in public, Yousafzai is following in the footsteps of her illustrious female forebears from the first century of Islam. Learned, feisty and principled women have contributed much to the Islamic heritage.
Her predicament reminds us why this history must be featured prominently in our own times and why women must be reinstated into the very mainstream of the Islamic intellectual tradition. It is the most effective way to keep religious obscurantism at bay in Muslim-majority societies, especially the kind that threatens the well-being of Muslim girls and women.
Congressional Gold Medal proposed for Malala
WASHINGTON, Oct 24: A senior American lawmaker on Wednesday distributed a
letter in the US Congress, urging her colleagues to award the
Congressional Gold Medal to Malala Yousuf zai.
Separately, thousands of people have signed an online petition to nominate Malala for the Nobel Peace Prize.
Angelina Jolie, a famous American actress who is also a goodwill ambassador for the United Nations, was the first to propose this idea, saying that the 14-year-old girl deserved a Nobel Prize for standing up to the forces that others did not have the courage to confront.
Malala, who was shot in the head by a Taliban gunman for speaking up for her rights, is undergoing treatment at a British hospital in Birmingham.
`Malala ... stood against the oppressive policies imposed upon the citizens of Pakistan by the Taliban. Her stand for education for girl and gender equality resulted in a fatwa issued by the Taliban calling for her death,` Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee wrote in her letter.
The congresswoman, a Democrat from Texas who has been a member of the House since1995, also heads the Pakistan caucus on the Hill and is one of few US lawmakers who still openly support Pakistan.
`The shooting of this young girl has sent shockwaves through the region and around the world; religious leaders and communities are condemning her shooting, yet the Taliban remains unrepentant,` the congresswoman wrote.
`Malala has displayed true courage as she continued to fight for justice, even while her life was in danger. Because of her courage, Malala Yousufzai has become a symbol of hope in a country long beset by violence and oppression,` she noted.
`It is fitting that Malala has become the new face of Pakistan. She represents the future of Pakistan, where young girls can attend school and expect equal rights.
Congresswoman Lee noted that Malala`s actions demonstrated the power one child can have on an entire region. `Her message could not be silenced by the cowardly acts of the few.
It is my firm belief that we should honour her message and recognise her bravery,` she said.
`I, like all of you, value the need for education, justice, and gender equality. Join me in supporting this legislation to honour Malala Yousufzai and her message,` she wrote.
Separately, thousands of people have signed an online petition to nominate Malala for the Nobel Peace Prize.
Angelina Jolie, a famous American actress who is also a goodwill ambassador for the United Nations, was the first to propose this idea, saying that the 14-year-old girl deserved a Nobel Prize for standing up to the forces that others did not have the courage to confront.
Malala, who was shot in the head by a Taliban gunman for speaking up for her rights, is undergoing treatment at a British hospital in Birmingham.
`Malala ... stood against the oppressive policies imposed upon the citizens of Pakistan by the Taliban. Her stand for education for girl and gender equality resulted in a fatwa issued by the Taliban calling for her death,` Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee wrote in her letter.
The congresswoman, a Democrat from Texas who has been a member of the House since1995, also heads the Pakistan caucus on the Hill and is one of few US lawmakers who still openly support Pakistan.
`The shooting of this young girl has sent shockwaves through the region and around the world; religious leaders and communities are condemning her shooting, yet the Taliban remains unrepentant,` the congresswoman wrote.
`Malala has displayed true courage as she continued to fight for justice, even while her life was in danger. Because of her courage, Malala Yousufzai has become a symbol of hope in a country long beset by violence and oppression,` she noted.
`It is fitting that Malala has become the new face of Pakistan. She represents the future of Pakistan, where young girls can attend school and expect equal rights.
Congresswoman Lee noted that Malala`s actions demonstrated the power one child can have on an entire region. `Her message could not be silenced by the cowardly acts of the few.
It is my firm belief that we should honour her message and recognise her bravery,` she said.
`I, like all of you, value the need for education, justice, and gender equality. Join me in supporting this legislation to honour Malala Yousufzai and her message,` she wrote.
China and India are partners instead of rivals: Beijing
BEIJING: Beijing stressed on Wednesday that India and China were
`partners instead of rivals` with common interests in development,
striking a conciliatory note on the 50th anniversary of a war between
the neighbours.
Badly-equipped Indian troops were humiliated in the four-week war along the Himalayan frontier which begn in October 1962, with Chinese forces pouring through the mountains and advancing as far as the plains of Assam.
China then withdrew to the current border but it still claims much of the remote Indian state of Arunachal Pradesh, and the dispute consistently sours efforts to improve ties between the regional rivals.-AFP
Badly-equipped Indian troops were humiliated in the four-week war along the Himalayan frontier which begn in October 1962, with Chinese forces pouring through the mountains and advancing as far as the plains of Assam.
China then withdrew to the current border but it still claims much of the remote Indian state of Arunachal Pradesh, and the dispute consistently sours efforts to improve ties between the regional rivals.-AFP
Sudan accuses Israel of bombing factory, threatens retaliation
KHARTOUM, Oct 24: Sudan on Wednesday accused Israel of carrying out
missile strikes against a military factory that killed two people in
Khartoum overnight and threatened to retaliate `We think Israel did the
bombing,` Culture and Information Minister Ahmed Bilal Osman told a news
conference. `We reserve the right to react at a place and time we
choose.
The military and foreign ministry in Israel, which has long accused Khartoum of serving as a base for militants from the Palestinian Islamist group Hamas, refused to comment.
Osman said four radar-evading aircraft conducted an attack at around midnight on the Yarmouk military manufacturing facility in the south of the Sudanese capital.
Evidence pointing to Israel was found among remnants of the explosives, he said, adding that the cabinet would hold an urgent meeting.
Residents of the area earlier said an aircraft or missile flew over the facili-ty shortly before the plant exploded and burst into flames.
A journalist several kilometres away saw two or three fires flaring across a wide area, with heavy smoke and intermittent flashes of white light bursting above the state-owned factory.
In 1998, Human Rights Watch said a coalition of opposition groups alleged that Sudan stored chemical weapons for Iraq at the Yarmouk facility but government officials strenuously denied the charges at the time.
In August of that year, US cruise missiles struck the Al-Shifa pharmaceutical factory in North Khartoum, which Washington alleged was linked to chemical weapons production.
Evidence for that claim later proved questionable.
`I heard a sound like a plane in the sky, but I didn`t see any light from a plane. Then I heard two explosions, and fire erupted in the compound, said a resident who asked to be identified only as Faize.A woman living south of the compound also reported two initial blasts.
`I saw a plane coming from east to west and I heard explosions and there was a short length of time between the first one and the second one,` she said.
`Then I saw fire and our neighbour`s house was hit by shrapnel, causing minor damage. The windows of my own house rattled after the second explosion.
The sprawling Yarmouk facility is surrounded by barbed wire and set back about two kilometres from the district`s main road, meaning signs of damage were not visible later Wednesday when a journalist reporter visited.
But at least three houses in the neighbourhood had been punctured by shrapnel which left walls and a fence with holes about 20-centimetres in diameter, the reporter said.
There was also slight damage to a Coca-Cola warehouse.
The fires appeared to be extin-guished by 3.30am, more than three hours after they began, a journalist said.
Osman said Yarmouk makes `traditional weapons`.
`The attack destroyed part of the compound infrastructure, killed two people inside and injured another who is in serious condition,` he said.
There have been other mysterious blasts in Sudan and allegations of Israeli involvement.
In April last year, Sudan said it had irrefutable evidence that Israeli attack helicopters carried out a missile and machinegun strike on a car south of Port Sudan.
Israel refused to comment.
Last year`s attack mirrored a similar strike by foreign aircraft on a truck convoy reporte dly laden with weapons in eastern Sudan in January 2009.
Khartoum is seeking the removal of US sanctions imposed in 1997 over alleged support for international terrorism, its human rights record and other concerns.-AFP
The military and foreign ministry in Israel, which has long accused Khartoum of serving as a base for militants from the Palestinian Islamist group Hamas, refused to comment.
Osman said four radar-evading aircraft conducted an attack at around midnight on the Yarmouk military manufacturing facility in the south of the Sudanese capital.
Evidence pointing to Israel was found among remnants of the explosives, he said, adding that the cabinet would hold an urgent meeting.
Residents of the area earlier said an aircraft or missile flew over the facili-ty shortly before the plant exploded and burst into flames.
A journalist several kilometres away saw two or three fires flaring across a wide area, with heavy smoke and intermittent flashes of white light bursting above the state-owned factory.
In 1998, Human Rights Watch said a coalition of opposition groups alleged that Sudan stored chemical weapons for Iraq at the Yarmouk facility but government officials strenuously denied the charges at the time.
In August of that year, US cruise missiles struck the Al-Shifa pharmaceutical factory in North Khartoum, which Washington alleged was linked to chemical weapons production.
Evidence for that claim later proved questionable.
`I heard a sound like a plane in the sky, but I didn`t see any light from a plane. Then I heard two explosions, and fire erupted in the compound, said a resident who asked to be identified only as Faize.A woman living south of the compound also reported two initial blasts.
`I saw a plane coming from east to west and I heard explosions and there was a short length of time between the first one and the second one,` she said.
`Then I saw fire and our neighbour`s house was hit by shrapnel, causing minor damage. The windows of my own house rattled after the second explosion.
The sprawling Yarmouk facility is surrounded by barbed wire and set back about two kilometres from the district`s main road, meaning signs of damage were not visible later Wednesday when a journalist reporter visited.
But at least three houses in the neighbourhood had been punctured by shrapnel which left walls and a fence with holes about 20-centimetres in diameter, the reporter said.
There was also slight damage to a Coca-Cola warehouse.
The fires appeared to be extin-guished by 3.30am, more than three hours after they began, a journalist said.
Osman said Yarmouk makes `traditional weapons`.
`The attack destroyed part of the compound infrastructure, killed two people inside and injured another who is in serious condition,` he said.
There have been other mysterious blasts in Sudan and allegations of Israeli involvement.
In April last year, Sudan said it had irrefutable evidence that Israeli attack helicopters carried out a missile and machinegun strike on a car south of Port Sudan.
Israel refused to comment.
Last year`s attack mirrored a similar strike by foreign aircraft on a truck convoy reporte dly laden with weapons in eastern Sudan in January 2009.
Khartoum is seeking the removal of US sanctions imposed in 1997 over alleged support for international terrorism, its human rights record and other concerns.-AFP
most dangerous country for journalists
THERE is no doubt that for journalists, this is one of the most dangerous countries in the world.
Journalists are killed or harassed because of their work or in the line of duty partly because the state has consistently refused to track down the killers or intimidators. Here, journalists are sandwiched between a rock and a hard place: at one end is a shadowy establishment that tries to keep certain information cloaked, and at the other, a war with elements that consider no means too foul to achieve their end. Yet the harassment of journalists, and their killing with impunity is a global problem. The Committee to Protect Journalists estimates that some 49 journalists have been killed around the world so far this year, while Reporters Without Borders` `Press Freedom Barometer` points out that over 270 people, including journalists and `netizens`, have been put in prison during these 10 months. In this tug-of-war between those who seek to expose the truth and those who try to contain it, what is at stake is the citizens` right to know.It was in defence of this right that the world media community expressed dismay at the ineffectiveness of UN efforts to ensure the safety of newsmen the 2006 UNSC Resolution 1738, among other matters, reminded all parties in situations of armed conflict to respect the professional independence of media personnel. At a symposium on `Media Responses to Matters of Life and Death` that took place in London last week, ahead of the second UN Inter-Agency meeting on `the safety of journalists and the issue of impunity` that is to be held in Vienna next month, representatives of 40 media organisations from around the world called upon the UN to persuade member states to create a safer environment for journalists. The symposium has drafted a set of proposals in this regard. This needs to be given due attention.
Too many governments, among them the Pakistani government, are guilty of either perpetrating violence against media personnel or standing by as such violence occurs. If the world is concerned about the freedom of speech, here is where it begins.
Journalists are killed or harassed because of their work or in the line of duty partly because the state has consistently refused to track down the killers or intimidators. Here, journalists are sandwiched between a rock and a hard place: at one end is a shadowy establishment that tries to keep certain information cloaked, and at the other, a war with elements that consider no means too foul to achieve their end. Yet the harassment of journalists, and their killing with impunity is a global problem. The Committee to Protect Journalists estimates that some 49 journalists have been killed around the world so far this year, while Reporters Without Borders` `Press Freedom Barometer` points out that over 270 people, including journalists and `netizens`, have been put in prison during these 10 months. In this tug-of-war between those who seek to expose the truth and those who try to contain it, what is at stake is the citizens` right to know.It was in defence of this right that the world media community expressed dismay at the ineffectiveness of UN efforts to ensure the safety of newsmen the 2006 UNSC Resolution 1738, among other matters, reminded all parties in situations of armed conflict to respect the professional independence of media personnel. At a symposium on `Media Responses to Matters of Life and Death` that took place in London last week, ahead of the second UN Inter-Agency meeting on `the safety of journalists and the issue of impunity` that is to be held in Vienna next month, representatives of 40 media organisations from around the world called upon the UN to persuade member states to create a safer environment for journalists. The symposium has drafted a set of proposals in this regard. This needs to be given due attention.
Too many governments, among them the Pakistani government, are guilty of either perpetrating violence against media personnel or standing by as such violence occurs. If the world is concerned about the freedom of speech, here is where it begins.
Guns, drones and butter By Michael Krepon
THERE is no shortage of young talent with restless intellectual energy
and entrepreneurial skills in Pakistan. Natural resources are untapped.
Despite its economic travails, Pakistan has a middle class that can grow
if markets grow.
A Pakistani diaspora in the West could come to the country`s aid. These positive notes within Pakistan cannot become music until governance improves and the writ of the state extends toits borders.
The music has stopped completely after the Pakistani Taliban`s attempt to kill Malala Yousufzai. It also stops whenever they blow up markets, record shops, cinemas, and other places where civilians congregate. No city in Pakistan is immune from these attacks. Thousands have been killed annually.
The deaths of innocent civilians from drone strikes represent a small fraction of this carnage. The Tehrik-iTaliban Pakistan (TTP) didn`t begin this reign of terror because of drone strikes, and they won`t end it if the drone strikes stop. The strongest linkage between these disparate phenomena is that some US drone strikes are directed at those who plan and direct this carnage on Pakistani soil. No one in authority in Pakistan appears willing to acknowledge this.
My advice, freely and repeatedly given, has been for the Obama administration to fundamentally reassess its policy on drone strikes, and to make them exceptional, rather than common occurrences in Pakistan. As was evident in the foreign policy debate between President Obama and Gov Mitt Romney, this is unlikely to happen. As long as US and Nato forces in Afghanistan are being targeted by Afghan Talibanfighters who take refuge on Pakistan`s soil, drone strikes will continue.
When US forces are mostly withdrawn from Afghanistan, and if the Afghan Taliban leadership move themselves as well as their operations across the Durand Line, drone strikes in Pakistan may be significantly reduced but not until then.
In my view, a qualified suspension of drone strikes within Pakistan is still warranted, even in the aftermath of the attempt to kill Malala. What are the qualifications?First, if Pakistani authorities privately request them and if the targets are legitimate. Second, if extremist groups continue to plan and carry out attacks on US and Nato forces, Washington would reserve the right to respond not at lieutenants, but at their leaders, wherever they may be a difficult standard for Washington and Islamabad to swallow.
Third, if there is actionable intelligence about plans to carry out attacks on US or allied territory, the United States would reserve the right to disrupt them.
Taken together, all of these qualifications are likely to result in far fewer drone strikes. These strikes would become even rarer if Pakistani authorities assumed the responsibility of preventing their soil from becoming a launching pad for attacks that ruin Pakistan`s international standing and economic prospects.
A secondary reason for this proposal is that it would clarify the wrongheaded conclusion that drone strikes make every one of Pakistan`s problems worse. I disagree. Drone strikes do not make Pakistan`s economic prospects worse, and the absence of drone strikes would not make deals with the TTP any more likely to succeed.
Drone strikes had nothing to do with the attempt to kill Malala. Nor did drone strikes factor in the ill-fated deal between the Pakistani government and the TTP in Swat, or its predictable demise. Horrific Muslim-on-Muslim violence in Pakistan will continue as long as political leaders look the other way while seeking `consensus`, and as long as poor governance, economic stagnation, corruption, flimsy social services, and a deteriorating educational system hold sway.
Even if civilian casualties are kept to an absolute minimum, there are three primary reasons for a reassessment of US policy regarding drone strikes. First, they are unlikely to make a significant difference in Afghanistan`s future dispensation.
Second, they can help Pakistan`s armed forces only marginally to reclaim their country`s periphery. Third, drone strikes ruin America`s standing in Pakistan, and decent US-Pakistani relations are one essential condition for a reversal of Pakistan`s fortunes.
Unless drone strikes become exceptional rather than routine, they are a diversion and a hindrance to steps that eventually help Pakistan to become whole.
Whether drone strikes increase, decrease, or are suspended, Pakistan cannot hope to become healthy unless its economy grows. Pakistan could eventually become a beneficiary of its geography if trade flows naturally through Pakistan between Central Asia and the subcontinent.
This promise cannot be realised as long as Pakistan remains at loggerheads with India, and if Afghanistan is mired in perpetual turmoil. Unchecked violence checkmates trade flows.
Afghanistan may remain unsettled for some time to come, blocking Pakistan`s economic growth via Central Asia. Increased trade with India is far more feasible. If leaders in both countries can keep increased trade on course, despite explosions intended to stop progress, radical elements can be marginalised and Pakistan can hope for a brighter future. The writer is co-founder of the Stimson Centre in Washington.
A Pakistani diaspora in the West could come to the country`s aid. These positive notes within Pakistan cannot become music until governance improves and the writ of the state extends toits borders.
The music has stopped completely after the Pakistani Taliban`s attempt to kill Malala Yousufzai. It also stops whenever they blow up markets, record shops, cinemas, and other places where civilians congregate. No city in Pakistan is immune from these attacks. Thousands have been killed annually.
The deaths of innocent civilians from drone strikes represent a small fraction of this carnage. The Tehrik-iTaliban Pakistan (TTP) didn`t begin this reign of terror because of drone strikes, and they won`t end it if the drone strikes stop. The strongest linkage between these disparate phenomena is that some US drone strikes are directed at those who plan and direct this carnage on Pakistani soil. No one in authority in Pakistan appears willing to acknowledge this.
My advice, freely and repeatedly given, has been for the Obama administration to fundamentally reassess its policy on drone strikes, and to make them exceptional, rather than common occurrences in Pakistan. As was evident in the foreign policy debate between President Obama and Gov Mitt Romney, this is unlikely to happen. As long as US and Nato forces in Afghanistan are being targeted by Afghan Talibanfighters who take refuge on Pakistan`s soil, drone strikes will continue.
When US forces are mostly withdrawn from Afghanistan, and if the Afghan Taliban leadership move themselves as well as their operations across the Durand Line, drone strikes in Pakistan may be significantly reduced but not until then.
In my view, a qualified suspension of drone strikes within Pakistan is still warranted, even in the aftermath of the attempt to kill Malala. What are the qualifications?First, if Pakistani authorities privately request them and if the targets are legitimate. Second, if extremist groups continue to plan and carry out attacks on US and Nato forces, Washington would reserve the right to respond not at lieutenants, but at their leaders, wherever they may be a difficult standard for Washington and Islamabad to swallow.
Third, if there is actionable intelligence about plans to carry out attacks on US or allied territory, the United States would reserve the right to disrupt them.
Taken together, all of these qualifications are likely to result in far fewer drone strikes. These strikes would become even rarer if Pakistani authorities assumed the responsibility of preventing their soil from becoming a launching pad for attacks that ruin Pakistan`s international standing and economic prospects.
A secondary reason for this proposal is that it would clarify the wrongheaded conclusion that drone strikes make every one of Pakistan`s problems worse. I disagree. Drone strikes do not make Pakistan`s economic prospects worse, and the absence of drone strikes would not make deals with the TTP any more likely to succeed.
Drone strikes had nothing to do with the attempt to kill Malala. Nor did drone strikes factor in the ill-fated deal between the Pakistani government and the TTP in Swat, or its predictable demise. Horrific Muslim-on-Muslim violence in Pakistan will continue as long as political leaders look the other way while seeking `consensus`, and as long as poor governance, economic stagnation, corruption, flimsy social services, and a deteriorating educational system hold sway.
Even if civilian casualties are kept to an absolute minimum, there are three primary reasons for a reassessment of US policy regarding drone strikes. First, they are unlikely to make a significant difference in Afghanistan`s future dispensation.
Second, they can help Pakistan`s armed forces only marginally to reclaim their country`s periphery. Third, drone strikes ruin America`s standing in Pakistan, and decent US-Pakistani relations are one essential condition for a reversal of Pakistan`s fortunes.
Unless drone strikes become exceptional rather than routine, they are a diversion and a hindrance to steps that eventually help Pakistan to become whole.
Whether drone strikes increase, decrease, or are suspended, Pakistan cannot hope to become healthy unless its economy grows. Pakistan could eventually become a beneficiary of its geography if trade flows naturally through Pakistan between Central Asia and the subcontinent.
This promise cannot be realised as long as Pakistan remains at loggerheads with India, and if Afghanistan is mired in perpetual turmoil. Unchecked violence checkmates trade flows.
Afghanistan may remain unsettled for some time to come, blocking Pakistan`s economic growth via Central Asia. Increased trade with India is far more feasible. If leaders in both countries can keep increased trade on course, despite explosions intended to stop progress, radical elements can be marginalised and Pakistan can hope for a brighter future. The writer is co-founder of the Stimson Centre in Washington.
In defence of Aafia Siddiqui
THIS refers to Shafiq Murad`s letter `Malala vs Aafia` (Oct 21) wherein
he has tried to distort the facts about Dr Aafia Siddiqui, dubbing her
an American national and an aide ofterrorists.
Perhaps the writer does not know that Dr Aafia has not been convicted of being associated with Al Qaeda or the Taliban. In fact, she has been sentenced to jail for 86 years for attacking an American soldier in the Afghan province of Ghazni.
I was one of the participants of an eight-member delegation that visited the United States under Pakistan-US journalists` exchange programme last year. The Pakistani journalists had a meeting with senior FBI officials in New York as part of the tour. During the meeting an FBI official, who claimed to be aware of the arrest, interrogation and prosecution process which ultimately led to Dr Aafia`s conviction, was very upset over a `hue and cry` in Pakistan with respect to the matter.He asserted that the FBI had ample reasons and proofs to believe that Dr Aafia was an Al Qaeda operative, a fund-raiser and had been associated with an alleged senior Al Qaeda member, Adnan Al Shukri Jumma.
The FBI official was repeatedly asked by the Pakistani journalists that if the agency had ample evidences against Dr Aafia, why was she thennottnedunderthose charges? Why was she charged with trying to kill a US soldier in Afghanistan? The FBI official had no answer except that `I cannot comment on that. It is not within my purview.
The fact is that Dr Aafia had been arrested by a joint team of FBI and Pakistani security officials in Karachi in 2003. She was immediately shifted to Bagram airbase in Kandahar. According to her family, one of her three children died when he was thrown on the floor by an investigator during her detention. Luckily, her eldest son,Ahmed and daughter Mariyam, were handed over to the family a few years ago.
It was a British journalist, Yvonne Ridley, who revealed the presence of Dr Aafia at the Bagram detention centre in 2008. A joint campaign launched by the US and the UKbased human rights groups, Ms Ridley and Imran Khan, had forced the US forces to stage this drama otherwise she might have spent her whole life in that illegal detention.
How surprising it is that a woman, who had gone so weak and lost her senses due to torture by interrogators, attacked a US soldier, but instead of harming him, she received two bullets.
Ironically, the court declared the two important issues raised by Dr Aafia`s lawyer, i.e., her illegal detention for five years, and torture by investigators, irrelevant.
A former US attorney-general, Ramsey Clarke, and other American lawyers, who visited Pakistan and met Dr Aafia`s family last month,categorically stated that her conviction had raised questions on the US justice system.
If US secret agencies had even minor evidence against Dr Aafia regarding her involvement in terrorist activities, she would have been tried for that.
I believe we should avoid exploiting attack on Malala to justify a blatant injustice with Dr Aafia. It will earn nothing but aggravate the already brewing polarisation in our society.
The Pakistani government should learn a lesson from the US government which went beyond justice to get Raymond Davis released. Mr Clarke and other lawyers are of the view that if the government of Pakistan wants Dr Aafia back home, she can be back home in weeks.
For Mr Murad`s information, Dr Aafia is not an American citizen which has been clarified by her family many times.
Perhaps the writer does not know that Dr Aafia has not been convicted of being associated with Al Qaeda or the Taliban. In fact, she has been sentenced to jail for 86 years for attacking an American soldier in the Afghan province of Ghazni.
I was one of the participants of an eight-member delegation that visited the United States under Pakistan-US journalists` exchange programme last year. The Pakistani journalists had a meeting with senior FBI officials in New York as part of the tour. During the meeting an FBI official, who claimed to be aware of the arrest, interrogation and prosecution process which ultimately led to Dr Aafia`s conviction, was very upset over a `hue and cry` in Pakistan with respect to the matter.He asserted that the FBI had ample reasons and proofs to believe that Dr Aafia was an Al Qaeda operative, a fund-raiser and had been associated with an alleged senior Al Qaeda member, Adnan Al Shukri Jumma.
The FBI official was repeatedly asked by the Pakistani journalists that if the agency had ample evidences against Dr Aafia, why was she thennottnedunderthose charges? Why was she charged with trying to kill a US soldier in Afghanistan? The FBI official had no answer except that `I cannot comment on that. It is not within my purview.
The fact is that Dr Aafia had been arrested by a joint team of FBI and Pakistani security officials in Karachi in 2003. She was immediately shifted to Bagram airbase in Kandahar. According to her family, one of her three children died when he was thrown on the floor by an investigator during her detention. Luckily, her eldest son,Ahmed and daughter Mariyam, were handed over to the family a few years ago.
It was a British journalist, Yvonne Ridley, who revealed the presence of Dr Aafia at the Bagram detention centre in 2008. A joint campaign launched by the US and the UKbased human rights groups, Ms Ridley and Imran Khan, had forced the US forces to stage this drama otherwise she might have spent her whole life in that illegal detention.
How surprising it is that a woman, who had gone so weak and lost her senses due to torture by interrogators, attacked a US soldier, but instead of harming him, she received two bullets.
Ironically, the court declared the two important issues raised by Dr Aafia`s lawyer, i.e., her illegal detention for five years, and torture by investigators, irrelevant.
A former US attorney-general, Ramsey Clarke, and other American lawyers, who visited Pakistan and met Dr Aafia`s family last month,categorically stated that her conviction had raised questions on the US justice system.
If US secret agencies had even minor evidence against Dr Aafia regarding her involvement in terrorist activities, she would have been tried for that.
I believe we should avoid exploiting attack on Malala to justify a blatant injustice with Dr Aafia. It will earn nothing but aggravate the already brewing polarisation in our society.
The Pakistani government should learn a lesson from the US government which went beyond justice to get Raymond Davis released. Mr Clarke and other lawyers are of the view that if the government of Pakistan wants Dr Aafia back home, she can be back home in weeks.
For Mr Murad`s information, Dr Aafia is not an American citizen which has been clarified by her family many times.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)