WHAT was always a case fit for emergency treatment is finally getting the right kind of attention from those who can help provide a remedy. The Young Doctors Association in Punjab has climbed down from its position and appears more likely than at any other time in recent weeks to enter into decisive negotiations with the thus far unyielding Shahbaz Sharif government. The change in the YDA stance has come after the provincial government shot down an impossible Rs423bn service structure package proposed by the doctors.
Clearly, the young medics at Punjab hospitals who have developed a habit of staying away from work in recent years at the risk of public censure had stretched it a bit too far this time. By asking for the moon they exposed themselves to a strong and reasonable counterargument by the government.
Another factor that rais-es hopes for some kind of compromise is the alliance between the YDA and Pakistan Medical Association, a platform senior doctors work from. The YDA has in recent times widened the scope of its demands to cover the senior doctors also. This strategy brought the young doctors closer to the seniors who had so far kept away from the former`s protest.
The alliance between the YDA and PMA has given the doctors` movement a more comprehensive look, and in the process, it has provided the young doctors` drive with the cool, thinking heads it was so far accused of lacking for a workable solution. These senior doctors must now try and mediate a careful compromise between the young doctors and the government. It is not an easy task butitis one that can only be delayed at the cost of thousands of patients who turn up at government hospitals each day for want of an option.
Tuesday, June 26, 2012
Egypt- Muhamad Morsi has tough days ahead
EVEN though there were mutual greetings and thanks, the military junta and Mohammed Morsi, Egypt`s first freely elected president, must have been conscious of the difficulties involved in working together. Mr Morsi is the Muslim Brotherhood`s first leader to rule Egypt, and that makes his position unique and his task challenging.
While he thanked his people for the sacrifices in the cause of democracy, Mr Morsi also expressed his thanks to `the army and the police` whose brutal handling of the protesters had resulted in hundreds of deaths. While receiving congratulations from Field Marshal Hussain Tantawi, Mr Morsi could not have failed to note the irony in the situation because of the post-election decree that almost nullified all the democratic gains made since Hosni Mubarak`s ouster. The decree issued by the Supreme Command of the Armed Forces makes Mr Morsi an almost ceremonial head of state, for it denies him the title of the supreme commander of the armed forces, reserves budget-making for Scaf and protects the army from civilian over-sight. With the Lower House already dissolved by the constitutional court, Mr Morsi will be hamstrung by the absence of a legislature. That gives lawmaking to Scaf. A general election will now take another year, until a constitution is prepared, and here too the generals have made it clear it is they who will make the basic law.
The assembly`s dissolution and the sweeping powers assumed by the generals are clear indications that Mubarak loyalists are well-entrenched in the system. The generals had to hold an election because there was no other way in which the anti-Mubarak insurgents could be satisfied. But Mr Morsi`s victory upset all their calculations. Let us also note that proMubarak feelings still exist among the people, as is evident from the narrow margin of Mr Morsi`s victory, for Ahmad Shafiq, Mr Mubarak`s prime minister, secured over 48 per cent of the votes. The world will keenly watch how the Arab world`s most populous nation works in the coming months to make a success of a democratic experience already sabotaged by the generals.
While he thanked his people for the sacrifices in the cause of democracy, Mr Morsi also expressed his thanks to `the army and the police` whose brutal handling of the protesters had resulted in hundreds of deaths. While receiving congratulations from Field Marshal Hussain Tantawi, Mr Morsi could not have failed to note the irony in the situation because of the post-election decree that almost nullified all the democratic gains made since Hosni Mubarak`s ouster. The decree issued by the Supreme Command of the Armed Forces makes Mr Morsi an almost ceremonial head of state, for it denies him the title of the supreme commander of the armed forces, reserves budget-making for Scaf and protects the army from civilian over-sight. With the Lower House already dissolved by the constitutional court, Mr Morsi will be hamstrung by the absence of a legislature. That gives lawmaking to Scaf. A general election will now take another year, until a constitution is prepared, and here too the generals have made it clear it is they who will make the basic law.
The assembly`s dissolution and the sweeping powers assumed by the generals are clear indications that Mubarak loyalists are well-entrenched in the system. The generals had to hold an election because there was no other way in which the anti-Mubarak insurgents could be satisfied. But Mr Morsi`s victory upset all their calculations. Let us also note that proMubarak feelings still exist among the people, as is evident from the narrow margin of Mr Morsi`s victory, for Ahmad Shafiq, Mr Mubarak`s prime minister, secured over 48 per cent of the votes. The world will keenly watch how the Arab world`s most populous nation works in the coming months to make a success of a democratic experience already sabotaged by the generals.
Pakistan - way forward for Raja parvez Ashraf
THERE is resistance to the new prime minister, and the issue of the letter to the Swiss authorities still looms. But if the ruling coalition and the opposition are willing to display some cooperation and maturity, there is still a workable way forward.
Despite their seemingly being at loggerheads, there are glimmers of hope in what the prime minister and opposition politicians have said in recent days. The initial opposition response to Raja Pervez Ashraf was not particularly encouraging understandably so, given the prime minister`s record on the energy front. And his invitation to the opposition for talks on governance issues during his inaugural speech in the National Assembly was snubbed. But the PML-N spokesperson has now said the opposition would be willing to talk as long as the focus of talks is on appointing a chief election commissioner, creating an interim setup and holding early elections. And in that lies a potential middle ground that could benefit both the ruling coalition and the democratic system itself.
The wisest course for the PPP now is to announce a time frame for negotiations, asking for a specific period of time to govern before the start of talks on elections and related issues. This concrete proposal could stem some opposition impatience by displaying a will-ingness to bring elections forward. That, in turn, could buy time for the government to implement whatever improved governance is possible and try to improve its badly damaged reputation on that front before the next polls.
The PPP has little to lose by doing this it has nearly completed a full term, and by bringing elections forward it would lose at most a handful of months in power. In return for a reasonable time frame for the start of negotiations on polls, the opposition should tone down its rhetoric and let the ruling coalition try to implement some reforms.
If an arrangement like this can be worked out, that should be all the more reason for the Supreme Court to consider carefully the effects of pursuing the letter to the Swiss with the current prime minister as well. The upside of doing so is entirely unclear, given the position the ruling party has taken on the president`s immunity. The downside, though, is obvious: destabilisation of the system once again, a lack of clear answers on how to proceed and, in the worst-case scenario, further encouragement to extra-constitutional forces that so far haven`t taken matters into their own hands. If they are able to reach an agreement and schedule for the way forward, Pakistan`s politicians might yet be able to prevent this chain of events from taking place.
Despite their seemingly being at loggerheads, there are glimmers of hope in what the prime minister and opposition politicians have said in recent days. The initial opposition response to Raja Pervez Ashraf was not particularly encouraging understandably so, given the prime minister`s record on the energy front. And his invitation to the opposition for talks on governance issues during his inaugural speech in the National Assembly was snubbed. But the PML-N spokesperson has now said the opposition would be willing to talk as long as the focus of talks is on appointing a chief election commissioner, creating an interim setup and holding early elections. And in that lies a potential middle ground that could benefit both the ruling coalition and the democratic system itself.
The wisest course for the PPP now is to announce a time frame for negotiations, asking for a specific period of time to govern before the start of talks on elections and related issues. This concrete proposal could stem some opposition impatience by displaying a will-ingness to bring elections forward. That, in turn, could buy time for the government to implement whatever improved governance is possible and try to improve its badly damaged reputation on that front before the next polls.
The PPP has little to lose by doing this it has nearly completed a full term, and by bringing elections forward it would lose at most a handful of months in power. In return for a reasonable time frame for the start of negotiations on polls, the opposition should tone down its rhetoric and let the ruling coalition try to implement some reforms.
If an arrangement like this can be worked out, that should be all the more reason for the Supreme Court to consider carefully the effects of pursuing the letter to the Swiss with the current prime minister as well. The upside of doing so is entirely unclear, given the position the ruling party has taken on the president`s immunity. The downside, though, is obvious: destabilisation of the system once again, a lack of clear answers on how to proceed and, in the worst-case scenario, further encouragement to extra-constitutional forces that so far haven`t taken matters into their own hands. If they are able to reach an agreement and schedule for the way forward, Pakistan`s politicians might yet be able to prevent this chain of events from taking place.
Pakistan - PkMAP Chairman address
QUETTA, June 25: Pakhtunkhwa Milli Awami Party (PkMAP) chairman Mahmood Khan Achakzai warned on Monday that the country was passing through a dangerous phase and it was the need of the hour to take wise decisions to resolve contentious issues.
Addressing a public meeting, he said Pakistan comprised Pakhtuns, Baloch, Sindhis, Seraikis and Punjabis and a new social contract should be worked out among the nationalities in order to put them in control of their resources.
He said all divided areas of Pakhtuns should form a new province and until such time it should be ensured that they got the same rights in all spheres of life as being enjoyed by the Baloch so that both communities could live in harmony and peace.
The PkMAP chief warned that if equal rights of Pakhtuns in the province were not accepted then they could themselves declare their separate province.
He said the PkMAP was in favour of Islam and Pakistan but added that recognition of the rights of five nationalities would strengthen the federation.
He said Pakistan was isolated at the international level because of its wrong policies and emphasised that the country should revisit its policies.
Mr Achakzai said there should be no role for the military and intelligence agencies in politics and politicians should be allowed to deal with political issues and serve society.
He said the government had failed to solve problems being faced by people.
The PkMAP leader condemned the killing of innocent people, kidnapping for ransom and killing of Pakhtun traders and transporters in the Baloch-dominated areas of the province, adding that such inhuman acts would only deepen differences between the two communities.
Addressing a public meeting, he said Pakistan comprised Pakhtuns, Baloch, Sindhis, Seraikis and Punjabis and a new social contract should be worked out among the nationalities in order to put them in control of their resources.
He said all divided areas of Pakhtuns should form a new province and until such time it should be ensured that they got the same rights in all spheres of life as being enjoyed by the Baloch so that both communities could live in harmony and peace.
The PkMAP chief warned that if equal rights of Pakhtuns in the province were not accepted then they could themselves declare their separate province.
He said the PkMAP was in favour of Islam and Pakistan but added that recognition of the rights of five nationalities would strengthen the federation.
He said Pakistan was isolated at the international level because of its wrong policies and emphasised that the country should revisit its policies.
Mr Achakzai said there should be no role for the military and intelligence agencies in politics and politicians should be allowed to deal with political issues and serve society.
He said the government had failed to solve problems being faced by people.
The PkMAP leader condemned the killing of innocent people, kidnapping for ransom and killing of Pakhtun traders and transporters in the Baloch-dominated areas of the province, adding that such inhuman acts would only deepen differences between the two communities.
Monday, June 25, 2012
Pakistan - Deforestation
ACCORDING to research conducted by conservation activists, mangroves
have the highest rate of deforestationin the country. As per the study,
Vanishing Riverine Forests of Sindh, details of which were published in
this paper recently, forest cover in the country declined by 19 per cent
between 1992 and 2001. It is indeed tragic that Pakistan has one of the
highest deforestation rates in the world. The phenomenon is highest in
the Indus delta region; one of the major factors contributing to
deforestation in this area is thefact thatnot enough water is flowing in
the Indus downstream Kotri.
The ecological benefits mangroves provide are quite well known. These include protection against coastal flooding and erosion while the plants also act as barriers against storms and cyclones.
While dealing with some factors responsible for deforestation, such as climate change, is beyond human control, the state can sure-ly focus on aspects that can be managed, such as overexploitation of forests for wood. The research paper offers a number of solutions to stop this destructive process, such as a ban on conversion of forestland to other uses and the formulation of a forest management plan. Also, it is vital to involve and educate those communities living in or near forests on how to sustainably manage these valuable eco-regions.
We must realise that if Pakistan`s forests continue to disappear at current rates, an environmental disaster is bound to strike, with desertification and increased flooding being possible outcomes. Thus, deforestation is an issue that affects the ecological stability of the country. If the mangroves and forests of other varieties continue to be chopped down, it will also have a negative effect on wildlife. It is still not too late to act; it is a matter of the official quarters displaying the will and inclination to preserve the country`s biodiversity.
The ecological benefits mangroves provide are quite well known. These include protection against coastal flooding and erosion while the plants also act as barriers against storms and cyclones.
While dealing with some factors responsible for deforestation, such as climate change, is beyond human control, the state can sure-ly focus on aspects that can be managed, such as overexploitation of forests for wood. The research paper offers a number of solutions to stop this destructive process, such as a ban on conversion of forestland to other uses and the formulation of a forest management plan. Also, it is vital to involve and educate those communities living in or near forests on how to sustainably manage these valuable eco-regions.
We must realise that if Pakistan`s forests continue to disappear at current rates, an environmental disaster is bound to strike, with desertification and increased flooding being possible outcomes. Thus, deforestation is an issue that affects the ecological stability of the country. If the mangroves and forests of other varieties continue to be chopped down, it will also have a negative effect on wildlife. It is still not too late to act; it is a matter of the official quarters displaying the will and inclination to preserve the country`s biodiversity.
CJ remarks
ON the face of it, Chief Justice Iftikhar Chandhry`s remarks on
Saturday that parliament cannot enact any law that is repugnant to the
constitution, fundamental rights and Islamic provisions seems innocuous
and uncontroversial after all, few would argue that parliament`s right
to legislate is unfettered. But the comments of the chief justice have
come against a particular background. One, at no point has the present
parliament attempted to legislate against what can be considered the
basic features of the constitution. After the 18th Amendment, the
Supreme Court did question the new procedure for appointment of superior
court judges but legal opinion was divided on whether parliament had
exceeded its mandate or not. Two, it is the activism of the court, which
seemingly reached its apogee with the ouster of former prime minister
Yousuf Raza Gilani, that would appear to be the more immediate threat to
the democratic order not speculative acts by the government that may or
may not occur. In the face of unprecedented activism by the court, the
government has by and large remained unprovoked, even going so far as to
accept the loss of one prime minister and then its first-choice
replacement prime minister in a matter of days.
Crucial to the stability of the democratic order inthe days ahead, then, may well be the choices the Supreme Court itself makes.
The first test will be the fate of the new prime minister: will the court move to oust him too if he refuses to write the so-called Swiss letter, as is likely? Given that elections are now much closer than they were when the court reactivated the NRO issue in January, judicial restraint at this point in time may not necessarily be seen as a climbdown by a judiciary intent on carving out an equal space for itself alongside the traditional power centres in the country.
However, if common sense is to prevail, the political temperature will have to be brought down first and that would entail the judiciary following some of its own advice. As Chief Justice Chaudhry remarked on Saturday, `No one can claim supremacy over and above the law.` That is advice well worth reflecting on, for it is the court that seemed to make part of the constitution redundant by short-circuiting the disqualification process last week.
Finally, as whispers grow that some kind of quasior extra-constitutional arrangement is being contemplated in response to governance woes and in order to oust an unpopular government, the court, in line with its earlier commitment against such interventions, is expected to stand on only one side: that of the law and constitution.
Crucial to the stability of the democratic order inthe days ahead, then, may well be the choices the Supreme Court itself makes.
The first test will be the fate of the new prime minister: will the court move to oust him too if he refuses to write the so-called Swiss letter, as is likely? Given that elections are now much closer than they were when the court reactivated the NRO issue in January, judicial restraint at this point in time may not necessarily be seen as a climbdown by a judiciary intent on carving out an equal space for itself alongside the traditional power centres in the country.
However, if common sense is to prevail, the political temperature will have to be brought down first and that would entail the judiciary following some of its own advice. As Chief Justice Chaudhry remarked on Saturday, `No one can claim supremacy over and above the law.` That is advice well worth reflecting on, for it is the court that seemed to make part of the constitution redundant by short-circuiting the disqualification process last week.
Finally, as whispers grow that some kind of quasior extra-constitutional arrangement is being contemplated in response to governance woes and in order to oust an unpopular government, the court, in line with its earlier commitment against such interventions, is expected to stand on only one side: that of the law and constitution.
Issue in Arab world
IF somebody were to rely exclusively on our TV channels for news, he
would soon come to believe that Pakistan is the centre of the universe.
Events abroad unless they relate to our country are barely reported, and
hardly ever deemed worthy of comment or debate.
Thus, the ongoing civil conflict in Syria and its implications for the region and the world has hardly figured in any of the TV reports and chat shows that I have been watching these last few weeks. Although around 15,000 Syrian have been killed over the last year, the Pakistani response has been a deafening silence.
We in Pakistan are so gripped by our unending and entirely self-created political crises that we have little time for, or interest in, what`s happening around the world. This unhealthy preoccupation with our series of storms in the proverbial teacup has resulted in an inward-looking mindsetwhere conspiracies replace logic, and paranoid fantasies displace reality.
Had 15,000 Muslims including hundreds of children been killed, and thousands more tortured and wounded, by a nonMuslim power, we would have been demonstrating and attacking the embassy of the guilty state. Indeed, Pakistani politicians and clerics score points regularly by taking to the streets when an American drone strike kills villagers behind whom extremists shelter in our tribal areas.
But Muslim-on-Muslim killings go largely unreported and uncondemned. Whether the Taliban slaughter their fellow-Afghans next door, or jihadis kill Pakistanis by the thousands, there is scarcely a murmur of protest by the likes of Nawaz Sharif, Hameed Gul and Imran Khan.
So when Bashar al-Assad`s forces shell towns, or attack the opposition with helicopter gun-ships, few in the Muslim world are moved to protest. True, Saudi Arabia and Qatar are reported to be supplying arms to the opposition. But this is not out of any sympathy for Syrian civilians: the cold calculus here is that by removing Bashar, Iran will be deprived of a crucial regional ally.
This suits western powers as they try to cut Tehran down to size. Thus, the rising chorus to intervene in Washington and London. Had it not been for warweariness and the current economic crisis, I have little doubt that we would have seen Nato planes over Syria by now.
Meanwhile, beyond the scarcely concealed supply of arms to Syrian rebels by Saudi Arabia (and coordinated, we are told, by the CIA), the Muslim world seems to have no clear role or strategy. Turkey has come out strongly against the Assad regime, but is cautious about direct intervention.
The downing of a Turkish jetfighter flying over Syrian airspace will have sent out a clear message that the country is not another Libya. The fact that the Syrian army has remained relatively united under the Assad government is a reminder that any armed intervention will be fiercely resisted. Continuing Russian and Iranian support are the other factors that discourage a Libya-type attempt at regime change.
While I would dearly love to see the Syrian dictator leave, the reality is that his departure might cause more problems than it solves. With an Allewite minority ruling over a majority of Sunnis, there are already rising sectarian tensions between the two communities. There have been credible reports of groups of pro-Assad Allewite thugs killing and torturing civilians.
Should the regime collapse, there is a grave risk of a sectarian bloodbath as Sunnis settle scores.
Apart from Sunnis and ShiaAllewites, Syria is also home to Christians, Druzes and small numbers of Jews and Yazdis.
These minorities fear that once the brutal but secular government of Bashar al-Assad is deposed, the next one might not be as tolerant. They have reason to be worried, judging from the targeted killings of Christians in Egypt and Iraq. Indeed, around half of the country`s million-plus Christians have fled their homes in post-Saddam Iraq. The ancient, pre-Islamic Maronite community of Egypt makes up around 10 per cent of the population, and has been persecuted for years. But now, without the minimal protection they received from Mubarak, they fear the worst under an Islamic dispensation.
Libya today is witnessing regional fragmentation as local militias grab power, and confront a weak and chaotic Transitional National Council. Given the disunity and confusion, there are few prospects of a stable govern-ment emerging anytime soon. So clearly, it is easier to remove a despotic regime than it is to replace it with a democratic one.
Returning to Syria, it seems that a diplomatic solution is the only way forward if we are to avoid a messy endgame of the sort we saw in Iraq and are witnessing in Libya. Clearly, the Kofi Anan formula has collapsed under the weight of multiple breaches of the fragile truce by both sides. Britain and the US are now trying to persuade the Syrian dictator to go into exile with a guarantee of immunity from prosecution. This is known as the Yemen model whereby President Saleh stepped down after months of bloody street protests.
In an ideal world, a movement against dictatorship should culminate in the emergence of a freely elected, democratic government. Sadly, things are never that simple. Vestiges of the old regime continue to cling to power, as we are seeing in Egypt:with the military and security forces still entrenched, they are placing a series of roadblocks on the road to democracy.
How should the world react when faced with the kind of bloodbath we are witnessing in Syria today? Decent people want to see it end, and the only way to stop it seems to be the immediate removal of the dictator. Thus, the Nato campaign to rid Libya of Qadhafi was widely welcomed at the time. But few people are concerned with the disturbing aftermath. Similarly, hardly anybody in the West is aware of the disastrous impact of Saddam Hussein`s removal on women and the minorities in Iraq.
These are tricky moral and political issues, and there are no easy answers. Unfortunately, these questions are not properly discussed in Pakistan where, despite or because of our 24/7 rolling news and TV chat shows, we get more confused than ever.with the military and security forces still entrenched, they are placing a series of roadblocks on the road to democracy.
How should the world react when faced with the kind of bloodbath we are witnessing in Syria today? Decent people want to see it end, and the only way to stop it seems to be the immediate removal of the dictator. Thus, the Nato campaign to rid Libya of Qadhafi was widely welcomed at the time. But few people are concerned with the disturbing aftermath. Similarly, hardly anybody in the West is aware of the disastrous impact of Saddam Hussein`s removal on women and the minorities in Iraq.
These are tricky moral and political issues, and there are no easy answers. Unfortunately, these questions are not properly discussed in Pakistan where, despite or because of our 24/7 rolling news and TV chat shows, we get more confused than ever.
Thus, the ongoing civil conflict in Syria and its implications for the region and the world has hardly figured in any of the TV reports and chat shows that I have been watching these last few weeks. Although around 15,000 Syrian have been killed over the last year, the Pakistani response has been a deafening silence.
We in Pakistan are so gripped by our unending and entirely self-created political crises that we have little time for, or interest in, what`s happening around the world. This unhealthy preoccupation with our series of storms in the proverbial teacup has resulted in an inward-looking mindsetwhere conspiracies replace logic, and paranoid fantasies displace reality.
Had 15,000 Muslims including hundreds of children been killed, and thousands more tortured and wounded, by a nonMuslim power, we would have been demonstrating and attacking the embassy of the guilty state. Indeed, Pakistani politicians and clerics score points regularly by taking to the streets when an American drone strike kills villagers behind whom extremists shelter in our tribal areas.
But Muslim-on-Muslim killings go largely unreported and uncondemned. Whether the Taliban slaughter their fellow-Afghans next door, or jihadis kill Pakistanis by the thousands, there is scarcely a murmur of protest by the likes of Nawaz Sharif, Hameed Gul and Imran Khan.
So when Bashar al-Assad`s forces shell towns, or attack the opposition with helicopter gun-ships, few in the Muslim world are moved to protest. True, Saudi Arabia and Qatar are reported to be supplying arms to the opposition. But this is not out of any sympathy for Syrian civilians: the cold calculus here is that by removing Bashar, Iran will be deprived of a crucial regional ally.
This suits western powers as they try to cut Tehran down to size. Thus, the rising chorus to intervene in Washington and London. Had it not been for warweariness and the current economic crisis, I have little doubt that we would have seen Nato planes over Syria by now.
Meanwhile, beyond the scarcely concealed supply of arms to Syrian rebels by Saudi Arabia (and coordinated, we are told, by the CIA), the Muslim world seems to have no clear role or strategy. Turkey has come out strongly against the Assad regime, but is cautious about direct intervention.
The downing of a Turkish jetfighter flying over Syrian airspace will have sent out a clear message that the country is not another Libya. The fact that the Syrian army has remained relatively united under the Assad government is a reminder that any armed intervention will be fiercely resisted. Continuing Russian and Iranian support are the other factors that discourage a Libya-type attempt at regime change.
While I would dearly love to see the Syrian dictator leave, the reality is that his departure might cause more problems than it solves. With an Allewite minority ruling over a majority of Sunnis, there are already rising sectarian tensions between the two communities. There have been credible reports of groups of pro-Assad Allewite thugs killing and torturing civilians.
Should the regime collapse, there is a grave risk of a sectarian bloodbath as Sunnis settle scores.
Apart from Sunnis and ShiaAllewites, Syria is also home to Christians, Druzes and small numbers of Jews and Yazdis.
These minorities fear that once the brutal but secular government of Bashar al-Assad is deposed, the next one might not be as tolerant. They have reason to be worried, judging from the targeted killings of Christians in Egypt and Iraq. Indeed, around half of the country`s million-plus Christians have fled their homes in post-Saddam Iraq. The ancient, pre-Islamic Maronite community of Egypt makes up around 10 per cent of the population, and has been persecuted for years. But now, without the minimal protection they received from Mubarak, they fear the worst under an Islamic dispensation.
Libya today is witnessing regional fragmentation as local militias grab power, and confront a weak and chaotic Transitional National Council. Given the disunity and confusion, there are few prospects of a stable govern-ment emerging anytime soon. So clearly, it is easier to remove a despotic regime than it is to replace it with a democratic one.
Returning to Syria, it seems that a diplomatic solution is the only way forward if we are to avoid a messy endgame of the sort we saw in Iraq and are witnessing in Libya. Clearly, the Kofi Anan formula has collapsed under the weight of multiple breaches of the fragile truce by both sides. Britain and the US are now trying to persuade the Syrian dictator to go into exile with a guarantee of immunity from prosecution. This is known as the Yemen model whereby President Saleh stepped down after months of bloody street protests.
In an ideal world, a movement against dictatorship should culminate in the emergence of a freely elected, democratic government. Sadly, things are never that simple. Vestiges of the old regime continue to cling to power, as we are seeing in Egypt:with the military and security forces still entrenched, they are placing a series of roadblocks on the road to democracy.
How should the world react when faced with the kind of bloodbath we are witnessing in Syria today? Decent people want to see it end, and the only way to stop it seems to be the immediate removal of the dictator. Thus, the Nato campaign to rid Libya of Qadhafi was widely welcomed at the time. But few people are concerned with the disturbing aftermath. Similarly, hardly anybody in the West is aware of the disastrous impact of Saddam Hussein`s removal on women and the minorities in Iraq.
These are tricky moral and political issues, and there are no easy answers. Unfortunately, these questions are not properly discussed in Pakistan where, despite or because of our 24/7 rolling news and TV chat shows, we get more confused than ever.with the military and security forces still entrenched, they are placing a series of roadblocks on the road to democracy.
How should the world react when faced with the kind of bloodbath we are witnessing in Syria today? Decent people want to see it end, and the only way to stop it seems to be the immediate removal of the dictator. Thus, the Nato campaign to rid Libya of Qadhafi was widely welcomed at the time. But few people are concerned with the disturbing aftermath. Similarly, hardly anybody in the West is aware of the disastrous impact of Saddam Hussein`s removal on women and the minorities in Iraq.
These are tricky moral and political issues, and there are no easy answers. Unfortunately, these questions are not properly discussed in Pakistan where, despite or because of our 24/7 rolling news and TV chat shows, we get more confused than ever.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)