WHO will get to vote, and will the Election Commission be able to
protect that vote? The new chief election commissioner was sworn in
yesterday, and these are the two major issues he should focus on before
the next polls. As many as 20 million Pakistanis of voting age the
majority of them women are estimated to have been unregistered in the
draft electoral rolls revealed in March. The other major problem was
registration of citizens at the wrong addresses, especially migrants
registered in their hometowns. What is important now is that the time is
taken to fix these flaws if they still exist in the updated rolls due
this month so that no citizens especially women, migrants and young
people who have recently turned 18 are disenfranchised. There has been a
general hurry about this, with the ECP, in part pushed by the Supreme
Court, rushing to draft rolls, producing a flawed list and missing
several self-imposed revision deadlines. But if the new list is also
flawed, the ECP needs to ensure citizens have an easier way to check and
correct their status this time by increasing the number of display
centres and making the process more efficient. In the worst case, if
problems are widespread, it may have to conduct another door-to-door
exercise. But ensuring that all citizenshave the ability to vote is
worth the effort.
There is also the issue of the ECP`s authority
over polling staff. Brought in from the local bureaucracy, they are not
subject to disciplinary action by the commission. Nor does the ECP have
the authority to transfer or discipline administrators, such as those
from Wapda or the police, who can influence outcomes in their areas.
Electoral
reforms to address these issues have been praised in the Indian
context, but they are languishing somewhere between the ECP and
parliament in Pakistan, and now is the time to pass them. There are
other issues with staff too both polling staff and many returning
officers are under pressure from local politicians. Posting them outside
their districts, or appointing more lower-court judges as returning
officers, are alternatives to look into.
Much progress has been
made since the last election. Linking electoral rolls to Nadra data has
reduced duplication and will allow more reliable identification of
voters.
We now have an ECP and a CEC appointed by consensus
between the government and the opposition. But these improvements are
not enough. More people need to be able to vote, and the commission
needs to be empowered. It is worth taking the time to do this before the
country goes to the polls.
Tuesday, July 24, 2012
Afghan couple looking for asylum in peshawar
PESHAWAR, July 23: The Peshawar High Court on Monday quashed a case of
illegal entry and stay in Pakistan against an Afghan couple, who fled
their country after facing death threats over marriage.
A bench comprising Chief Justice Dost Mohammad Khan and Justice Shahjehan Khan Akhunzada handed over the couple to local police directing them to keep them at a safe place preferably the women`s police station or police lines and provide them with food, clothes and money for daily expenditure.
The court fixed for July 31 the hearing into the case. The couple were produced before the bench on the orders of the chief justice, who had taken a suo motu notice of their arrest by Abbottabad police.
The complainant in the case against the couple, Ishaq Khan, appeared before the court and alleged that the woman, Ms Maryam, already married to his brother, had eloped with the man, Hewad.
He informed the bench that he had been legally living in Peshawar`s Scheme Chowk and possessed a proof of registration card issued by Nadra.
The bench ordered the card`s verification, which revealed that the card was fake.
The bench ordered Mr Ishaq`s arrest and directed the SHO of the relevant east cantonment police station to investigate how he acquired the card and who the culpable officials were.
Senior superintendent of police (investigation), Abbottabad, Raza Hussain and the SHO of the relevant Mirpur police station produced the couple, saying they were taken into custody on complaint lodged by Ishaq, who claimed to be the brother-in-law of thewoman, Ms Maryam.
They added that the couple illegally stayed in Pakistan and therefore, FIR was registered against them under Section 14 of the Foreigners Act.
The chief justice observed that hundreds of thousands of Afghan nationals had illegally been roaming around but the authorities had not been taking action against them and in that light, why action was taken against the said couple.
The chief justice observed that the couple had escaped from Afghanistan under serious circumstances for asylum here and it was not appropriate for po-lice to use the Foreigners Act for them.
The couple told the judges and later journalists that instead of returning to Afghanistan, they would prefer dieing in Pakistan.
The couple were taken into custody four days ago by Mirpur police in Abbottabad.
A local judicial magistrate sent the woman, 22, to a women`s shelter house and the man charged under Section 14 of Foreigners Act to Mansehra prison.
The couple claimed that father of Maryam had planned to marry her against her consent and therefore, she escaped to Pakistan along with Hewad.
A bench comprising Chief Justice Dost Mohammad Khan and Justice Shahjehan Khan Akhunzada handed over the couple to local police directing them to keep them at a safe place preferably the women`s police station or police lines and provide them with food, clothes and money for daily expenditure.
The court fixed for July 31 the hearing into the case. The couple were produced before the bench on the orders of the chief justice, who had taken a suo motu notice of their arrest by Abbottabad police.
The complainant in the case against the couple, Ishaq Khan, appeared before the court and alleged that the woman, Ms Maryam, already married to his brother, had eloped with the man, Hewad.
He informed the bench that he had been legally living in Peshawar`s Scheme Chowk and possessed a proof of registration card issued by Nadra.
The bench ordered the card`s verification, which revealed that the card was fake.
The bench ordered Mr Ishaq`s arrest and directed the SHO of the relevant east cantonment police station to investigate how he acquired the card and who the culpable officials were.
Senior superintendent of police (investigation), Abbottabad, Raza Hussain and the SHO of the relevant Mirpur police station produced the couple, saying they were taken into custody on complaint lodged by Ishaq, who claimed to be the brother-in-law of thewoman, Ms Maryam.
They added that the couple illegally stayed in Pakistan and therefore, FIR was registered against them under Section 14 of the Foreigners Act.
The chief justice observed that hundreds of thousands of Afghan nationals had illegally been roaming around but the authorities had not been taking action against them and in that light, why action was taken against the said couple.
The chief justice observed that the couple had escaped from Afghanistan under serious circumstances for asylum here and it was not appropriate for po-lice to use the Foreigners Act for them.
The couple told the judges and later journalists that instead of returning to Afghanistan, they would prefer dieing in Pakistan.
The couple were taken into custody four days ago by Mirpur police in Abbottabad.
A local judicial magistrate sent the woman, 22, to a women`s shelter house and the man charged under Section 14 of Foreigners Act to Mansehra prison.
The couple claimed that father of Maryam had planned to marry her against her consent and therefore, she escaped to Pakistan along with Hewad.
Only fair polls can secure future: CEC
ISLAMABAD, July 23: Justice (retd) Fakhruddin G.
Ebrahim who took the oath of the Chief Election Commissioner on Monday has said that only three free and fair general elections have been held in the history of the country.
At a meeting he held with members, officers and employees of the commission, Justice Ebrahim said that the elections held in 1971, 1988 and 2008 were to some extent free and fair.
Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhry administered the oath to the new CEC at a ceremony attended by judges of the Supreme Court, members and officers of the Election Commission and senior lawyers.
Justice Ebrahim said the country`s future depended on transparent and fair electionsand his one-point agenda was to hold free and fair elections.
`We have the Constitution and electoral laws to guide us and do not have to look here and there,` sources quoted him as saying at the meeting.
He asked officers and staff of the Election Commission to work with dedication and honesty without any pressure.
He said it was his dream to give a prosperous and democratic Pakistan to the new generation and the Election Commission was the institution which could turn the dream into reality.
`We have only one-point agenda and that is public justice through free, fair, transparent and impartial elections so that no-one could ever point a finger at the impartiality of the EC and all employees of the EC should work to achieve that goal.He said democracy was a philosophy leading to a democratic system and this could only be achieved through a process of election. Justice Ebrahim said that the Constitution and law would be followed by the Election Commission in holding free and fair elections.
Talking to reporters after the swearing-in ceremony, he said it was the prerogative of the government to hold elections, adding that his earlier statement about the need for early elections had been made in his personal capacity.
Justice Ebrahim said his predecessor had recently said that the commission was ready to hold general and local government elections and he was confident that this was the factual position.
Meanwhile, PMIzN Senator Syed Zafar Ali Shah has expressed reservations over Justice Ebrahim`s views about fairness of elections held in 1971, 1988 and 2008.
He said there was no doubt that the 1971 polls were free and fair, but Mujibur Rehman`s Awami League, and not the PPP, emerged victorious.
In accordance with the principle of majority, the Awami League should have formed the government but the PPP because of what he termed its lust for power dismembered the country.
He said that the elections held in 1988 were to a large extent free from interference of the establishment which was under pressure at that time. He said the polls had taken place months after the death of Gen Ziaul Haq in a plane crash in Bahawalpur and Ghulam Ishaq Khan, being the acting president, had no political interests.He said that Gen (retd) Aslam Beg was the chief of the army staff who avoided meddling in the electoral process.
About 2008 elections, the PML-N leader said Justice Ebrahim appeared to have some misunderstanding about fairness of the polls which `in no way were either free or fair` He said the elections were held under military ruler Gen (retd) Pervez Musharraf and even the president of the `King`s party`, Chaudhry Shujaat Hussain was on record having said that his defeat had been engineered by the establishment.`Justice Fakhruddin G. Ebrahim is a good jurist and let us see how he holds next general elections,` he said.
Justice Ebrahim is the first Chief Election Commissioner appointed through a changed procedure involving a parliamentary committee with equal representation of the treasury and opposition. He is also the first CEC appointed for a term of five years under a provision of the 18th Constitution Amendment.
Ebrahim who took the oath of the Chief Election Commissioner on Monday has said that only three free and fair general elections have been held in the history of the country.
At a meeting he held with members, officers and employees of the commission, Justice Ebrahim said that the elections held in 1971, 1988 and 2008 were to some extent free and fair.
Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhry administered the oath to the new CEC at a ceremony attended by judges of the Supreme Court, members and officers of the Election Commission and senior lawyers.
Justice Ebrahim said the country`s future depended on transparent and fair electionsand his one-point agenda was to hold free and fair elections.
`We have the Constitution and electoral laws to guide us and do not have to look here and there,` sources quoted him as saying at the meeting.
He asked officers and staff of the Election Commission to work with dedication and honesty without any pressure.
He said it was his dream to give a prosperous and democratic Pakistan to the new generation and the Election Commission was the institution which could turn the dream into reality.
`We have only one-point agenda and that is public justice through free, fair, transparent and impartial elections so that no-one could ever point a finger at the impartiality of the EC and all employees of the EC should work to achieve that goal.He said democracy was a philosophy leading to a democratic system and this could only be achieved through a process of election. Justice Ebrahim said that the Constitution and law would be followed by the Election Commission in holding free and fair elections.
Talking to reporters after the swearing-in ceremony, he said it was the prerogative of the government to hold elections, adding that his earlier statement about the need for early elections had been made in his personal capacity.
Justice Ebrahim said his predecessor had recently said that the commission was ready to hold general and local government elections and he was confident that this was the factual position.
Meanwhile, PMIzN Senator Syed Zafar Ali Shah has expressed reservations over Justice Ebrahim`s views about fairness of elections held in 1971, 1988 and 2008.
He said there was no doubt that the 1971 polls were free and fair, but Mujibur Rehman`s Awami League, and not the PPP, emerged victorious.
In accordance with the principle of majority, the Awami League should have formed the government but the PPP because of what he termed its lust for power dismembered the country.
He said that the elections held in 1988 were to a large extent free from interference of the establishment which was under pressure at that time. He said the polls had taken place months after the death of Gen Ziaul Haq in a plane crash in Bahawalpur and Ghulam Ishaq Khan, being the acting president, had no political interests.He said that Gen (retd) Aslam Beg was the chief of the army staff who avoided meddling in the electoral process.
About 2008 elections, the PML-N leader said Justice Ebrahim appeared to have some misunderstanding about fairness of the polls which `in no way were either free or fair` He said the elections were held under military ruler Gen (retd) Pervez Musharraf and even the president of the `King`s party`, Chaudhry Shujaat Hussain was on record having said that his defeat had been engineered by the establishment.`Justice Fakhruddin G. Ebrahim is a good jurist and let us see how he holds next general elections,` he said.
Justice Ebrahim is the first Chief Election Commissioner appointed through a changed procedure involving a parliamentary committee with equal representation of the treasury and opposition. He is also the first CEC appointed for a term of five years under a provision of the 18th Constitution Amendment.
Friday, July 20, 2012
Syria - Blow to Asad
ALREADY on its knees, the Syrian regime of Bashar al-Assad took another
body blow on Wednesday. The assassination of three of the regime`s top
security advisers, including the defence minister, occurred in the heart
of the capital and highlighted the continued shrinkage of the area
under Baathist control. On Wednesday also, 600 more Syrians, including
two brigadier generals, crossed over to Turkey, thus adding to the ranks
of the Free Syrian Army. With fighting no longer confined to the
provinces helicopters and artillery are shelling parts of Damascus there
are rumours that President Assad`s whereabouts are not known. There is
no doubt the 17-month-old uprising has now turned into a ferocious civil
war, with the opposition claiming 17,000 fatalities. After Libya, this
is the highest death toll for an `Arab spring`country.
President Assad missed the bus in April when he accepted Kofi Annan`s six-point plan only to renege on it. The plan had provided for a ceasefire and smooth transition to democracy. The caretakercabinet proposal, too, is dead. Even Russia had agreed to a neutral cabinet in which there would be men from both sides.
But President Assad`s intransigence scuttled it when he insisted that he should be part of it. This was not acceptable to the opposition. Fissures in the security establishment have now been so widened and the loyalist ranks so weakened that Assad is pulling troops out of the Golan Heights to bolster security around him. The world has watched the fate of the four Arab dictators who have fallen. It is now for President Assad to decide whether he would choose to seek a Saleh-like amnesty and go abroad or suffer a worse fate. If his regime falls, there could be repercussions in the region. The causes of the uprising are not sectarian, but the fact that the Alawite minority has been ruling for four decades may give a sectarIan touch to the aftermath.
If there is a sectarian flare-up, there could be political fallout in neighbouring Lebanon. Iran would lose one of its allies and that would also affect Hezbollah and Hamas.
President Assad missed the bus in April when he accepted Kofi Annan`s six-point plan only to renege on it. The plan had provided for a ceasefire and smooth transition to democracy. The caretakercabinet proposal, too, is dead. Even Russia had agreed to a neutral cabinet in which there would be men from both sides.
But President Assad`s intransigence scuttled it when he insisted that he should be part of it. This was not acceptable to the opposition. Fissures in the security establishment have now been so widened and the loyalist ranks so weakened that Assad is pulling troops out of the Golan Heights to bolster security around him. The world has watched the fate of the four Arab dictators who have fallen. It is now for President Assad to decide whether he would choose to seek a Saleh-like amnesty and go abroad or suffer a worse fate. If his regime falls, there could be repercussions in the region. The causes of the uprising are not sectarian, but the fact that the Alawite minority has been ruling for four decades may give a sectarIan touch to the aftermath.
If there is a sectarian flare-up, there could be political fallout in neighbouring Lebanon. Iran would lose one of its allies and that would also affect Hezbollah and Hamas.
New ambassadors to Af-Pak
TWO new envoys in critical posts at a critical time for the region: the
replacement of the American ambassadors in Kabul and Islamabad is both a
risk and an opportunity for a fresh start. Continuity at such a
delicate stage might have worked better than the early departures of the
outgoing chief diplomats; Cameron Munter left in less than two years
and Ryan Crocker in just one. And lingering sources of tension with
America in both countries will not make these changes simple or easy. Mr
Munter had been here for some of the most damaging episodes in USPak
relations, but much about this relationship still remains to be sorted
out, particularly on the counterterrorism front.
And while Mr Crocker helped develop the framework that will guide the withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan, the trickiest part of it is likely to be its implementation; the new envoy will have to manage both Afghan anxiety about the country`s security post-2014 and mistrust of the American presence.
But persistent problems also suggest that new faces could become an opportunity to reset ties.
In part this is because the success of American diplomacy here depends as much on how Washington works as it does on what goes on in Kabul or Islamabad. Mr Munter reportedly wanted to takea less aggressive approach to Pakistan than the CIA, on drone strikes, for example. And although Mr Crocker`s health was put forward as the reason for his departure, he is said to have been in favour of a slower withdrawal from Afghanistan than has been planned.
The more effective the US wants its new envoys to be, the more coordinated the Pentagon, the CIA, the State Department, the Af-Pak office within the State Department and the White House will need to be while still allowing the diplomats the independence they need to do their jobs. With Pakistan the main sticking point is counterterrorism, and in Kabul the focus is on war. Ambassadors, military and intelligence will have to develop consistent approaches without constricting the space for diplomacy to work.
For Pakistan an ambassador coming from a post in the Kabul embassy, as is Richard Olson, is not likely to wholly sympathise with its point of view. Alternatively, his contacts with Kabul could help navigate our own tricky relations with Afghanistan and coordinate a more integrated American approach to the region. Most importantly, the hope is that he is able to bring to Islamabad an open mind and the ability to balance America`s counterterrorism demands with Pakistan`s interests, politics and public opinion.
And while Mr Crocker helped develop the framework that will guide the withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan, the trickiest part of it is likely to be its implementation; the new envoy will have to manage both Afghan anxiety about the country`s security post-2014 and mistrust of the American presence.
But persistent problems also suggest that new faces could become an opportunity to reset ties.
In part this is because the success of American diplomacy here depends as much on how Washington works as it does on what goes on in Kabul or Islamabad. Mr Munter reportedly wanted to takea less aggressive approach to Pakistan than the CIA, on drone strikes, for example. And although Mr Crocker`s health was put forward as the reason for his departure, he is said to have been in favour of a slower withdrawal from Afghanistan than has been planned.
The more effective the US wants its new envoys to be, the more coordinated the Pentagon, the CIA, the State Department, the Af-Pak office within the State Department and the White House will need to be while still allowing the diplomats the independence they need to do their jobs. With Pakistan the main sticking point is counterterrorism, and in Kabul the focus is on war. Ambassadors, military and intelligence will have to develop consistent approaches without constricting the space for diplomacy to work.
For Pakistan an ambassador coming from a post in the Kabul embassy, as is Richard Olson, is not likely to wholly sympathise with its point of view. Alternatively, his contacts with Kabul could help navigate our own tricky relations with Afghanistan and coordinate a more integrated American approach to the region. Most importantly, the hope is that he is able to bring to Islamabad an open mind and the ability to balance America`s counterterrorism demands with Pakistan`s interests, politics and public opinion.
`WHAT is this social media, and why is it so important?`
`WHAT is this social media, and why is it so important?` Variations of
this question rang out all weekend as news spread of the Social Media
Mela, a conference that brought Indian journalists, writers, and
activists to Karachi to discuss with their Pakistani counterparts how
the social media has affected various aspects of their lives.
According to Wikipedia, social media is, simply put, `web-based and mobile-based technologies which are used to turn communication into interactive dialogue among organisations, communities, and individuals` (also known as Web 2.0). It includes Twitter and Facbeook, but also blogs and microblogs, online communities, YouTube and any other space on the Web that is accessible to all and enabled by `scalable communication techniques` meaning that it can be accessed as easily on a humble mobile phone as on a sophisticated laptop.
The conference illustrated how Pakistanis are using social media, integrating it into culture, politics, activism and education, amongst other disciplines and areas, in a positive and constructive way.
Recognising the potential of the social media to effect farreaching change in Pakistan, the US Consulate organised last year`s social media conference but this year took a back seat and left it to the NGO PeaceNiche, run by Sabeen Mahmud. She and her team decided to make Pakistan-India relations a primary theme at this year`s event, and for many attendees, the highlight of the weekend was meeting theIndian guests who were able to attend thanks to former Interior Minister Rehman Malik`s personal influence in having their visas issued.
The conference had a laid-back, relaxed feel with a desi atmosphere.
Speakers from a variety of organisations and disciplines, as well as appeal-ing graphic designs, gave the mela a unique branding, with an army of young volunteers ushering guests around the venue and a buzz that lingered for several days after the event. During the sessions, attendees learned how the social media has been used to raise funds for a movie in India (`crowdfunding`), enhance and support the learning activities in a school in Kashmir, effect political change through online petitions, create instant celebrities in the arts and media, engage Pakistani youth in the political process and raise awareness about media ethics, sexual harassment and human rights issues. The Indian guests returned home with many negative illusions about Pakistan countered, and crates of mangoes to share with their families.
But the conference was as much about the limits of social media as it was about what it can achieve. This was brought to light in Ali Dayan Hasan`s keynote speech on social media and human rights. The Pakistan director of Human Rights Watch said that the social media helped spread information quickly and was useful for recording human rights abuses, but policymakers had to listen and effectchange in government which the social media has not been able to achieve.
Raheel Khursheed, communications director for India`s Change.org, also addressed the issue of armchair activism enabled by the social media, saying bluntly that online activism was useless if it was not followed by real-world action. Beena Sarwar, a peace activist, echoed Hasan in her blog observations about the social media conference: `Political establishments have the power to change [the situation between India and Pakistan], if only they would follow the voice of the people.
That voice is being expressedlouderthaneveron the social media, but is anyone from the government actually listening? In Pakistan, there is an image problem in the context of the social media. Its proponents sometimes expect far too much of it; they are almost evangelical about its powers to change society and the political system. They will be disappointed by the fact that the social media mela did not solve the Kashmir problem, eliminate corruption, stop the killing of the Hazara Shias or the Baloch, or the persecution of Ahmadis and Christians.
Such people need constant reminding that the revolution will not come just because people click `like` on a Facebook link or retweet a popular politician`s messages.
By the same token, many don`t take the social media seriously enough. Its detractors are often those who simply don`t understand it. Take the example of Pakistani journalists who think that the social media is merely reporting about social events.
Jokes aside, mainstreammedia in Pakistan has practitioners who feel that the social media is no competition to traditional print or broadcast journalism, or lacks legitimacy as a medium. And those Pakistani politicians who are online and tweeting to their followers seem to think of the social media as a game or a popularity contest: who has the most ardent followers or who has the most abusive trolls.
The power of the social media lies in its ability to give a voice to people traditionally left out of the mainstream media, to hold political figures and governments to account for their actions and abuses, and to mobilise people to action in communities and across them.
But there`s still a huge gap between intent and action, and it will take several years for the social media scene in Pakistan to mature enough to have a tangible effect on governance and policy. Still, learning, observing and experimenting without fear is the most intelligent approach to understanding what the social media can and can`t do for us. The writer is the author of Slum Child.
binashah@yahoo.com
According to Wikipedia, social media is, simply put, `web-based and mobile-based technologies which are used to turn communication into interactive dialogue among organisations, communities, and individuals` (also known as Web 2.0). It includes Twitter and Facbeook, but also blogs and microblogs, online communities, YouTube and any other space on the Web that is accessible to all and enabled by `scalable communication techniques` meaning that it can be accessed as easily on a humble mobile phone as on a sophisticated laptop.
The conference illustrated how Pakistanis are using social media, integrating it into culture, politics, activism and education, amongst other disciplines and areas, in a positive and constructive way.
Recognising the potential of the social media to effect farreaching change in Pakistan, the US Consulate organised last year`s social media conference but this year took a back seat and left it to the NGO PeaceNiche, run by Sabeen Mahmud. She and her team decided to make Pakistan-India relations a primary theme at this year`s event, and for many attendees, the highlight of the weekend was meeting theIndian guests who were able to attend thanks to former Interior Minister Rehman Malik`s personal influence in having their visas issued.
The conference had a laid-back, relaxed feel with a desi atmosphere.
Speakers from a variety of organisations and disciplines, as well as appeal-ing graphic designs, gave the mela a unique branding, with an army of young volunteers ushering guests around the venue and a buzz that lingered for several days after the event. During the sessions, attendees learned how the social media has been used to raise funds for a movie in India (`crowdfunding`), enhance and support the learning activities in a school in Kashmir, effect political change through online petitions, create instant celebrities in the arts and media, engage Pakistani youth in the political process and raise awareness about media ethics, sexual harassment and human rights issues. The Indian guests returned home with many negative illusions about Pakistan countered, and crates of mangoes to share with their families.
But the conference was as much about the limits of social media as it was about what it can achieve. This was brought to light in Ali Dayan Hasan`s keynote speech on social media and human rights. The Pakistan director of Human Rights Watch said that the social media helped spread information quickly and was useful for recording human rights abuses, but policymakers had to listen and effectchange in government which the social media has not been able to achieve.
Raheel Khursheed, communications director for India`s Change.org, also addressed the issue of armchair activism enabled by the social media, saying bluntly that online activism was useless if it was not followed by real-world action. Beena Sarwar, a peace activist, echoed Hasan in her blog observations about the social media conference: `Political establishments have the power to change [the situation between India and Pakistan], if only they would follow the voice of the people.
That voice is being expressedlouderthaneveron the social media, but is anyone from the government actually listening? In Pakistan, there is an image problem in the context of the social media. Its proponents sometimes expect far too much of it; they are almost evangelical about its powers to change society and the political system. They will be disappointed by the fact that the social media mela did not solve the Kashmir problem, eliminate corruption, stop the killing of the Hazara Shias or the Baloch, or the persecution of Ahmadis and Christians.
Such people need constant reminding that the revolution will not come just because people click `like` on a Facebook link or retweet a popular politician`s messages.
By the same token, many don`t take the social media seriously enough. Its detractors are often those who simply don`t understand it. Take the example of Pakistani journalists who think that the social media is merely reporting about social events.
Jokes aside, mainstreammedia in Pakistan has practitioners who feel that the social media is no competition to traditional print or broadcast journalism, or lacks legitimacy as a medium. And those Pakistani politicians who are online and tweeting to their followers seem to think of the social media as a game or a popularity contest: who has the most ardent followers or who has the most abusive trolls.
The power of the social media lies in its ability to give a voice to people traditionally left out of the mainstream media, to hold political figures and governments to account for their actions and abuses, and to mobilise people to action in communities and across them.
But there`s still a huge gap between intent and action, and it will take several years for the social media scene in Pakistan to mature enough to have a tangible effect on governance and policy. Still, learning, observing and experimenting without fear is the most intelligent approach to understanding what the social media can and can`t do for us. The writer is the author of Slum Child.
binashah@yahoo.com
Qadir Gilani scrapes through in neck `n` neck fight
MULTAN, July 19: A contest which the PPP expected to be a walkover turned out to be a neck `n` neck fight in Multan on Thursday.
The voters of the NA-151 constituency gave their mandate to Abdul Qadir Gilani, son of disqualified prime minister Yousuf Raza Gilani, but it was only a marginal victory for the PPP.
According to observers, the thin margin of the Gilani junior`s victory showed that the voters were disgruntled with the ruling party.
Independent candidate Shaukat Bosan, who was being dubbed the underdog despite enjoying the support of major opposition parties PTI, PML-N and the JI, put up a tough fight and lost by only 4,096 votes.According to unofficial results, Mr Gilani secured 64,628 votes and Mr Bosan 60,532.
Celebrations erupted in the Gilani camp once the count was completed.
There was tension in both camps during the count and fortunes fluctuated as results trickled in.
The Election Commission had set up 245 polling stations 62 for men, 59 for women and 123 joint with 712 booths.
The number of registered voters was 307,871.
Although the EC had declared 64 polling stations sensitive, the electoral process went on peacefully, except in Khairpur Bhutta where two groups occasionally fired into the air.
Ten candidates were in the run but only Mr Gilani contested on a party tick-et.
The polling began at 8am and concluded at 5pm.
Urban stations saw a slow turnout, but polling in rural areas was brisk throughout the day.
Many voters reached polling stations on their own as under the new election rules candidates were not allowed to arrange pick-and-drop facility for them and the EC failed to provide transport in several areas.
The commission, however, made adequate arrangements to provide slips to voters containing their names, voter numbers and polling station by setting up camps outside polling booths.
But several voters at the Muhammadpura Ghota polling station complained that the slips were incorrect.

The voters of the NA-151 constituency gave their mandate to Abdul Qadir Gilani, son of disqualified prime minister Yousuf Raza Gilani, but it was only a marginal victory for the PPP.
According to observers, the thin margin of the Gilani junior`s victory showed that the voters were disgruntled with the ruling party.
Independent candidate Shaukat Bosan, who was being dubbed the underdog despite enjoying the support of major opposition parties PTI, PML-N and the JI, put up a tough fight and lost by only 4,096 votes.According to unofficial results, Mr Gilani secured 64,628 votes and Mr Bosan 60,532.
Celebrations erupted in the Gilani camp once the count was completed.
There was tension in both camps during the count and fortunes fluctuated as results trickled in.
The Election Commission had set up 245 polling stations 62 for men, 59 for women and 123 joint with 712 booths.
The number of registered voters was 307,871.
Although the EC had declared 64 polling stations sensitive, the electoral process went on peacefully, except in Khairpur Bhutta where two groups occasionally fired into the air.
Ten candidates were in the run but only Mr Gilani contested on a party tick-et.
The polling began at 8am and concluded at 5pm.
Urban stations saw a slow turnout, but polling in rural areas was brisk throughout the day.
Many voters reached polling stations on their own as under the new election rules candidates were not allowed to arrange pick-and-drop facility for them and the EC failed to provide transport in several areas.
The commission, however, made adequate arrangements to provide slips to voters containing their names, voter numbers and polling station by setting up camps outside polling booths.
But several voters at the Muhammadpura Ghota polling station complained that the slips were incorrect.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)