THE untapped gold and copper deposits at Reko Dig are in the news again,
with more of the same further delays. The dispute at the moment is over
which lawyers will hear the case in international arbitration. But this
is only the latest obstacle in a standoff between a foreign mining
company and the Balochistan government that flared up a year and a half
ago over the reportedly massive deposits in the province. And it has
been nearly two decades since an exploration agreement was first signed
that could by now have helped transform Balochistan`s fortunes. Now
stuck in both the Supreme Court and in international arbitration, the
disagreement shows no signs of being resolved while the province relies
on handouts from the federal government and languishes for lack of
development.
Each side offers a series of arguments against the
other. Tethyan Copper claims the 1993 agreement includes a generous
pay-off for the provincial government and that there was no valid reason
to deny them a mining license after they invested more than $200m in
exploration. Balochistanclaims the agreement offers no real financial
benefit for the province and did not guarantee a mining license, and
that the company has failed to begin mining for years. Lost in all of
this is the bigger picture.
For one, although various speculative
figures are thrown around by people on both sides of the debate who
undervalue or overvalue the deposits depending on their motivations,
Reko Dig is a substantial deposit by global standards. The Balochistan
government needs to get realistic about whether it has the means or the
expertise to tap into this badly needed source of revenue. Second, the
matter goes beyond Reko Diq.
Foreign direct investment has been
falling for the last four years, including by 50 per cent in 2011-12. If
this case becomes yet another example of Pakistani economic policies
and contracts changing depending on the government in power, that will
only further damage the country`s reputation as an investment
destination. It is worth trying to put nationalist rhetoric aside and
reshape the agreement rather than necessarily throwing it out
altogether.
Monday, July 30, 2012
THE untapped gold and copper deposits at Reko Dig
Cross-border attacks from Afghanistan
AT the Aspen Security Conference, Pakistani Ambassador to the US Sherry
Rehman and President Obama`s special adviser on Afghanistan and
Pakistan, Gen Douglas Lute (retd), squared off over cross-border raids
on Saturday.
When Ms Rehman complained about the rising incidents of cross-border attacks from Afghanistan into Pakistan, Mr Lute struck back with longstanding accusations that Pakistan was effectively sponsoring Afghan Taliban attacks inside Afghanistan from sanctuaries on the Pakistani side of the border. Who`s right, who`s wrong partisans can debate the subject endlessly. More independent observers would suggest that both sides are to blame. The recent attacks into Pakistan particularly the savage attacks in Dir in June, but also in Bajaur and Mohmand agencies have clearly riled up the Pakistani security establishment, which believes that Afghan and American forces in Afghanistan have either looked the other way or not done enough to stop the attacks into Pakistan. It is an entirely plausible accusation and one that neither the Afghan government nor the Americans have done much to credibly distance themselves from.
The danger at presentis that the low-level attacks into Pakistan could spiral out of control as Pakistan reacts and Afghanistan counter-reacts. In response to the killings and beheadings of Pakistani security per-sonnel in Dir, the Pakistani security forces shelled villages along the border in Kunar where they believed the attacks emanated from.
Angered by this, the Afghan forces have shown signs of increasingly turning to hot pursuit of Afghan militants with sanctuaries on this side of the border. If not checked, this cycle of violence and counter-violence could get out of control, particularly given acute mistrust on both sides of the border.
Unwelcome as the suggestion may be in Pakistani security circles, perhaps the first move toward ratcheting down the tension should come from the Pakistani side. Unpalatable as it is, Douglas Lute was closer to the truth than Ms Rehman`s formulation when he said, `There`s no comparison of the Pakistani Taliban`s relatively recent, small-in-scale presence inside Afghanistan ...
to the decades-long experience and relations between elements of the Pakistani government and the Afghan Taliban.` The key, then, to resolving this or realistically, just managing the problem lies perhaps in North Waziristan. While the Haqqani network contributes no more than 15-20 per cent of attacks inside Afghanistan, it does carry out a disproportionately large number of the highprofile, headline-grabbing attacks. If something were tobe done aboutthatproblem, perhaps cooperation from the Afghan side on problems that concern Pakistan would be forthcoming.
When Ms Rehman complained about the rising incidents of cross-border attacks from Afghanistan into Pakistan, Mr Lute struck back with longstanding accusations that Pakistan was effectively sponsoring Afghan Taliban attacks inside Afghanistan from sanctuaries on the Pakistani side of the border. Who`s right, who`s wrong partisans can debate the subject endlessly. More independent observers would suggest that both sides are to blame. The recent attacks into Pakistan particularly the savage attacks in Dir in June, but also in Bajaur and Mohmand agencies have clearly riled up the Pakistani security establishment, which believes that Afghan and American forces in Afghanistan have either looked the other way or not done enough to stop the attacks into Pakistan. It is an entirely plausible accusation and one that neither the Afghan government nor the Americans have done much to credibly distance themselves from.
The danger at presentis that the low-level attacks into Pakistan could spiral out of control as Pakistan reacts and Afghanistan counter-reacts. In response to the killings and beheadings of Pakistani security per-sonnel in Dir, the Pakistani security forces shelled villages along the border in Kunar where they believed the attacks emanated from.
Angered by this, the Afghan forces have shown signs of increasingly turning to hot pursuit of Afghan militants with sanctuaries on this side of the border. If not checked, this cycle of violence and counter-violence could get out of control, particularly given acute mistrust on both sides of the border.
Unwelcome as the suggestion may be in Pakistani security circles, perhaps the first move toward ratcheting down the tension should come from the Pakistani side. Unpalatable as it is, Douglas Lute was closer to the truth than Ms Rehman`s formulation when he said, `There`s no comparison of the Pakistani Taliban`s relatively recent, small-in-scale presence inside Afghanistan ...
to the decades-long experience and relations between elements of the Pakistani government and the Afghan Taliban.` The key, then, to resolving this or realistically, just managing the problem lies perhaps in North Waziristan. While the Haqqani network contributes no more than 15-20 per cent of attacks inside Afghanistan, it does carry out a disproportionately large number of the highprofile, headline-grabbing attacks. If something were tobe done aboutthatproblem, perhaps cooperation from the Afghan side on problems that concern Pakistan would be forthcoming.
UN Rights Envoy in Myanmar
YANGON, July 29: The United Nations expert on human rights in Myanmar
arrived in the country late Sunday, days after the UN voiced fears that
efforts to end unrest in Rakhine state had turned into a crackdown on
Muslims.
UN Special Rapporteur Tomas Ojea Quintana flew into the main city of Yangon for a visit set to include a trip to the restive western state as well as meetings with Myanmar`s president and civil society.It comes after a warning by UN human rights chief Navi Pillay that Muslim communities in Rakhine, particularly the Rohingya minority, were being targeted by security forces.
`We have been receiving a stream of reports from independent sources alleging discriminatory and arbitrary responses by security forces, and even their instigation of and involvement in clashes,` she said in a statement Friday.
Quintana says that Myanmarhas made `significant` progress on reforms under President Thein Sein, who came to power last year, but said the country faced `ongoing human rights challenges` Violence between Buddhist ethnic Rakhine and Muslim Rohingya communities erupted in early June and have left at least 78 people dead and 70,000 homeless, according to official figures.
Unofficial estimates of the death toll were higher, the UN said.
UN Special Rapporteur Tomas Ojea Quintana flew into the main city of Yangon for a visit set to include a trip to the restive western state as well as meetings with Myanmar`s president and civil society.It comes after a warning by UN human rights chief Navi Pillay that Muslim communities in Rakhine, particularly the Rohingya minority, were being targeted by security forces.
`We have been receiving a stream of reports from independent sources alleging discriminatory and arbitrary responses by security forces, and even their instigation of and involvement in clashes,` she said in a statement Friday.
Quintana says that Myanmarhas made `significant` progress on reforms under President Thein Sein, who came to power last year, but said the country faced `ongoing human rights challenges` Violence between Buddhist ethnic Rakhine and Muslim Rohingya communities erupted in early June and have left at least 78 people dead and 70,000 homeless, according to official figures.
Unofficial estimates of the death toll were higher, the UN said.
Muslim holocast in barma
ISRAELIS have often complained that whenever a Palestinian is killed,
the story is carried by the media across the Islamic world. But when a
Muslim is slain by a fellow Muslim, nobody pays attention. There is some
truth in this charge: Palestine has come to occupy such a focal point
in the Muslim sense of identity that reminders of the Israeli occupation
feed into a constant feeling of collective outrage.
It is very human to be selective in our sympathy: with all the suffering around the world, it would take a saint to grieve equally for all the victims of injustice. So we pick and choose according to our views, beliefs and proximity. It would be fair to say that the average Pakistani feels little for, say, the native tribes being virtually wiped out due to land clearing along the Amazon.
For the same reason, the plight of the Myanmar Muslim Rohingyas does not strike a chordin much of the Muslim world. The recent outbreak of violence against them by the majority Buddhists was reported widely last month, but the story has virtually disappeared from the media. It wasn`t till the Taliban threatened action against Burmese interests that we paid attention again.
The fact is that until last month`s slaughter, few of us were even aware of the substantial Muslim population of 800,000 in Myanmar. The image of the country has always been that of a predominantly Buddhist one, with the courageous Nobel Peace Prize winner, Aung San Suu Kyi, being the face of Burma.
However, the fact is that the Rohingyas have been subjected to persecution for decades.
According to Amnesty International, some 200, 000 of them fled to Bangladesh in 1978 to escape a brutal military operation. This was followed by anotherwave of around 250,000 in 199192. The refugees complained of rape, persecution and forced labour by the military. Another 100,000 fled to Thailand, but were forced to leave for camps along the border with Myanmar.
The Muslim presence in Myanmar goes back to the 8th century, when Arab merchants and sailors set up settlements along the coast. Later, in the 15th century, a king from the independent kingdom of Arakan sought help from the neighbouring state of Bengal. For centuries after these early contacts, there was no check on movement between the two neighbouring states. When the British took over Burma, as it was then known as, they encouraged Muslim farmers from Bengal to move to the underpopulated valleys of Arakan.
Now, virtually the entire Rohingya population of Myanmar is viewed as having entered illegally, and is denied basic humanrights. As the recent massacre shows, they have a very precarious existence, and are deeply resented by the majority Buddhists. Since Buddhism is a religion that teaches its followers to walk the path of non-violence and tolerance, outsiders assume that Buddhists are essentially peaceful people. Sadly, this is just not so. Over the last decade, I have spent at least a couple of months a year in Sri Lanka, another Buddhist country. While I have mostly enjoyed being there, I have been very conscious of a violent streak running just below the surface.
During the vicious civil war between the Tamil Tigers and the Sri Lankan state fought over a quarter of a century, many terrible atrocities were committed by both sides. The last few days of the war, in particular, saw horrors seldom matched in modern warfare.
It is feared that as many as 80,000 Tamil civilians were killed in theclosing stages of the separatist conflict.
To try and understand how devout Buddhists could justify any kind of killing, I asked Sri Lankan friends to explain the contradiction. According to several of them, Buddhist monks had issued their version of a fatwa to the effect that violence was justified in defence of the Buddhist homeland.
Indeed, the Buddhist clergy in Sri Lanka were the most rigid opponents to a negotiated settlement. They set up their own political party, and were part of the coalition government that rejected any compromise. Had it not been for the intransigence shown by these monks, it is just possible that the civil war could have been ended without so much bloodshed.
But even apart from this kind of organised warfare, there is much domestic violence and public brutality in evidence. Many politicalopponents have been killed, kidnapped and beaten up over the years. Thus, for all the rosy-hued images of peaceful, gentle people projected abroad, Buddhist states seldom live up to their billing.
Thailand is another Buddhist country where the government has no compunctions about putting down opposition with great force. This is as true of Muslim separatists in the southern provinces as of Buddhist supporters of political opponents of the previous junta.
More often than not, Buddhist monks play the same kind of role clerics do in Muslim countries.
Fanning the flames of religious intolerance and rabid nationalism, they both equate political differences with treachery and even apostasy. Instead of advocating peace and harmony, they teach messages of hate and fanaticism.
Neither of them can win elections on their own as their followers seldom vote for them. To makeup for this lack of popularity, they push their agendas in the streets, in mosques and in temples. All too often, they lend their support to oppressive regimes.
And yet the teachings of Lord Buddha have left a lasting impact: in Sri Lanka, wildlife is largely doing well because hunting is banned. Nevertheless, wild elephants are often killed by villagers for damaging crops. But to its credit, the Sri Lankan government has established over a score of national parks across the island where all kinds of wild animals and birds are protected.
Now that Myanmar is edging towards more representative government, we can hope that Aung San Suu Kyi`s towering moral authority will make it possible for the state to accommodate the unfortunate Rohingyas. However, her stand has not been encouraging for thus far, she has not condemned the violence against them in unequivocal terms.
It is very human to be selective in our sympathy: with all the suffering around the world, it would take a saint to grieve equally for all the victims of injustice. So we pick and choose according to our views, beliefs and proximity. It would be fair to say that the average Pakistani feels little for, say, the native tribes being virtually wiped out due to land clearing along the Amazon.
For the same reason, the plight of the Myanmar Muslim Rohingyas does not strike a chordin much of the Muslim world. The recent outbreak of violence against them by the majority Buddhists was reported widely last month, but the story has virtually disappeared from the media. It wasn`t till the Taliban threatened action against Burmese interests that we paid attention again.
The fact is that until last month`s slaughter, few of us were even aware of the substantial Muslim population of 800,000 in Myanmar. The image of the country has always been that of a predominantly Buddhist one, with the courageous Nobel Peace Prize winner, Aung San Suu Kyi, being the face of Burma.
However, the fact is that the Rohingyas have been subjected to persecution for decades.
According to Amnesty International, some 200, 000 of them fled to Bangladesh in 1978 to escape a brutal military operation. This was followed by anotherwave of around 250,000 in 199192. The refugees complained of rape, persecution and forced labour by the military. Another 100,000 fled to Thailand, but were forced to leave for camps along the border with Myanmar.
The Muslim presence in Myanmar goes back to the 8th century, when Arab merchants and sailors set up settlements along the coast. Later, in the 15th century, a king from the independent kingdom of Arakan sought help from the neighbouring state of Bengal. For centuries after these early contacts, there was no check on movement between the two neighbouring states. When the British took over Burma, as it was then known as, they encouraged Muslim farmers from Bengal to move to the underpopulated valleys of Arakan.
Now, virtually the entire Rohingya population of Myanmar is viewed as having entered illegally, and is denied basic humanrights. As the recent massacre shows, they have a very precarious existence, and are deeply resented by the majority Buddhists. Since Buddhism is a religion that teaches its followers to walk the path of non-violence and tolerance, outsiders assume that Buddhists are essentially peaceful people. Sadly, this is just not so. Over the last decade, I have spent at least a couple of months a year in Sri Lanka, another Buddhist country. While I have mostly enjoyed being there, I have been very conscious of a violent streak running just below the surface.
During the vicious civil war between the Tamil Tigers and the Sri Lankan state fought over a quarter of a century, many terrible atrocities were committed by both sides. The last few days of the war, in particular, saw horrors seldom matched in modern warfare.
It is feared that as many as 80,000 Tamil civilians were killed in theclosing stages of the separatist conflict.
To try and understand how devout Buddhists could justify any kind of killing, I asked Sri Lankan friends to explain the contradiction. According to several of them, Buddhist monks had issued their version of a fatwa to the effect that violence was justified in defence of the Buddhist homeland.
Indeed, the Buddhist clergy in Sri Lanka were the most rigid opponents to a negotiated settlement. They set up their own political party, and were part of the coalition government that rejected any compromise. Had it not been for the intransigence shown by these monks, it is just possible that the civil war could have been ended without so much bloodshed.
But even apart from this kind of organised warfare, there is much domestic violence and public brutality in evidence. Many politicalopponents have been killed, kidnapped and beaten up over the years. Thus, for all the rosy-hued images of peaceful, gentle people projected abroad, Buddhist states seldom live up to their billing.
Thailand is another Buddhist country where the government has no compunctions about putting down opposition with great force. This is as true of Muslim separatists in the southern provinces as of Buddhist supporters of political opponents of the previous junta.
More often than not, Buddhist monks play the same kind of role clerics do in Muslim countries.
Fanning the flames of religious intolerance and rabid nationalism, they both equate political differences with treachery and even apostasy. Instead of advocating peace and harmony, they teach messages of hate and fanaticism.
Neither of them can win elections on their own as their followers seldom vote for them. To makeup for this lack of popularity, they push their agendas in the streets, in mosques and in temples. All too often, they lend their support to oppressive regimes.
And yet the teachings of Lord Buddha have left a lasting impact: in Sri Lanka, wildlife is largely doing well because hunting is banned. Nevertheless, wild elephants are often killed by villagers for damaging crops. But to its credit, the Sri Lankan government has established over a score of national parks across the island where all kinds of wild animals and birds are protected.
Now that Myanmar is edging towards more representative government, we can hope that Aung San Suu Kyi`s towering moral authority will make it possible for the state to accommodate the unfortunate Rohingyas. However, her stand has not been encouraging for thus far, she has not condemned the violence against them in unequivocal terms.
Pakistan`s institutional lapse helps India complete water projects
ISLAMABAD, July 29: Having been officially informed about India`s intentions to avail itself of the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) benefits from Nimoo-Bazgo and Chutak Hydroelectric Power Projects, Pakistan has decided not to move the international legal system because a committee to investigate an institutional lapse stands dissolved.
An inquiry conducted by Wapda secretary Mohammad Imtiaz Tajwar has found that the Indian commissioner of Indus waters (ICIW) had informed his Pakistani counterpart that `India will be availing CDM benefits from Nimoo-Bazgo project`.
The decision not to challenge in the international court of arbitration a verdict of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) to grant carbon credits to India on a controversial hydropower project without mandatory clearance of its trans-boundary environmental impact assessment follows completion of the two projects a few weeks ago by India without any fanfare to avoid media attention.
`The two projects (Nimoo-Bazgo and Chutak) are complete, producing electricity and contributing to the Indian energy system,` a source confirmed to Dawn requesting anonymity because of his official position.
The decision not to go ahead with the international arbitration was also based on a premise that the projects had became a fait accompli and any court or arbitrator would unlikely to decide against an engineering project that has been completed and built for public interest.The source said that while the Pakistan commissioner of Indus waters (PCIW) had come under too much focus, the government agencies, ministries and a couple of inquiry committees did not examine the negligence or connivance of former secretaries of water and power, environment and foreign affairs who did not take steps to stop India from completing the projects without trans-boundary impact assessment.
The inquiry report said the information about the Nimoo-Bazgo project had been received in 2002. India was asked through letters in 2002-2004 which suggested that the `PCIW was in knowledge of the issue and could have approached the authorities to approach court of arbitration or neutral experts at that stage.
However, that initiative was not availed and the opportunity was missed`.
It said the intelligence agencies had been providing sufficient information about the Nimoo-Bazgo project but proper objections were not raised and opportunities to approach international courts should have been utilised between 2002 and 2005. On the other hand, it was continuously reported in the media until 2010 but the `PCIW never asked Indian commissioner regarding the awaited reply from Indian side or raising the project or raising the issue of carbon credit benefits which were disputed aspects in all aspects`.The inquiry report said a few years were lost during the course of deliberations between the ministries of law and justice, foreign affairs, water and power and the prime minister`s secretariat to take up the issue at the international level.
Officials said another inquiry committee had stood dissolved following retire-ment of its head a few months ago and his replacement had not yet been made while other members of the committee had been transferred.
Wapda secretary Mohammad Imtiaz Tajwar, who was appointed an inquiry officer by the ministry of water and power, confirmed a Dawn report of July 2010 that India had secured carbon credits for the controversial 45-MW NimooBazgo hydropower project from the UNFCCC without mandatory clearance of its impact assessment from Pakistan.
India applied for carbon credits for the project which was a `long-term process and must have spread over 4-5 years`, the inquiry officer wrote. `It is still not established how India was able to get carbon credit benefits for the Nimoo-Bazgo project which is located on trans-boundary water and for which ratification of the parties concerned should have been procured beforehand by it under clause 37(b) of UNFCCC. Although it is too difficult to get carbon credits on a trans-boundary project such as Nimoo-Bazgo, due to lack of contest by PCIW, India was able to get the credits on the project,` he said.
In December 2010, the ministry of foreign affairs said there were enough credible ground to refer the project to a neutral expert or the court of arbitration, but it was obvious that the project was at the stage of fait accompli, not due to India`s design but because of carelessness of the Pakistan side and it was difficult now to get a favourable outcome from arbitration. It remained, however, unclear why the ministries of law and foreign affairs and other related institutions failed to know about the Indian success at the UNFCCC during the carbon credit approval process of four to five years.
An inquiry conducted by Wapda secretary Mohammad Imtiaz Tajwar has found that the Indian commissioner of Indus waters (ICIW) had informed his Pakistani counterpart that `India will be availing CDM benefits from Nimoo-Bazgo project`.
The decision not to challenge in the international court of arbitration a verdict of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) to grant carbon credits to India on a controversial hydropower project without mandatory clearance of its trans-boundary environmental impact assessment follows completion of the two projects a few weeks ago by India without any fanfare to avoid media attention.
`The two projects (Nimoo-Bazgo and Chutak) are complete, producing electricity and contributing to the Indian energy system,` a source confirmed to Dawn requesting anonymity because of his official position.
The decision not to go ahead with the international arbitration was also based on a premise that the projects had became a fait accompli and any court or arbitrator would unlikely to decide against an engineering project that has been completed and built for public interest.The source said that while the Pakistan commissioner of Indus waters (PCIW) had come under too much focus, the government agencies, ministries and a couple of inquiry committees did not examine the negligence or connivance of former secretaries of water and power, environment and foreign affairs who did not take steps to stop India from completing the projects without trans-boundary impact assessment.
The inquiry report said the information about the Nimoo-Bazgo project had been received in 2002. India was asked through letters in 2002-2004 which suggested that the `PCIW was in knowledge of the issue and could have approached the authorities to approach court of arbitration or neutral experts at that stage.
However, that initiative was not availed and the opportunity was missed`.
It said the intelligence agencies had been providing sufficient information about the Nimoo-Bazgo project but proper objections were not raised and opportunities to approach international courts should have been utilised between 2002 and 2005. On the other hand, it was continuously reported in the media until 2010 but the `PCIW never asked Indian commissioner regarding the awaited reply from Indian side or raising the project or raising the issue of carbon credit benefits which were disputed aspects in all aspects`.The inquiry report said a few years were lost during the course of deliberations between the ministries of law and justice, foreign affairs, water and power and the prime minister`s secretariat to take up the issue at the international level.
Officials said another inquiry committee had stood dissolved following retire-ment of its head a few months ago and his replacement had not yet been made while other members of the committee had been transferred.
Wapda secretary Mohammad Imtiaz Tajwar, who was appointed an inquiry officer by the ministry of water and power, confirmed a Dawn report of July 2010 that India had secured carbon credits for the controversial 45-MW NimooBazgo hydropower project from the UNFCCC without mandatory clearance of its impact assessment from Pakistan.
India applied for carbon credits for the project which was a `long-term process and must have spread over 4-5 years`, the inquiry officer wrote. `It is still not established how India was able to get carbon credit benefits for the Nimoo-Bazgo project which is located on trans-boundary water and for which ratification of the parties concerned should have been procured beforehand by it under clause 37(b) of UNFCCC. Although it is too difficult to get carbon credits on a trans-boundary project such as Nimoo-Bazgo, due to lack of contest by PCIW, India was able to get the credits on the project,` he said.
In December 2010, the ministry of foreign affairs said there were enough credible ground to refer the project to a neutral expert or the court of arbitration, but it was obvious that the project was at the stage of fait accompli, not due to India`s design but because of carelessness of the Pakistan side and it was difficult now to get a favourable outcome from arbitration. It remained, however, unclear why the ministries of law and foreign affairs and other related institutions failed to know about the Indian success at the UNFCCC during the carbon credit approval process of four to five years.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

